Problem with diy speakers

As both speakers had identical issue and now sound fine I believe the poster when he says the fix was reversing the woofer connections.
Having experienced this issue myself as described in my last post, I would have found the symptoms difficult to describe. Without first turning down the volume, I jumped out of my skin when I swapped the dodgy speakers for a properly working pair, such was the difference in sound level. Quiet - LOUD!
 
Glad you fixed them.

Many years ago I bought then returned a pair of speakers from Richer Sounds.
No matter how loud I turned the amp the sound was quiet and muddied.

Looking back I am convinced it must have left the factory with drivers wired opposite phase.
I didn't know then but it would have been easy to test as it had separate woofer & tweeter binding posts for bi-wiring. I was using single speaker cabling & linked the posts as intended, red to red, black to black.

I the 70s a friend bought a pair of Marsden-Hall speakers, and I pointed out that the mid and tweeter connections on one had been connected to the wrong O/Ps of the Xover - mid energy going to tweeter, and tweeter energy to mid, and he hadn't noticed.