Princeton Reverb - Distortion at low volume/not decay

Hey guys. I just built a Mojotone Princeton Reverb and it has this very subtle fuzzy distortion at low volumes when the notes are decaying. It's strange because I used metal film resistors and all of the voltages in the whole amp are within less than 10% of the schematic.

The only mods to the stock design are:

Added grid stoppers and screen resistors to the 6V6s
Added switchable negative feeback using the ground switch. Cable is shielded.
470k resistor on the PI grid.

Here's what I've tried so far and nothing has fixed it:

I have pulled the reverb driver tube.
Adjusted the output tube bias hotter and cooler.
Swapped all tubes.
Tried the Paul C mod.
Swapped speakers.
Plugged in the amp in a different building.

My oscilloscope decided to die, so I can't track it down. Does anyone have any ideas as to what it is and what might cause it? Or is this normal and I'm just obsessing?

I'll add that the amp sounds very nice the louder it gets. It's just the very tail end of decays at low volume that bug me. Gets crunchy.
 
The symptom makes me think crossover distortion. First thing I would do after answering PRR's questions would be to measure part values and voltages around the output tubes to get a picture of what's happening there.

Also, you mentioned you made the negative feedback switchable — does switching it on reduce the problem? That would offer clues about which stage it comes from.
 
A few photos of the layout.
 

Attachments

  • 37A8AD2D-422A-4EBE-BDDB-CEB5B5E5C8F2.jpg
    37A8AD2D-422A-4EBE-BDDB-CEB5B5E5C8F2.jpg
    886.7 KB · Views: 103
  • DAEBB4BF-70CB-4FE7-9A4B-526242434988.jpg
    DAEBB4BF-70CB-4FE7-9A4B-526242434988.jpg
    898.6 KB · Views: 101
This has a resonant sound that seems to get louder on some notes than others, which makes me think something is physically rattling. My first guess would be a microphonic tube — I've had them sound exactly like this — but you say you've swapped them out. Still, get a chopstick and lightly tap each of the tubes while the amp is on to see if one of them makes noise. You might also try tapping the components in the circuit with the chopstick (one hand behind your back, carefully) while you're at it, though I'd expect bad connections probably would sound different. If none of them are to blame, I'd start to wonder whether the sound is coming from somewhere other than the speaker, maybe metal parts somewhere that aren't quite secure. One way to check that would be to try using a speaker mounted in a separate cabinet, if you have one handy.

Nice playing, by the way!
 
Last edited: