Perfect Step Response

Status
This old topic is closed. If you want to reopen this topic, contact a moderator using the "Report Post" button.
Jump to Latest
A

ackcheng

Member
Joined 2003
I wonder if anyone of you when designing speaker aiming to get a perfect step response.

Stereophile: Measuring Loudspeakers, Part Two

Sure a perfect step response means time coherent which is a good thing, but are the majority of the speakers out there has a lousy step response curve?

JA made this comment on Stereo web page "This is also my view. Of the 350 or so loudspeakers I have measured, there is no correlation between whether or not they are time-coherent and whether or not they are recommended by a Stereophile reviewer."

But of course, there are more than sound that put an equiptment on stereophile recommended list. And I do not fully trust these guys who has a conflict of interest anyway. but still, it is not difficult for a maufacturer to build a speaker with better step response, so why not?
 
Last edited:
L

LineArray

Member
Joined 2008
dipol-audio.de
I also think, if you optimize a multiway for
perfect step response there will be a price to
pay.

Using 1st order crossovers may cause many
problems like

- tweeter distorsion
- wide crossover range
- woofers contributing to the direct sound while
driven far above their pistonic frequency range.
(resonances, lobing, beaming)

If one decides to make use of first order filters,
the whole design has to overcome those
restrictions.

Typically the quality of the drivers to be used
has to meet further criteria than with higher order
filters.

In my personal opinion the best crossover is not
the simplest possible one, but one that accounts
for the most important tasks of compensation,
also having a balanced energy frequency response
in mind.

Kind Regards
 
Vil

Vil

Member
Joined 2003
LineArray said:
I also think, if you optimize a multiway for
perfect step response there will be a price to
pay.

Using 1st order crossovers may cause many
problems like

- tweeter distorsion
- wide crossover range
- woofers contributing to the direct sound while
driven far above their pistonic frequency range.
(resonances, lobing, beaming)

If one decides to make use of first order filters,
the whole design has to overcome those
restrictions.

Typically the quality of the drivers to be used
has to meet further criteria than with higher order
filters.

In my personal opinion the best crossover is not
the simplest possible one, but one that accounts
for the most important tasks of compensation,
also having a balanced energy frequency response
in mind.

Kind Regards
Click to expand...


Its possible to use FIR linear phase xovers up to 96dB/oct with digital delay on some drivers if needed. And it works very good ....
 
Status
This old topic is closed. If you want to reopen this topic, contact a moderator using the "Report Post" button.
Top Bottom