Need a opamp suggestion to replace a NJM4558D

Status
Not open for further replies.
Hello

I have those image and the specs sheets. The cxd2500, the tda1541 and the cxd2500 connect to the sm5840.

Gaetan

An externally hosted image should be here but it was not working when we last tested it.


An externally hosted image should be here but it was not working when we last tested it.
 

Attachments

  • cxd2500-sm5840.jpg
    cxd2500-sm5840.jpg
    64.7 KB · Views: 303
Hello

As usual I did a small search, there is I2S and EIAJ standard, CXD2500 controller do have an EIAJ output. I would need to convert EIAJ to I2S if I want to use the TDA1541. So it seem that I can't use the TDA1541 in non-oversampling with a CXD2500, since the SM5840 are an oversampling chip.

Gaetan
 
Hi Gaetan,
Would you have some CS8414 or CS8412 ic, they are hard to find in Canada.
Yes they are, and no I don't. Try to dig up a non-working CD player that uses those chips that you want. That's what I would do.
So it seem that I can't use the TDA1541 in non-oversampling with a CXD2500
I don't understand why not. Some of the newer filters are much better than the old ones. The TDA1541 will accept data at a pretty fast rate I think. You do not want to use those old 7 th order analog filters. Believe me - you don't. You really do not want to send the audio into anything without filtering it either. Many reasons for this.
since the SM5840 are an oversampling chip.
Yes, it's a good one.

Of course you could try to take your signal out before the digital filter, the CXD2500 and process it that way.

This bit about non-oversampling is silly. It forces you into analog brick wall filters and they are no fun. You should see many early filters. You see L-C compound filters (tuned) and potted precision filer "jungle chips". Then you are stuck with whatever op amp they used because you can't get to it. Build your own? Nah. Not a chance.

1 bit, now that I don't like the sound of either.

-Chris
 
Hello

Maby the SM5840 could be good since they said that there is no group delay, so it should be linear in phase ?

If I remember correct, the TDA1541 are better sounding than the PCM61, I think so ??

There is so much talk about the better sounding of non-oversampling dac, it's hard to know what really going on.

Gaetan
 

Attachments

  • sm5840-filter.jpg
    sm5840-filter.jpg
    88.4 KB · Views: 244
NJM4558D

Gaetan
The TDA154 as implemented in the earlier Philip/Marantz CD players can sound very good indeed when oversampled, and the multibit ladder capacitors replaced by quality units. Then you need to null the DC current of around 1.8mA going into the next stage so that you don't have DC out at half rail voltage, then better opamps etc. The list goes on and on. I went through all this years ago with an old Marantz CD65. Believe me, you really don't want to go there !Then of course is the sad fact that virtually all the remaining TDA1541s are second rate. They were graded into different grades. The very best ones can fetch much more than $1,000 , if anyone is willing to part with them (Golden Dragon, or something like that)
Chris has given some very good advice in his previous posting. Especially, the VERY BOTTOM line.

SandyK
 
Re: NJM4558D

sandyK said:
Gaetan
The TDA154 as implemented in the earlier Philip/Marantz CD players can sound very good indeed when oversampled, and the multibit ladder capacitors replaced by quality units. Then you need to null the DC current of around 1.8mA going into the next stage so that you don't have DC out at half rail voltage, then better opamps etc. The list goes on and on. I went through all this years ago with an old Marantz CD65. Believe me, you really don't want to go there !Then of course is the sad fact that virtually all the remaining TDA1541s are second rate. They were graded into different grades. The very best ones can fetch much more than $1,000 , if anyone is willing to part with them (Golden Dragon, or something like that)
Chris has given some very good advice in his previous posting. Especially, the VERY BOTTOM line.

SandyK

Hello

Have you compared the TDA1541 vs the PCM61 ?

I allready have some new 10 years old TDA1541 , I did have them directly from Phillips Canada.

Gaetan
 
NJM4558D

Gaetan
No, I haven't compared them. Perhaps you could be better off wiring for SPDIF and feeding into a good DAC, either purchased, or from one of the Diy kits. I have no expertise in the Diy kit area.
I fear that you may be getting well out of your depth with these
ambitious plans.
SandyK
 
OPA2604 Dual

I agree with Colin, the Burr Brown OPA2604 (Dual) will simply fit in place without oscilation problem. Removing the 2(two) SMD type muting transistors also will add clarity however will create click noise when powering on and off - to cure this noise switched off the Power Amp before switch off the CD and switch on the CD first before the Power Amp. Also replace the out put capacitor C429 and C438 with Tantalum (cheaper) or Black Gate NX series (expensive).
 
Hi Gaetan,
As Sandy said ...
I fear that you may be getting well out of your depth with these
ambitious plans.
I tend to agree with him. Before leaping off with this, you may really benefit from doing some reading in the digital section. Try to avoid the FAD stuff.

Personally I much prefer the BB PCM1702 DA converter. For what it's worth, I feel you lose too much when using an external DAC via toslink or RCA. So if you can find a way to tie the new converter in, then do it that way. I've been wanting to do some of this, but I haven't yet. I don't know enough to do a good job.

-Chris
 
anatech said:
Hi Gaetan,
As Sandy said ...

I tend to agree with him. Before leaping off with this, you may really benefit from doing some reading in the digital section. Try to avoid the FAD stuff.

Personally I much prefer the BB PCM1702 DA converter. For what it's worth, I feel you lose too much when using an external DAC via toslink or RCA. So if you can find a way to tie the new converter in, then do it that way. I've been wanting to do some of this, but I haven't yet. I don't know enough to do a good job.

-Chris

Hello

BB PCM1702 DA converter ?

I presume it is not pin compatible with my BB PCM61 DA converter ?

Is the BB PCM1702 are as good than the BB PCM63 DA converter ?


Gaetan
 
Hello

I did just found a CS8464 at a surplus store.

I did look in my old box of parts and I have also some TDA1541, AD1851. AD1865, AD1866, AD1892, DIR1701, AD825, and OPA627, that box was far under others box in the basement, I did buy them years ago but was not experiment enough to use them.

I've just received sample of THS4032

So one day I may do a nice DAC

Gaetan
 
Hello

After finishing the last modifications on my Denon DCM-420 cd player (adding 400 uf cap on the rails, very close to the Dac PCM61 chips), I did some tests.

To test the jitter, I did found a 16bit/44.1kHz JTEST signal wave file. Made of a 11025Hz square wave with 229.6875Hz LSB.

So I did burn a cd with that signal and use it with my Denon DCM-420 cd player, and I use my sound card and a FFT software, the result seem good since my Denon have a jitter at -90 db in relation with the 0 db 11025Hz signal.

For the distortion at very low level I did burn a cd with a -60 db sine wave made with Cool Edit 96, and using again my sound card and a FFT software, I did reajust the MSB of the PCM61, and it give a -47 db distortions at that very low level sine.

For the PCM61, the I/V op amp are inside the PCM61, that integrated op amp have 12 volt us slew rate, we can diconnect the op amp but I don't know if it's worth it to use an external I/V op amp ?

Gaetan
 
Status
Not open for further replies.