Hello,
I have designed a choke input power supply for the driver stage of a little se amp. That's mainly because I have a second ht winding and choke input would come in handy to drop the voltage + gives a very fast ps (much faster than just 'hanging' it behind the output stage ps with a many K resistor and cap)... I am worrying about the minimum current draw however. There doesn't seem to be a definitive formula (one textbook says a rule of thumb is Imin = V / H) - the driver stage draws approx. 3mA; so with 240v and 60H we'll get around 4mA Imin... Not quite enough...
Is there hope left for this configuration / did I forget something?
Is a choke input not suited for small current applications as fleapower set driverstages? 😕
Thanks!🙂
I have designed a choke input power supply for the driver stage of a little se amp. That's mainly because I have a second ht winding and choke input would come in handy to drop the voltage + gives a very fast ps (much faster than just 'hanging' it behind the output stage ps with a many K resistor and cap)... I am worrying about the minimum current draw however. There doesn't seem to be a definitive formula (one textbook says a rule of thumb is Imin = V / H) - the driver stage draws approx. 3mA; so with 240v and 60H we'll get around 4mA Imin... Not quite enough...

Is there hope left for this configuration / did I forget something?
Is a choke input not suited for small current applications as fleapower set driverstages? 😕
Thanks!🙂
The quick answer is: NO.
A formula I always used is from Schade, given in "Radio Designer's Handbook" by F. Langford-Smith, chapter 30.3, equation (1). That states that for full-wave amplification and low current:
L should be equal to/greater than RL/6.pi.f
This translates to L = RL/940 for a 50 Hz supply (or L greater than...). [RL = total load on power supply]
Your rule-of-thumb is thus quite close. In your case RL appears to be 80K, which would indicate a minimum L of 85H. Thus an LC filter is never really economical for low current applications and hardly practical, where the disadvantages of a C-input filter (e.g. high peak charging current etc.) is minimal, and large serie resistors are practical.
How do you define a "fast" ps? (There is not much difference, for the same ripple, between an LC and a CLC filter, or for that matter a CRC, unless you mean something not in evidence here.)
A formula I always used is from Schade, given in "Radio Designer's Handbook" by F. Langford-Smith, chapter 30.3, equation (1). That states that for full-wave amplification and low current:
L should be equal to/greater than RL/6.pi.f
This translates to L = RL/940 for a 50 Hz supply (or L greater than...). [RL = total load on power supply]
Your rule-of-thumb is thus quite close. In your case RL appears to be 80K, which would indicate a minimum L of 85H. Thus an LC filter is never really economical for low current applications and hardly practical, where the disadvantages of a C-input filter (e.g. high peak charging current etc.) is minimal, and large serie resistors are practical.
How do you define a "fast" ps? (There is not much difference, for the same ripple, between an LC and a CLC filter, or for that matter a CRC, unless you mean something not in evidence here.)
Klimon said:Is a choke input not suited for small current applications as fleapower set driverstages? 😕
I'm afraid you've pretty well summed it up there. Choke input is better for higher current demands.
Just a thought: You could burn a few mills of current in a suitable resistor or low wattage light bulbs.
As long as the power transformer is capable of providing the increased current, its a valid design option.
HTH
Doug
As long as the power transformer is capable of providing the increased current, its a valid design option.
HTH
Doug
Thanks for the replies!
@Johan: I call the ps 'fast' because it reaches the B+ voltage very fast (= around 0,2 milliseconds versus maybe 0,4 for a 'slower' ps)...
Simon
@Johan: I call the ps 'fast' because it reaches the B+ voltage very fast (= around 0,2 milliseconds versus maybe 0,4 for a 'slower' ps)...
Simon
use a bleeder
Hallo Simon,
Yes, the solution has allready been given. Just ad a bleeder that will '' eat '' some extra current that is needed to make the power supply work as a real choke input. If the transformer can deliver the extra current it is not a problem to let the bleeder draw the same current as the pre-amp itself. De groeten, Eduard
Hallo Simon,
Yes, the solution has allready been given. Just ad a bleeder that will '' eat '' some extra current that is needed to make the power supply work as a real choke input. If the transformer can deliver the extra current it is not a problem to let the bleeder draw the same current as the pre-amp itself. De groeten, Eduard
Hallo Eduard,
Thanks for confirming that solution; I'll check it out - could be ideal
Zuidelijke groeten;
S.
Thanks for confirming that solution; I'll check it out - could be ideal

Zuidelijke groeten;
S.
choke-input rules
Hallo Simon,
Soon i will be ofline longtime but i will surely like to know about the results when i am back ( 13 January) will leave 23 november. De groeten, Eduard
Hallo Simon,
Soon i will be ofline longtime but i will surely like to know about the results when i am back ( 13 January) will leave 23 november. De groeten, Eduard
There is a book that clearly explains the answers to all of your questions regarding choke-input power supplies. Luckily, it is available online for free:
http://iweil.com/electronics/rectifiers/rectifier applications.pdf
Grab it while you can. It unfortunately seems to have disappeared from the OnSemi web site, and is an indespensible reference.
http://iweil.com/electronics/rectifiers/rectifier applications.pdf
Grab it while you can. It unfortunately seems to have disappeared from the OnSemi web site, and is an indespensible reference.
I find the free PSU Designer program from:
http://www.duncanamps.com/software.html
really useful for this kind of thing.
http://www.duncanamps.com/software.html
really useful for this kind of thing.
Charles Hansen said:There is a book that clearly explains the answers to all of your questions regarding choke-input power supplies.
I've just downloaded it and had a quick browse - it looks very good. Thanks for the tip!
That's a very nice guide from OnSemi, but the explanation of quantum theory of bands is cringe-inducing. What DO they teach people in engineering school?!?
- Status
- Not open for further replies.
- Home
- Amplifiers
- Tubes / Valves
- Min. current draw for choke input?