Measurements of Turntables/Record Players - in which Test Magazines to find

[tiefbassuebertr]

There are probably a wide range of audio/hifi magazines around the world (in many languages).

here some examples:
StereoNET Expands into NZ with Purchase of AudioEnz | StereoNET Australia - Hi Fi & Home Cinema News
SoundStage! Hi-Fi | SoundStageHiFi.com - SoundStageHiFi.com Equipment Reviews
MJ Magazine (formerly Musen to Jikken) - Yearly Index from 1924 - 2009 wanted
Stereo Sound ONLINE
Home Page | Hi-Fi Choice
https://www.whathifi.com
https://www.theabsolutesound.com
also there are online magazines, e. g.
https://www.audiophil-online.com
https://www.lowbeats.de

Which of these magazines also carry out measurements with regard to speed accuracy, SNR etc. ?

Obviously there aren't many of them. Even stereophile - go to
https://www.stereophile.com/content/lack-phono-measurements-stereophile
perform this only in individual cases like this very rare examples:
https://www.stereophile.com/content/linn-sondek-lp12-turntable-lingo-power-supply-measurements
https://www.stereophile.com/content/linn-lp-playing-system-measurements

It seems to be, that such measurements are usual at the u.s. magazine AUDIO - go to
https://static1.squarespace.com/sta...41acad/1489563683682/Plattenspieler+Audio.pdf

Any few measurements are to find the web:
https://www.audioasylum.com/message...ents-of-harmonic-distortion-from-my-turntable
https://www.woodsongaudio.com/service/thorens-td124-main-spindle-bearing-rebuild
https://stereo-magazine.com/review/sme-model-12-review

In old magazines like those in post #38-41 under
Overview from world's best historical and currently available electr/audio Magazines
so as in the magazine "l Audiophile" - go to
http://6bm8.lab.free.fr/Documentations/Revues/Audiophile/1977-1988/01/PHONO/PHONO.html
and
http://6bm8.lab.free.fr/Documentations/Revues/Audiophile/1977-1988/42/VERDIER/VERDIER.html
there are more measurement results to find.
Last both links are to find under
http://6bm8.lab.free.fr/Documentations/Revues/Audiophile/index-1977-1988.html

Thanks for advices to magazines with measurement results in their test reviews.

 

[Galu]

Hi-Fi News and Record Review measures speed error at 33.33rpm; time to audible stabilisation; Peak Wow/Flutter; Rumble (silent groove); Rumble (through bearing); Hum & Noise and power consumption.

For example: Thorens TD 148A Turntable Lab Report | Hi-Fi News

 

[duncan2]

Thanks for reminding me Hi-Fi News and Record Review is available online , I used to buy the magazine along with other well known UK audio magazines of the time.

I still miss the Hi-Fi Choice yearly books with full tests and graphs of cartridges-loudspeakers -turntables-amplifiers etc although I have some 1980,s versions ,even oscilloscope shots were displayed on the cartridges and full specifications as well as sound opinions from the relevant UK "golden ears ".

 

[Galu]

Yes Duncan, I treasure the 1985 and 1986 issues of the Hi-Fi Choice Best Buy Guides which I have retained.

I dig them out every now and again for a nostalgic reminder of how thoroughly and objectively turntables, loudspeakers etc. were reviewed in that era.

Hi-Fi World claims it is the only UK hi-fi magazine which has in-house testing.

Here's an example: Dual MTR-75 - p6 measured performance

 

[duncan2]

I clicked on it Galu and saw an old favourite an HP 3651A spectrum analyser , Stewart's of Reading is still selling them --£650.

Your right about in-house testing , the most well known UK public help website I was on has outsourced its testing and gone down market as has its magazine so don't rely on their choices now being the best.

 

[tiefbassuebertr]

Thanks for reminding me Hi-Fi News and Record Review is available online , I used to buy the magazine along with other well known UK audio magazines of the time.

I still miss the Hi-Fi Choice yearly books with full tests and graphs of cartridges-loudspeakers -turntables-amplifiers etc although I have some 1980,s versions ,even oscilloscope shots were displayed on the cartridges and full specifications as well as sound opinions from the relevant UK "golden ears ".

Very interesting.
Obviously hard to find in used condition.
Can you upload the cover image of the book issues from the 80's ?
Thank you very much.
P.S.: using keywords "HiFi Choice" and "yearbook" in Google provide only issues from the last years, unfortunately.

PS-II: What about magazines from Russian, China, Italy, France, Slovenia and Spain particularly for the wide range of currently manufactured record Player/Turntables ?

 

[duncan2]

Hi-Fi Choice 28 : Cartridges and Headphones. (1982): Amazon.co.uk: Colloms, Martin.: Books

I have that one and Cartridges & Accessories .

I see a 1980 one is on eBay -

403 Forbidden

 

[Galu]

Can you upload the cover image of the book issues from the 80's ?

Let's go back, way back, to 1977!

 

[tiefbassuebertr]

Thank you. Listed also on Amazon and Vinylengine
Hi-Fi Choice No.5: Turntables and Cartridges: Amazon.co.uk: Colloms, Martin: Books
Vinyl Engine -HI-FI CHOICE turntableS AND TONEARMS
Hi-Fi Choice Magazine 1980 No. 20 Cartridges and Headphones | eBay
Hi-Fi Choice 24 : Turntables and Tonearms. (1981): Amazon.co.uk: Colloms, Martin.: Books
I have save some images from cover - images of all issues are of interest as help for try to search.

 

[tiefbassuebertr]

Hi-Fi News and Record Review measures speed error at 33.33rpm; time to audible stabilisation; Peak Wow/Flutter; Rumble (silent groove); Rumble (through bearing); Hum & Noise and power consumption.

For example: Thorens TD 148A Turntable Lab Report | Hi-Fi News

The marked term is a good keyword for google
AVM Rotation R 5.3 Turntable Lab Report | Hi-Fi News
Dual CS 606 turntable Lab Report | Hi-Fi News
Pro-Ject 175 Vienna Philharmonic Recordplayer turntable Lab Report | Hi-Fi News
VPI HW-40 Anniversary Turntable Lab Report | Hi-Fi News
https://www.hifinews.com/content/sony-ps-fl7-turntable-lab-report
https://www.hifinews.com/content/revolver-turntable-lab-report
https://www.hifinews.com/content/acoustic-solid-wood-round-mpx-turntable-lab-report
https://www.hifinews.com/content/eat-b-sharp-turntable-lab-report
https://www.hifinews.com/content/bsr-bds-80-turntable-lab-report