Statistical regulator? Haven't heard about it, so I'm sure it's not in the 3rd edition. Wait, what?! I'm supposed to actually READ the 4th edition? 🙄
~Tom
~Tom
Actually, there's a LOT of new stuff on the topic of regulators and noise. I don't think anyone buys these books for the projects, the amps are shown as design exercises.
MJ's book, Tube CAD Journal is essentially everything you need to know whether it's basic or cutting edge tube business. If you need a book which describes whether you can tube roll a certain tube in a certain amp, then I can't help you.
The rest is personal preferences. As a physicist I love exact arithmetic expressions as given by Amos & Birkinshaw - "Television engineering, principles and practice". A nice book. But since I started to simulate the hell out of every circuit, you don't even need that 🙂
The rest is personal preferences. As a physicist I love exact arithmetic expressions as given by Amos & Birkinshaw - "Television engineering, principles and practice". A nice book. But since I started to simulate the hell out of every circuit, you don't even need that 🙂
Althoug, the Statistical regulator seems to me being much the here quite commonly used CSS-shunt with cascoded DN2540 jfet CSS and a zener-string (or gas tubes) shunt. Well explaied though. I must read it again.
True. It does help if you can read the schematic in the design exercises, though. 🙂
I recommend MJ's books to anyone interested in learning tube circuits. Those of us with a solid electronics background (but no vacuum tube knowledge) can skip directly to the description of how vacuum tubes work (Ch 2).
Those who are new to electronics should really work through Chapter 1 with a fine toothed comb until they understand the material and can apply it to actual circuits. I'm surprised MJ doesn't include a circuits analysis book in the recommended readings to Chapter 1. Something like Hayt & Kemmerly would seem an obvious choice.
I see now why I missed the "Statistical Regulator". Sorry. Stacking a bunch of zeners is not my cup of tea. I'd rather throw a control loop at the problem and have actual regulation. Each to their own, I guess.
~Tom
Last edited:
@SY: do you now if there are plans for releasing an updated version of the eBook version for the fools like myself who bought it? Would be great to read the diagrams properly...
Ale
Ale
No idea, sorry. My wife is a big e-book person, I personally never use them. My better electronics books and cookbooks are horribly stained and scarred, which would not be a good thing for a Kindle. 😀
You might contact Newnes?
You might contact Newnes?
Member
Joined 2009
Paid Member
Last year I got the chance to read the 3rd edition from a local library. I wanted to borrow it again but when it turned up it was the 4th edition so now I'm reading the latest. One thing I noticed was that he had a delayed turn-on power supply circuit in the 3rd edition which I can't find in the 4th edition. He does caution users of SS rectifiers for HT supply but does not suggest a delay-on circuit. Anybody know why ?
I remember reading at least one thread around here that explained that for most of the tubes we use, there is no issue applying HT before the heater is hot and that there is much misinformation to the contrary. I was sure hoping Morgan would have been clearer on this topic - or maybe I haven't read that bit yet ?
I remember reading at least one thread around here that explained that for most of the tubes we use, there is no issue applying HT before the heater is hot and that there is much misinformation to the contrary. I was sure hoping Morgan would have been clearer on this topic - or maybe I haven't read that bit yet ?
- Status
- Not open for further replies.