Help a Newcomer! Speaker Build

crossing from an 8inch driver to a 3-1/2 inch capable of playing up to 15kHz is a much better config for off-axis dispersion then going to a conventional 1inch tweeter.

This particular WAW by X has done a lot to populize the niche. There are man examples. It just makes so much more sense from a design POV — two are that the XO is moved to a place where it can be made less obnoxious, and the second is that you have a better distribution of the audio octves across the driver (and more equatable sharing of the power spectrum). Except that passive XOs use much bigger parts so cost more.

dave
 
Thanks again for all the responses. I am in firm belief that my first project has to be kit built.

I am in contact with Jantzen, discussing some of Troel Gravesen's designs - there are several that are interesting to me. The questions i have for the team is to what extent can i pretty up the cabinets from their designs. Some of them a fairly sterile IMO!!

Ive read his website and totally udenrstand someof the "rules" he puts in place but just trying to sound out the flexibility...

I am tossing up over the 8008 corner or the SEAS 3 Way classic mk II builds.

I have some ADAM Audio 5 inch minotors and some old Nuance 7-8 inch woofer two ways attached to the Sansui right now and i just love the warm boominess of the 7-8 woofer when compared to the ADAM monitors I need one in whatever i build.

If anyone else thinks i just whould look at another kit - im still open to ideas.

Thank you everyone for sharing your experiences. Really helps in the decision making process.
 
As long as you maintain driver position, baffle size, external and chamber dimensions, you can finish the speaker however you like.

I think Troels' 3 way classics are among his best designs, and would be inclined to those over a 2-way bookshelf. I think the Discovery Mk 2 + SBA 3WCs model to have more bass than the Seas version, and offer the best value versus the very expensive AudioTechnology and Satori versions.
 
Goodness, Apologies for the poor englihs in my last post. How reliant i am on spell check.

He makes a lot of mention around diffraction on the site and i just need to check if what i intend to do changes that piece at all.

Ill keep you posted on the project!