Gday guys,
I'm looking to make two identical pairs of speakers (one for me, one for my brother). They'll primarily be "party" speakers. so looking to design something that is relatively rugged.
I have four (4) peerless SLS 12" (830669) woofers that I'd like to use. As you can see in the datasheet they have a pretty big resonance at around 2k which I'll attenuate with a notch.
Peerless 830669 12" Paper Cone SLS Subwoofer 264-1118
What I'm looking for is a relatively cheap waveguide + compression driver that will happily crossover at around 1k to avoid the worst of this resonance. "Easy" I hear you all say, "just buy the selenium d220ti and the classic pyle waveguide used in the original econowave" to which I say, shipping those from America is STUPID expensive.
So I'm hoping to find something local (Australia) that would be suitable, without breaking the bank. I think these are the same as a Dayton 12" circular waveguide. If they're suitable then I just need to track down a screw-on 1" compression driver that will happily crossover at ~1k.
YD-L027 - HORN ABS RESIN 290X290X132 - Drivers / Tweeters / X-Overs - Accessories | DJ City
I'd appreciate any advice in tracking down a good waveguide-compression driver combination that would work in my situation.
Cheers, Westy.
I'm looking to make two identical pairs of speakers (one for me, one for my brother). They'll primarily be "party" speakers. so looking to design something that is relatively rugged.
I have four (4) peerless SLS 12" (830669) woofers that I'd like to use. As you can see in the datasheet they have a pretty big resonance at around 2k which I'll attenuate with a notch.
Peerless 830669 12" Paper Cone SLS Subwoofer 264-1118
What I'm looking for is a relatively cheap waveguide + compression driver that will happily crossover at around 1k to avoid the worst of this resonance. "Easy" I hear you all say, "just buy the selenium d220ti and the classic pyle waveguide used in the original econowave" to which I say, shipping those from America is STUPID expensive.
So I'm hoping to find something local (Australia) that would be suitable, without breaking the bank. I think these are the same as a Dayton 12" circular waveguide. If they're suitable then I just need to track down a screw-on 1" compression driver that will happily crossover at ~1k.
YD-L027 - HORN ABS RESIN 290X290X132 - Drivers / Tweeters / X-Overs - Accessories | DJ City
I'd appreciate any advice in tracking down a good waveguide-compression driver combination that would work in my situation.
Cheers, Westy.
Sounds fine!
The WG you linked looks like conical to me. Compression drivers want an exponential horn. There was a good link in another thread here... and it should be round, not square
The WG you linked looks like conical to me. Compression drivers want an exponential horn. There was a good link in another thread here... and it should be round, not square
Looking more closely at the photo it seems like you're right Juhazi, that waveguide is definitely conical. Bugger.
Well then, I'm open to ANY suggestions for a suitable combination that's available in AUS.
Well then, I'm open to ANY suggestions for a suitable combination that's available in AUS.
Conical is going to sound a lot better than exponential. Compression drivers don't care if they are on expos, tractrix, conical, hyperbolic....... Stay way from exponential horns. They are the ones that had the horn "honk". Have you looked at the eWave thread on Audio Karma. I think there was someone from Aus that built a pair.
Have you taken a look at the Pyle PH12s as a possible option?
Pyle PH12S Screw-On Constant Radiation Horn 292-2569
This is actually a Peavey driver used in the PV115 and the PV215 cabinets. The horns are inexpensive and reasonably well made though they will require a little file work to clean up the throats which are a little sharp off the mold. The Peavey RX14 is a great match to these horns and a 2K crossover would be easy to achieve just take a look here
Peavey RX14 Compression Driver by AmpsLab
The horns are made in China perhaps you can find the maker and buy directly? I hope that this is of interest. Best regards Moray James.
Pyle PH12S Screw-On Constant Radiation Horn 292-2569
This is actually a Peavey driver used in the PV115 and the PV215 cabinets. The horns are inexpensive and reasonably well made though they will require a little file work to clean up the throats which are a little sharp off the mold. The Peavey RX14 is a great match to these horns and a 2K crossover would be easy to achieve just take a look here
Peavey RX14 Compression Driver by AmpsLab
The horns are made in China perhaps you can find the maker and buy directly? I hope that this is of interest. Best regards Moray James.
you might also take a look at this horn.
PYLE PH515 NEW CONSTANT DIRECTIVITY HORN SCREW-ON TYPE WITH ABS GLASS FIBER | eBay
PYLE PH515 NEW CONSTANT DIRECTIVITY HORN SCREW-ON TYPE WITH ABS GLASS FIBER | eBay
Some great options in there guys, thanks for the suggestions. I'm still trying to find something local though. Stumbled upon these waveguides (the PH-3220). Do you think they'd work OK crossing over at 1k using this compression driver?
Waveguide (search for PH-3220 and open the pdf)
P.Audio Specifications Public Address Systems | Portable PA Systems | DJ Equipment & Lighting
Compression driver (search for BM-D450mkII and open the pdf)
P.Audio Specifications Public Address Systems | Portable PA Systems | DJ Equipment & Lighting
Any ideas on how their directivity control would be just by looking at a picture of the spec sheets and pictures of the two?
Waveguide (search for PH-3220 and open the pdf)
P.Audio Specifications Public Address Systems | Portable PA Systems | DJ Equipment & Lighting
Compression driver (search for BM-D450mkII and open the pdf)
P.Audio Specifications Public Address Systems | Portable PA Systems | DJ Equipment & Lighting
Any ideas on how their directivity control would be just by looking at a picture of the spec sheets and pictures of the two?
I can't get to the spec sheets, but I could tell you how well they would work just by looking at them. You need to post the data sheets however.
Hopefully this works and the datasheets are attached.
View attachment BM-D450mkII.pdf
View attachment PH2420_3220.pdf
View attachment BM-D450mkII.pdf
View attachment PH2420_3220.pdf
Some other options I have available to me.
gedlee, I'd really appreciate your input on the likely suitability of these!
View attachment PH220_170.pdf
View attachment PH3616_4220.pdf
View attachment PH230_2370.pdf
gedlee, I'd really appreciate your input on the likely suitability of these!
View attachment PH220_170.pdf
View attachment PH3616_4220.pdf
View attachment PH230_2370.pdf
Some impressive directivity graphs there from these SEOS waveguides but I'm really trying to source something locally (read "cheaply").
kevinh, do you have any insight into whether the above linked waveguides would be suitable?
kevinh, do you have any insight into whether the above linked waveguides would be suitable?
I'd use the PH220. I'd avoid P-audio drivers as I have not found them to be too reliable in data sheets or product. But all 1" compression drivers are pretty comparable at the lower end of the price spectrum. They are all just copies of the better companies designs. I know that B&C is available in Aus, but they may be pretty expensive.
No, special insight. the site has a forum where builders discuss the various kits and their own efforts, good information there.
My understanding is that they attempt to use the wave guide principles of Dr Geddes,
I haven't built any of these kits yet.
Last edited:
That's the claim, but I want to be clear that I was not consulted on any aspect of their design. I would do things quite a bit different.
- Status
- Not open for further replies.