Design rule not taught in school

To Marcel and Mark, in answer to a humourous...

How about this long-tail pair?
Until the tail current is steered into only one of the output legs to the onset of hard slewing, the gm is (almost) constant!
LTP.png
LTP2.png

😀
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bonsai
Another way of looking at this to feed a fast rise time square wave into the diff amp and then look at whether or not the diff pair switches ie one of the fief amp devices is driven into cutoff. Most diff amps will require degeneration - typically this will be 5x to 10x .026/Ie. If after degeneration the diff amp is still switching, an input bandwidth limiting filter is required - that’s usually set at 10x the audio bandwidth - so 200 kHz or higher.
 
Another design rule: always assume inputs will be corrupted by RF. Even suburbia can have many RF sources: cordless telephones, cell phones, wifi, leaky microwave ovens, and unbalanced cable shields are a wonderful way of letting RF into the box. My preference on all my gear is for XLR connectors on balanced lines with shields tied to chassis ground, no poxy RCAs allowed.

https://www.audiosciencereview.com/...pecially-of-the-lm4562-lme497x0-family.10687/
https://www.nationalgeographic.com/...-the-culprits-behind-mysterious-radio-signals
 
Another design rule: always assume inputs will be corrupted by RF. Even suburbia can have many RF sources
You don't say. There's a reason all my circuits have RFI filters on them. 🙂

This is the wifi environment as viewed from my backyard. Only two of those networks are mine. Granted, I live in "inner city" Calgary, which is a fairly broad term. I'm about 4-5 km from City Hall.

Screenshot 2024-09-24 at 10.29.19.png
 
DOH! I missed a DON'T in Post 31. This is why I hate double negatives.

What is taught in school is that lowpass filters have increasing attenuation in the stop band. That's not the case in reality.

I was thinking specifically of active filters where the loop gain of the opamp limits the stop band attenuation, but as Mark pointed out undesirable stop band performance is not limited to active filters.

Tom
 
  • Like
Reactions: Agent327
You don't say. There's a reason all my circuits have RFI filters on them. 🙂

This is the wifi environment as viewed from my backyard. Only two of those networks are mine. Granted, I live in "inner city" Calgary, which is a fairly broad term. I'm about 4-5 km from City Hall.

View attachment 1359903
Your own wifi and smartphones will generate much higher RF levels than a base station or outdoor access point, even if its fairly near.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tomchr
Another design rule not taught in school is to never use stainless steel for casings.
Why? Stainless steel is usually harder to work but it tends to stay prettier unpainted. It comes in fairly wide varieties allowing for more or less formablity, magnetic properties and of course corrosion resistance.

Most of the stainless I use is type 304 in sports facilities television broadcast cabling interconnect panels.

One time I was punching a piece of 1/8 thick stainless steel using a parting punch designed to punch 1/4” wide by 3” long slots. The first punch made a noise I haven’t heard before. So I stopped the machine and discovered even with 35 metric tons of force the punch wouldn’t go through the metal! A resharpening with a taper allowed the punch to work. The long term solution was to get a 2” long punch. (.018” die clearance.)
 
Enrico Fermi to his daughter Nella: "Never make something more accurate than necessary"

Fermi enraged fellow physicists by gravitating toward simple and direct explanations which were not elegant, but they were accurate. As a youth in Rome, he taught his college profs much of Einstein.

for more stuff on Fermi: "The Last Man Who Knew Everything"