I am wondering if there is any guidlines on how to to fill damping materials inside a bass reflex design.
1. Do you have to pad all 5 walls of the box? or just 3?
2. What is the density of material to use for damping?High vs Low
3. Is there any volume adjustments that need to be done for a damping pad of 2 inch thick?
1. Do you have to pad all 5 walls of the box? or just 3?
2. What is the density of material to use for damping?High vs Low
3. Is there any volume adjustments that need to be done for a damping pad of 2 inch thick?
1. 5 is the common method but in theory 3 would do.
2. That depend of what you mean by dense and light.
3. That depend on how much of the total volume that 2" layer makes .
2. That depend of what you mean by dense and light.
3. That depend on how much of the total volume that 2" layer makes .
First, use fiberglass. Other materials are not as good. Fiberglass is the pink stuff that is sold as insulation. It's itchy, so wear gloves. It's fibers are not good for your lungs, so wear a mask if you are going to play with it for long.
Yes, cover all sides with a couple of inches. It shouldn't cause a drastic change in box alignment. Depending on the box dimension, you may want to put a layer in the middle to absorb the longest standing wave. Read here for more:
http://www.diyaudio.com/forums/multi-way/215133-box-colourations-really-22.html#post3086482
Yes, cover all sides with a couple of inches. It shouldn't cause a drastic change in box alignment. Depending on the box dimension, you may want to put a layer in the middle to absorb the longest standing wave. Read here for more:
http://www.diyaudio.com/forums/multi-way/215133-box-colourations-really-22.html#post3086482
The fear of whatever is going to be caused by fiberglass is irrational. Yes, it is bad for the lungs. If you breath in a lot, you might get silicosis. That what the pharaohs died of. It is not a carcinogen, but use realistic protection while installing it.
No one has ever reported a yellow spot of the floor in front of their speakers. given a 2-3" or longer port there is no net are transport out of a port. Anything that dislodges from the stuffing/lining will be deposited in the bottom of that speaker. Yes, I have opened up an old MLTL and found a layer of yellow on the plinth. But noting ever actually exited the speaker.
Bob
No one has ever reported a yellow spot of the floor in front of their speakers. given a 2-3" or longer port there is no net are transport out of a port. Anything that dislodges from the stuffing/lining will be deposited in the bottom of that speaker. Yes, I have opened up an old MLTL and found a layer of yellow on the plinth. But noting ever actually exited the speaker.
Bob
Drboar total volume is going to be 0.25 or 0.35 cubic feet. So if there is 2 inch panells on 5 sides it may take up some volume?
Don't use lung damaging fibres in a vented box.
The air flow from the port will contaminate the air in the listening room.
I would not recommend lung damaging fibres in a sealed box either.
There are many other damping fibres available that are safe.
eg, long hair wool, BAF wadding, some types of open cell foam.
The air flow from the port will contaminate the air in the listening room.
I would not recommend lung damaging fibres in a sealed box either.
There are many other damping fibres available that are safe.
eg, long hair wool, BAF wadding, some types of open cell foam.
This type of damping is useless in a bass reflex box, because the velocity is zero at the walls. The vibration of the walls can be damped by bitumen pads, sorbothane etc.
I think we are getting deviated from topic.My concerns are more about the volume ,density and type of filling (resistive vs wall) than actual material.s you can see my box volume is small so wants to know how the wall damping is going to affect the volume.
The Loudspeaker designcook book 7th ed pages 80-83 for vented boxes says the lining the wall with even 50% thickness(3inch regular fiberglass) showed minimal changes in computer generated SPL and Impedence plots.But it will reduce standing waves.
Series Resistive vent model by filling(not lining) the box with fiberglass or Dacron can
Increase F3 from system
Reduce efficiency(output) of the system
Lower Qts
Increased cone excursion near cutoff.
At the end author recommends using straw filled vent ,which he explains as filling vent with rolled decorative corugated cardboard or bundle of plastic straw, which offers rather easly controllable way for trial and error.
Any one know how that can be done and what exactly it lookes like ?
I guess incresed F3 means higher roll off for bass frequencies(low bass)?
What is the effect of low Qts?
The Loudspeaker designcook book 7th ed pages 80-83 for vented boxes says the lining the wall with even 50% thickness(3inch regular fiberglass) showed minimal changes in computer generated SPL and Impedence plots.But it will reduce standing waves.
Series Resistive vent model by filling(not lining) the box with fiberglass or Dacron can
Increase F3 from system
Reduce efficiency(output) of the system
Lower Qts
Increased cone excursion near cutoff.
At the end author recommends using straw filled vent ,which he explains as filling vent with rolled decorative corugated cardboard or bundle of plastic straw, which offers rather easly controllable way for trial and error.
Any one know how that can be done and what exactly it lookes like ?
I guess incresed F3 means higher roll off for bass frequencies(low bass)?
What is the effect of low Qts?
The wall thickness is usually 1/2" to 1", take the half of it...
Neither of these is desirable.
Search for Aperiodic Enclosure, here are two random hits:
http://www.diyaudio.com/forums/multi-way/115810-how-should-we-model-aperiodic-boxes.html
http://www.diyaudio.com/forums/subwoofers/69741-how-do-i-design-aperiodic-sub-enclosure.html
Thank you oshifis.I guess those recommendations are for woofer inside a vented enclosure.What about a full range speaker inside a vented box?
I've been using Bonded Logic cotton house insulation with great success! Add and subtract to taste!
Larry
Larry
In this case stuffing does make sense, indeed. You have to find a good compromise between effectively damping wall reflexions and not overstuffing so that the LF response is affected too much. Although not a vented box, I stuffed the compression chamber behind the speaker in my full range horn with glass wool, and the sound became much less "raw".
- Status
- Not open for further replies.