I think, Jan Didden is the most close to the reason of oscillations: probaly half of all different scopes I have worked with oscillate with shorted probe and probe gnd when max (and near) Y scope sensitivity is selected. Such oscillation takes place wile measurements too.
I don't insist on I have worked with the best scopes, but it is a reality of my life 🙂.
I don't insist on I have worked with the best scopes, but it is a reality of my life 🙂.
Yes, I have observed that the oscillation went away when the amplifier power was disconnected. (I suppose there is still the possibility that it is picking something up.
Member
Joined 2002
I'm pretty sure the scope isn't the problem. It's a high end scope and seems to be immune to a lot of the problems that most scopes I've worked with have.
Member
Joined 2002
Duo said:I'm pretty sure the scope isn't the problem. It's a high end scope and seems to be immune to a lot of the problems that most scopes I've worked with have.
What kinda scope is it. ? what is the frequancy ? Could it be your probe's ?
The scope is a Tektronix 2247A with original probes that came with it.
I think I'll try it later with some of my other scopes; though I'm far more likely to believe it's the breadboard and not a scope problem.
I think I'll try it later with some of my other scopes; though I'm far more likely to believe it's the breadboard and not a scope problem.
You could contact the 'chief' amplifier engineer at Madrigal - he had a similar problem when I landed the revelation on him that LAYOUT MATTERED, after I advised a reroute of a Vas output PCB track away from the input diff'l pair on his rehash (of someone else's competent design) project amp. Immediately the THD dropped 2 orders of magnitude - to which he replied "Does layout matter?" . I asked "Who did the PCB layout?". "The draftsman!" "What criteria?" "Fit!?" He then asked how to do it. I explained that you need to identify all the sensitive low level areas/tracks and all the high current and voltage radiating tracks/blocks and keep them apart. "Can you identify them for me?". "Sure", I replied. I marked out the various sections of his 12" sq board and he hacksawed it up, connecting sections with 3-4" jumpers, fired it up while he moved the pieces around in 3D space!
Then it went up in flames and the engineering manager came racing out with a fire extinguisher and nuked it!
Seriously! You had to be there!
The *******s picked my brains for 4 months then didn't pay me!
Then it went up in flames and the engineering manager came racing out with a fire extinguisher and nuked it!
Seriously! You had to be there!
The *******s picked my brains for 4 months then didn't pay me!
Yes, I do understand that layout is of utmost importance in amplifiers. As I said, my PC boards work very very well, never any stability issues.
I tried this amplifier on the breadboard again at home today (I did the other one at the highschool) and this time it works perfectly as expected.
The only thing I did differently this time was spread the various stages of the amplifier farther apart. I also used a start ground instead of the rail in the breadboard. I found that 68pF was enough for the stabilization capacitor and the amplifier works well.
I still haven't determined exactly what the deal was with the 100MHz oscillation with the one at the school, but I intend to figure out the problem before I re-do the layout anyway. It would be interesting to know.
I tried this amplifier on the breadboard again at home today (I did the other one at the highschool) and this time it works perfectly as expected.
The only thing I did differently this time was spread the various stages of the amplifier farther apart. I also used a start ground instead of the rail in the breadboard. I found that 68pF was enough for the stabilization capacitor and the amplifier works well.
I still haven't determined exactly what the deal was with the 100MHz oscillation with the one at the school, but I intend to figure out the problem before I re-do the layout anyway. It would be interesting to know.
100Mhz is too high a frequency for a global feedback loop oscillation. It must be local oscillation across one or two transistors and breadboard capacitance is the most probable cause
As you have found, this is a layout issue
As you have found, this is a layout issue
- Status
- Not open for further replies.
- Home
- Amplifiers
- Solid State
- Amplifier oscillates at 100MHz