Another Idea of Balanced Moving Magnet Pre-amplifier

I don't have phono player but I like learn everything in audio electronic. I'm interested after reading balanced moving magnet (MM) pre-amplifier at Bob Cordell's website. Later I also read MM pre-amplifier by Scott Wurcer. They use JFET input in folded cascode topology. Bob Cordell's version: the equalization done in 2 ways. First, 75uS passive and other is active using op-amp. Scott Wurcer's version all equalization is passive. I choose all equalization passive because the signal level is very low. And I used only 2SK170 because my friend still have several pieces of this jfet and another friend have phono player, so I can test it someday.
I biased 2SK170 at 3,6mA because at this current the input voltage noise is minimum. I use diamond buffer to isolated the passive equalization. Gain about 38,5 dB at 1kHz and distortion is relative low because signal level is small.

Any suggestion are welcome.
 

Attachments

  • MM Balanced SCH.png
    MM Balanced SCH.png
    83 KB · Views: 960
  • MM Balanced FREQ.png
    MM Balanced FREQ.png
    44.2 KB · Views: 882
  • Balance MM phono 2SK170 v3.asc
    Balance MM phono 2SK170 v3.asc
    12.7 KB · Views: 203
I sim folded cascode pre-amplifier that can use after MM pre-amplifier or line pre-amplifier.
For input, i use 2SK117 which is easier to get than 2SK170. Compensation using two pole variant.
R44 to set output transistor about 7.29mA each or about 47mA from power supply. So it will work in class A for load impedance minimum 500 Ohm.
C15 can be shorted because DC offset can adjust using R61, but I'm not sure if JFET need to be matched or not.
Gain about 9.6 dB, low THD, high slew rate, high PSRR.
 

Attachments

  • Like
Reactions: inyashd
From me as well, nice circuit Bimo.

Suggestions... if I may, have a look at TI's new tightly matched ultra-low noise dual N-ch JFET (JFE2140) which is readily available from safe sources such as Digikey, Mouser and also directly from TI for a pretty attractive price bit under $5 each, TI has an even better price currently for ~$3.30.

https://www.ti.com/product/JFE2140/part-details/JFE2140DR
https://www.digikey.com/en/products/detail/JFE2140DR/296-JFE2140DRCT-ND/15666954
https://eu.mouser.com/ProductDetail/Texas-Instruments/JFE2140DR?qs=A6eO%2BMLsxmQVeRIGZCabaw==

Another dual JFET is LSK389 from Linear Systems, Digikey is nowadays distrubutor for LS, but it costs more than double.
https://linearsystems.com/product-spotlight.html
https://www.digikey.com/en/products/filter/transistors-jfets/288?s=N4IgTCBcDaIDIGUDSBmAHAThAXQL5A
 
  • Like
Reactions: inyashd
Suggestions... if I may, have a look at TI's new tightly matched ultra-low noise dual N-ch JFET (JFE2140) which is readily available from safe sources such as Digikey, Mouser and also directly from TI for a pretty attractive price bit under $5 each, TI has an even better price currently for ~$3.30.
Thank you.
For other JFETs, may be need to adjust drain current to achieve lowest input voltage noise. In simulation, you need change the value of R8 and R23.
 
if JFET need to be matched or not
Without source degeneration, it's better to match. Unbalance of J1/2 will unbalance Q3/4 and Q4 has a dc load of ~36kΩ. Less then 0.5 mA difference there will freeze that output to a rail.
Lower band phase shift occurs from 100Hz downwards. It's not from C4/R14 (2.5Hz). Or is the input signal an inverse riaa-sweep of some kind?
What signal level above 2 kHz upwards is at the Q4/6 collector node?
 
Lower band phase shift occurs from 100Hz downwards. It's not from C4/R14 (2.5Hz). Or is the input signal an inverse riaa-sweep of some kind?
What signal level above 2 kHz upwards is at the Q4/6 collector node?
This is the RIAA-reverse transfer function: Laplace=n*(1+T1*s)*(1+T3*s)/(1+T2*s)
And the output of frequency response is:
 

Attachments

  • resp.png
    resp.png
    7.4 KB · Views: 90