• WARNING: Tube/Valve amplifiers use potentially LETHAL HIGH VOLTAGES.
    Building, troubleshooting and testing of these amplifiers should only be
    performed by someone who is thoroughly familiar with
    the safety precautions around high voltages.

Bleeder resistor not needed for "pi" filter?

Jump to Latest
S

shan_rish

Member
Joined 2006
#1
Hi All,

I came across an article in audio express which states that bleeder resistor is not needed in a "pi" filter in the power supply section. Can anybody shed some light on this, since I am not able to understand what author meant. I always assumed that bleeder resistor is necessary to discharge high voltages in tube rectifier circuits.

The audio express link is: The 2A3 Tube Amplifier - A Tribute to Simplicity and Warm Sound | audioXpress

Thanks and Regards,
Shan
 
#3
> bleeder resistor is not needed in a "pi" filter

"single section “pi” filter or a “capacitor-input filter” with no need for a bleeder resistor."

No need because, as Allen says, the amplifier needs a heavy bleed to work.
 

Attachments

  • pi-bleed-42.gif
    pi-bleed-42.gif
    13.8 KB · Views: 340
#4
shan_rish said:
Hi All,

I came across an article in audio express which states that bleeder resistor is not needed in a "pi" filter in the power supply section. Can anybody shed some light on this, since I am not able to understand what author meant. I always assumed that bleeder resistor is necessary to discharge high voltages in tube rectifier circuits.

The audio express link is: The 2A3 Tube Amplifier - A Tribute to Simplicity and Warm Sound | audioXpress

Thanks and Regards,
Shan
Click to expand...


This design violates the conditions for the GZ34, maximum size of first cap
is 60uF. See https://frank.pocnet.net/sheets/010/g/GZ34.pdf
 
#5
It doesn't need a bleeder resistor because it t is a class A amplifier which is always conducting, not because it has a pi filter, and the article doesn't actually say otherwise. It says this design uses a pi-filter with no need for a bleeder resistor, but it doesn't link the two in a causation chain.
 
#10
Surviving spouses benefit from the lack of a bleeder resistor.
They get an inheritance.

Use a bleeder resistor and stay alive.
Calculate the time for discharge to a safe voltage (or remove the bottom plate very slowly, and check the voltage with a voltmeter before digging in).

Just imagine your amplifier 'dies' and you open it up.
Ahh, it was a dead output tube(s), and so the B+ still has high voltage, because you forgot to use a bleeder resistor.
Ouch!

Safety First!
 
#13
I have attached my amp's schematic and have drawn a redline of a path through which the bleeding might happen, even if the output tubes fail. Does anybody still think this amp's power supply needs a bleeder resistor, still?
 

Attachments

  • Bleeding path.png
    Bleeding path.png
    167 KB · Views: 83
#15
I calculated it, 1.3 Meg Ohms to discharge 400uF will take a lot longer than
1 minute per screw on a 6 screw bottom plate.
In fact, the RxC time constant is 520 seconds (8.66 minutes).
In 520 seconds, the Bleeder will discharge B+ from 300V down to 109V.

A dead 6P3P may cause harm to anybody getting inside before 15 minutes of discharge time.

Remember, Safety First.

Repeat after me,
Surviving Spouse Syndrome
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom