If OP is speaking of phono then as a Hall Effect works like a switch, I doubt there is enough signal variation for one to be useful.I assume that the OP is talking about phono pickups (cartridges).
If OP is speaking of phono then as a Hall Effect works like a switch, I doubt there is enough signal variation for one to be useful.
A hall effect device does not work as a switch.
It can output a voltage proportional to the change in magnetic field.
Being very small, it does require amplification.
Andy
As they say, "The Hall effect is a small effect". IME the SNR of a Hall cell used in analog mode is pretty bad. The mechanical issues of building a cart with a Hall cell bridge and a strain gauge are similar (but now you need a big static magnetic field), I don't know if it would be worth the bother.
Has anyone produced a pickup based on Hall Effect ?
Andy
Hello Andy,
Not to my knowledge. However, I don't see why it can't be done. The basic Hall element is an analog device. By the time it gets manufactured into a usable chip, it can be a digital switch or a ratiometric analog device. I have been using Hall effect devices since the early 1980s as position sensors in my various tone arm experiments when they were still being made by Sprague Eectric which is now Allegro Micro Systems. You can buy one for $2 or $3 fom Dgikey which is cheap enough to do some experimenting. They will need a 5v supply and need a total of four wires if you do stereo. I use one in my newest tone arm and I use the same gage wires as I use for the phono cartride itself. It would be interesting if somone actually did this.
Sincerely,
Ralf
Here is a kinda-suitable linear Hall sensor:
http://www.bristolwatch.com/hall_effect/ugn3503.pdf
I am not a phono needle designer. I'm guessing that even with a speaker magnet (5000 G) it would be hard to get 1 G deviation from a small stylus. That would be like a milliVolt which might be OK. But the broadband hiss is 80uV which is 100X or 40dB worse than conventional needles/amps.
Yes, modern Neo-whatzit magnets can put a very strong field in a very small area with little weight. But I'm guessing to get the signal level well out of the hiss they would have to be strong enough to suck paper-clips.
Small effect indeed.
http://www.bristolwatch.com/hall_effect/ugn3503.pdf
I am not a phono needle designer. I'm guessing that even with a speaker magnet (5000 G) it would be hard to get 1 G deviation from a small stylus. That would be like a milliVolt which might be OK. But the broadband hiss is 80uV which is 100X or 40dB worse than conventional needles/amps.
Yes, modern Neo-whatzit magnets can put a very strong field in a very small area with little weight. But I'm guessing to get the signal level well out of the hiss they would have to be strong enough to suck paper-clips.
Small effect indeed.
The sensor would need to be the moving part, set in a phenomenal local field. It might just work, given semiconductor sensors can be tiny and modern permanent magnets made to precision gaps in small dimensions with phenomenal strength...…..
Not much dafter than fishing MC signals out of the noise mire all things considered when one thinks about it? That works, after all.
LD
Not much dafter than fishing MC signals out of the noise mire all things considered when one thinks about it? That works, after all.
LD
- Status
- This old topic is closed. If you want to reopen this topic, contact a moderator using the "Report Post" button.
- Home
- Source & Line
- Analogue Source
- Hall Effect Pick Up