World's Best Tweeters Face-off :: Subjective comparison

Attachments

  • 9108CMTHR-IMG-JS-Ionic.jpg
    9108CMTHR-IMG-JS-Ionic.jpg
    77.3 KB · Views: 655
OK, get your flame throwers.

IMHO the Focal/Be and B&W Diamond drivers are garbage. Those micro motors can't do much but compress. Measure and sound ragged as hell.

I've heard Lansche speakers with plasma drivers at shows a couple of times. MEH! I'm sorry but whatever we think those massless drivers should do for you, they don't for me. I mean, they're fine. Certainly several cuts above the micro-motor tweets discussed above, but nothing that would make me spend extra for them. The ScanSpeak Be drivers used by Magico were a lot more interesting to listen to, had wider dispersion, and seemed less congested and more extended, but those speakers are also tuned a little brighter.
 
Last edited:
OK, get your flame throwers.

IMHO the Focal/Be and B&W Diamond drivers are garbage. Those micro motors can't do much but compress. Measure and sound ragged as hell.

I've heard Lansche speakers with plasma drivers at shows a couple of times. MEH! I'm sorry but whatever we think those massless drivers should do for you, they don't for me. I mean, they're fine. Certainly several cuts above the micro-motor tweets discussed above, but nothing that would make me spend extra for them. The ScanSpeak Be drivers used by Magico were a lot more interesting to listen to, had wider dispersion, and seemed less congested and more extended, but those speakers are also tuned a little brighter.

Actually B&W and Focal make the best tweeters in the world. Always have. Period.
 
At hifi shows I seem to have an inclination for speakers with pure ribbon tweeters, realizing that they are probably not entirely neutral and they work well with the music they play at such shows.
In terms of do it all well (range, dynamics, distortion, dispersion and neutrality) the best implementations I have listened to have been: Top of line scan speak ring radiator, dynaudio esotar, and the mundorf AMTs.

I was surprised about the ring radiator, did not expect how clean and effortless it sounded.

I have yet to listen to the scanspeak beryllium and the SB acoustic ring domes.
With that said, tweeter selection becomes easier with age 🙂
 
At hifi shows I seem to have an inclination for speakers with pure ribbon tweeters, realizing that they are probably not entirely neutral and they work well with the music they play at such shows.
In terms of do it all well (range, dynamics, distortion, dispersion and neutrality) the best implementations I have listened to have been: Top of line scan speak ring radiator, dynaudio esotar, and the mundorf AMTs.

I was surprised about the ring radiator, did not expect how clean and effortless it sounded.

I have yet to listen to the scanspeak beryllium and the SB acoustic ring domes.
With that said, tweeter selection becomes easier with age 🙂

It is strange how that works. I can't stand to listen to any ribbon electro static tweeters for more than several seconds, including the almighty RAAL. They irk me unlike anything else. With unnatural, bleached out, grainy, SACD like sound.
 
The world's best tweeter to blow your face off is any sufficiently high efficiency (110db+) 2" compression driver mounted to the biggest horn you can find and crossed at 300Hz directly from a stack of scoops played in a warehouse with corrugated metal walls and ceiling. With a DJ redlining the mixer.

Have I understood this thread correctly?