CDM4/19 two types of cog-wheel

Hi,
There are two kinds of cog-wheels in the CDM4/19 based drawer mechanisms (see the photos attached): full plastic, supported on both sides (the second photo) and plastic with the metal spindle, fixed on the one side (the first photo). I found the first type cog-wheel in Marantz CD-72 unit and the second type in many other Philips and Marantz units.
In what units are used the full-plastic cog-wheels? Is there a list?
f.
 

Attachments

  • cdm419cogw.JPG
    cdm419cogw.JPG
    55.4 KB · Views: 204
  • DSCF0021-1024.jpg
    DSCF0021-1024.jpg
    139.5 KB · Views: 194
It would be my guess that the dimensions are identical although this is only a guess. I've been through many cdm4/19 of the Philips and marantz variety and I've never noticed the metal spindle version. Maybe it was a late version revision?

The original brown wheels used in the majority of cdm4/19 mech go brittle and break as shown. I doubt the replacements now available on eBay will suffer the same fate as the material used to make is different.
 
Maybe it depends on where the machine was made? Much earlier, CDM1 machines made in Japan had completely different drive mechanism and motor. Moulds for the loader frame weren't cheap, so there must have been a good reason for variation. Either location or date, presumably.
 
In your 1st post, you state that your cd72 has the metal spindle type??? Now I'm confused!

Does it really matter? All the full plastic originals fail but can be replaced with new plastic (different construction) ones from china. I doubt they will fail in the next 20 years but you could always keep a spare!!
 
Hi,
There are two kinds of cog-wheels in the CDM4/19 based drawer mechanisms (see the photos attached): full plastic, supported on both sides (the second photo) and plastic with the metal spindle, fixed on the one side (the first photo). I found the first type cog-wheel in Marantz CD-72 unit and the second type in many other Philips and Marantz units.
In what units are used the full-plastic cog-wheels? Is there a list?
f.
Rotel RCD965BX. Has spindle.