lGl-2, continuing "hybrid madness" - no GNFB class A

Status
Not open for further replies.
Jump to Latest
#42
jwilhelm said:
The transformer I'm looking at has dual 6.3V windings as well. I'll get it on order. Thanks.
Next dilemma is what tubes to choose. Any recommendations on brands?
Click to expand...

I use Electro-Harmonix Gold - Russian manufacturer selling internationally (just easy to buy here). I did not try any other manufacturers as yet... Heard good feedback on Genalex (more expensive though).
Try to buy the selected ones with matched triodes within each tube - this will ensure better balance (lower distortion, lower DC offset). Although DC offset may be corrected with the pot to some extent, matched triodes are still a preference.
Here is a good online store in Canada (Ontario):

The Tube Store - 12AU7 (ECC82)

They offer "selected" option.
 
#43
vzaichenko said:
I use Electro-Harmonix Gold - Russian manufacturer selling internationally (just easy to buy here). I did not try any other manufacturers as yet... Heard good feedback on Genalex (more expensive though).
Try to buy the selected ones with matched triodes within each tube - this will ensure better balance (lower distortion, lower DC offset). Although DC offset may be corrected with the pot to some extent, matched triodes are still a preference.
Here is a good online store in Canada (Ontario):

The Tube Store - 12AU7 (ECC82)

They offer "selected" option.
Click to expand...
Thanks. Those were some I was looking at. There is a huge range in prices!
 
#46
Here's my version laid out on a 3" x 4" board to plug into a Slewmaster output board. Critiques are welcome.
 

Attachments

  • No NFB input.PNG
    No NFB input.PNG
    316.3 KB · Views: 440
#47
jwilhelm said:
Here's my version laid out on a 3" x 4" board to plug into a Slewmaster output board. Critiques are welcome.
Click to expand...

Jeff, looks very good to me!
Just please check some values with the final schematic in >post #35< - some caps and resistors were adjusted, comparing to earlier schematic.
Worth building. It will be interesting to know your listening impressions. This one has got a clear signature 🙂
Also, worth trying it with Lat-Fet OPS from TubSuMo. I did not try this combination as yet, but I surely will...

Cheers,
Valery
 
#48
vzaichenko said:
Yes, I also realized high 2-nd harmonic doe not scare me any more 😀
It sounds cool. Experimenting with some alternative configurations, including the one with a "light" NFB (~6db loop gain).
Click to expand...

Valery

Just found this thread - been considering something similar but using Quad "current dumping" output stage using Sziklai pairs.

On 2nd - it is still distortion. Now, the 12AU7, while cheap and cheerful, is not a low distortion device. The 6SN7 or 5687 are going to be better (by all reports). Should be able to reduce 2nd and 3rd a bit by swapping these out.

Lynn Olson's work suggests SRPP 6SN7 taking output from lower play would be best.

OR

I'd be interested in a wrapping a high NFB loop (ie a decent op-amp. Even the venerable 5532.) around the voltage gain stage - not the whole amplifier. This will keep the speaker OUT of your NFB loop.

As long as you don't clip Op Amps they seem (in my experience) to behave pretty well. Clip them (eg. by generating larger error terms) and they get ugly quickly.

(I'm trying to work out how to build a practical "limiting" error amplifier - needs to limit asymmetrically to minimise odd harmonics, too)
 
#51
thoglette said:
I forgot to mention that (if you can find it*) Bruno Putzeys penned an article on the impact of NFB on distortion spectra where he extends Bandaxall's work. Some leaps of faith are needed but it's a thought provoking read.

(*my copy is titled "The F-word" and marked "Linear Audio Volume 1 - Circuit design" but no date or place of publication)
Click to expand...

Cool, I will find it :wiz:
BTW, did you see a couple of my other designs with tube LTP at the input and high loop gain (very low distortion)? A different story, but also a good direction to go, IMHO...

>Low TIM, low distortion hybrid front-end<
>Ultra-high performance, yet rather simple - hybrid and more!<
 
#57
jwilhelm said:
While the tubes are warming up, can the 250 volt supply be live while the rest of the amplifier is off or will that cause problems?
Click to expand...

If I understand the question, the rails should not be hot while the tube is warming up. I tried it and the rail voltage is all over the place for at least 15-20 seconds. If you let the tube warm up for 10 seconds or so the fluctuation will be greatly reduced. Valery's protection circuit is set up to turn on the tube warmer first, then the soft start and then short the soft start for full power. After all that there is a delay on the speaker protection side to let the rails settle at zero. This takes 5 relays, three on a separate board and the two on the protection board. I'm not sure you can do it another way unless you skip the soft start.
 
#58
still4given said:
If I understand the question, the rails should not be hot while the tube is warming up. I tried it and the rail voltage is all over the place for at least 15-20 seconds. If you let the tube warm up for 10 seconds or so the fluctuation will be greatly reduced. Valery's protection circuit is set up to turn on the tube warmer first, then the soft start and then short the soft start for full power. After all that there is a delay on the speaker protection side to let the rails settle at zero. This takes 5 relays, three on a separate board and the two on the protection board. I'm not sure you can do it another way unless you skip the soft start.
Click to expand...
The rails won't be hot. This input uses an extra 250 volt supply just for the tubes that is fed by the same transformer as the heaters. It would need a second power delay relay.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom