Lowest noise BJT transistor?

Status
This old topic is closed. If you want to reopen this topic, contact a moderator using the "Report Post" button.
Dick Kleijer's website has an excellent article on low noise device measurements, this part of the article has a table of measured noise spectra and calculated Rbb's that's very relevant here: Ultra low noise amplifiers
That's excellent!! It would appear, from his research, that the ZTX851 and its brothers are about the lowest noise transistors available---he's quoting voltage noise of 0.223nV√Hz for these. Anyone find anything better? How about low-noise FETs?
 
Last edited:
If you are willing to spend a fortune on a FET with an absurdly large die area, they can have quite low voltage noise (though not as low as 0.223 nV/sqrt(Hz)), see the InterFET IF3601 and IF3602 datasheets.
Thanks---that FET sure is quiet! Datasheet says 0.3nV√Hz. But oh MY---$21.64 EACH!!!
Is there anything else that's pretty quiet but not so much $$$$$???
 
Sure, a dozen AM car radio front-end JFETs in (AC) parallel. The BF862 is out of production, but there are alternatives, such as the NSVJ3557SA3 and the NSVJ5908DSG5. I haven't read it, but I know that Dimitri Danyuk wrote an article about low-noise FETs some time ago.
 
Last edited:
1 dB in 1 kHz corresponds to 2.036377 nV/sqrt(Hz) when there is no noise current. However, a graph in the datasheet also shows 2 dB in 100 ohm, which boils down to 0.967852 nV/sqrt(Hz). In fact the whole graph looks weird, because the noise figure approaches 1 dB with increasing source resistance and then stays there. Calibration error or incorrect noise bandwidth maybe?

I don't know any through-hole equivalents, but Linear Systems has some pretty good through-hole FETs. An On Semiconductor J109 may also be interesting for you, although its 1/f noise is a bit high.
 

PRR

Member
Joined 2003
Paid Member
Exactly, the knee frequency is high. Ideally you'd like 1/f knee at or below 20Hz for audio, but that's pretty rare.

<20Hz is extremely rare, and not very important because of low bandwidth. (Also typical room rumble, and because Fletcher-Munson.)

The actual +3dB knee freq is below 100Hz which is very good for audio.

Yes, the NF should decline at high R but 1dB may just be test gear limit.

These parts are about as good as it gets for >150r source.

It is folly to be chasing dB of NF. If 3dB NF is "not good enough", after honest listening tests, you want to re-think the whole situation. Put the mike closer to the flea. Use a transformer on your MC needle. Etc.
 
Member
Joined 2014
Paid Member
Hans Polak and Syn08 have been messing around with the ZTX851 for MC headamps and getting some very good results. Some argument over where the 1/f knee is, but seems to be around 10Hz if you keep Ic around 5mA. In that application its low enough noise that most cartridges produce significantly more. Hfe is a little low but if you need lowest noise at a sensible price in a BJT it's the goto.
 
<20Hz is extremely rare, and not very important because of low bandwidth. (Also typical room rumble, and because Fletcher-Munson.)

The actual +3dB knee freq is below 100Hz which is very good for audio.

The remark about the not so low 1/f corner applied to the On Semiconductor J109, which has a knee frequency far above 100 Hz. Nonetheless it's not a big deal; even 700 Hz is fine when you look at the A- and ITU-R 468 weighting curves.

Yes, the NF should decline at high R but 1dB may just be test gear limit.

It is easy enough to subtract the noise of the test gear, for example with hot-cold methods. It amazes me that On Semiconductor didn't bother to measure the noise of the NSVJ3557SA3 more accurately, considering that its low noise appears to be its main selling point. In fact it is meant for car radio AM LNAs, and designers of those would do almost anything for a whole decibel of noise reduction.

These parts are about as good as it gets for >150r source.

It is folly to be chasing dB of NF. If 3dB NF is "not good enough", after honest listening tests, you want to re-think the whole situation. Put the mike closer to the flea. Use a transformer on your MC needle. Etc.

Do you also design your main amplifiers to distort as much as the loudspeaker? In any case, the purpose of a step-up transformer for MC cartridges is to reduce the noise figure.
 
Hans Polak and Syn08 have been messing around with the ZTX851 for MC headamps and getting some very good results. Some argument over where the 1/f knee is, but seems to be around 10Hz if you keep Ic around 5mA. In that application its low enough noise that most cartridges produce significantly more. Hfe is a little low but if you need lowest noise at a sensible price in a BJT it's the goto.

You're right, let's get back on topic.
 
Status
This old topic is closed. If you want to reopen this topic, contact a moderator using the "Report Post" button.