|Analogue Source Turntables, Tonearms, Cartridges, Phono Stages, Tuners, Tape Recorders, etc.|
Please consider donating to help us continue to serve you.
Ads on/off / Custom Title / More PMs / More album space / Advanced printing & mass image saving
||Thread Tools||Search this Thread|
|15th February 2010, 06:06 AM||#222|
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: Queens, New York
I've only read the first ten pages of this thread so far, but I'd like to add a note that I own an older (circa: 1970-1975) belt drive, aluminum platter turntable on a plastic base (Not a really expensive or high end BDTT) from a maker who has been in the business for thirty or forty years now.
This 1970's BDTT has a dual ring magnet bearing under the fairly light weight aluminum platter. The ring magnets OD are approximately the size of an LP's record label and ID about 1 inch smaller. While I've never measured it, I guess the platter is suspended some 2 - 4 mm to unload the center bearing when a rubber mat and LP are in place.
-Steven L. Bender, Designer of Vintage Audio Equipment
Steven L. Bender, Designer of Vintage Audio Equipment
|15th February 2010, 08:30 AM||#223|
Join Date: Jan 2007
Hmm...interesting; I'm not aware of the design you mention (though no doubt you are correct). What is the make and model of the turntable please? Presumably it uses ferrite magnets?
|2nd June 2010, 07:06 AM||#224|
Join Date: Jul 2007
Successful Mag Lev on a Linn Sondek LP12...Wolf in sheep's clothing...
I read all the posts on this thread with great interest last night for a couple of hours....after I had looked up 'magnetic turntable bearing' on google...
Three things amaze me.
Firstly, I am very impressed with everybody's interest in the subject....I had thought I was alone!
Secondly, yesterday, after a few weeks of experimenting, I had managed to use mag lev on a Linn Sondek LP12, which, although it is alternately cast as an angel or a villain in the world of hifi, certainly has, in its natural form, a really musical toe tapping ability. For a few months now, a) because I am on a budget, and b) because I have engineering skills and can't ever leave well alone, I have been rebuilding my LP12 with:
1. a CAD designed water-cut single piece titanium subchassis & arm mount,
2. a CAD redesigned thicker water-cut stainless steel top plate,
3. new 7pm motor position,
4. new external & internal electronics,
5. thicker & more rigid higher tensile steel bolt & locknut components,
6. machined corian armboard,
7. machined corian baseplate,
8. lathe turned dural thickened bearing housing,
9. silicon or rubber rings on crucial parts to damp resonances,
10. molybdenum sulphide greased ruby motor bearing in phosphor bronze bearing housing,
11. laser cut and hand finished acetyl arm pillar mounted cradle for the armrest,
12. thick water-cut stainless steel motor mounting,
13. two-part mag lev ring bearing on main bearing, relieving thrust plate pressure and consequent reduction of friction & noise,
14. solid silver wiring throughout,
15. renovation of rosewood plinth,
16. rebuilding of internal hidden elements of plinth (eg internal mahogany top-plate supports)
17. other minor aspects....polishing of bearing shaft tip, etc...
and it is sounding SO good.....
Thirdly, when reading the thread, I notice that a few of you had talked about living in the UK, in Sheffield, in S11 or S7.
When I was a young guy, I remember Sheffield was world-famous for its steel works and I remember drinking Magnet ale...in fact the famous Sheffield United football team fans' song refers to 'Magnet' ale produced locally by John Smith's Brewery, a packet of Woodbines cigarettes, a pinch of snuff(tobacco), a night out in Sheffield and a greasy chip butty.
The full lyrics to Sheffield United's Greasy Chip Butty song are:
You fill up my senses Like a gallon of Magnet
Like packet of Woodbines
Like a good pinch of snuff
Like night out in Sheffield
Like a greasy chip butty
Like Sheffield United Come thrill me again....
Na Na Naa Naa Naaaaa, Oooooooh!"
Well the thing is...
I was born in Sheffield S11 too...and lived there until I was 17....
There MUST have been something in the water....
|7th June 2010, 05:06 AM||#226|
Join Date: Nov 2003
Location: Melbourne (Oz, not Florida!)
I'd also be interested to know what made you decide on #2 - in comparison, say, to a CF top-plate? Does your new top-plate use the same fixing bolts/ screws as the stock one? And what does the extra thickness deliver?
And I have #18 for you - but you need access to a sophisticated (CNC?) lathe. That is, to get both the inner & outer platters dynamically balanced!
An Aussie on Stereo Net Australia (SNA) had this done and, on the basis of his review, I decided to get mine done. Haven't got them back from the guy, yet, though (so I'm vinyl-less ATM).
|12th June 2010, 01:05 PM||#228|
Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: Furulund, SWEDEN
I have read parts of this thread with great interest!
Me and a few friends made an experiment with a DIY Platine Verdier about 20 years ago and came to the conclusion that it sounded better with the platter resting on the ball than not. Better dynamics in the lower registers and an overall more stable presentation was the result from the second the ball was in place. I do not know how much weight that was put on the ball but it was not much at all, we are talking about a lot less than 100g here .
Reading through a few posts in this thread got me thinking, if mechanical grounding is so important maybe a zero play bearing like the one used in the Well Tempered Record Player (without the bottom ball though) can be used to good effect here. A non inverted bearing with the sleeve replaced by two V-shaped pieces of POM would be a good start. If the force from the belt is not enough to bias the bearing this could be done by small modifications to the magnet circuit. One could either tilt the lower magnet plate down slightly on the side towards the motor or simply remove a few magnets on that side.
|15th June 2010, 06:42 PM||#229|
Join Date: Oct 2009
Nice thread, I have not read all of it, mostly looked at the pictures.
Keep up the good work.
.....................back to reading what I skimmed over.
Tubes and Martin Logan's
|3rd December 2010, 01:23 PM||#230|
Join Date: Sep 2010
interesting thread, also because I am planning to make my own TT.
I had drawn a lot of plans with a normal bearing like we all now them with the ceramic bal at the button.
Than I saw this thread and began thinking about it, this must be the way to go I thought.
So after some searching I saw that the Da Vinci Audio Gabriel AAS MK2 also used a magnetic bearing.
Here is a photo of that one :
Could some one help with calculating how much magnets you would need for a 20 kilo platter ?
|Thread Tools||Search this Thread|
|Thread||Thread Starter||Forum||Replies||Last Post|
|Air Bearing Spindle DD Turntable||monsieurphot||Analogue Source||18||12th April 2008 08:05 AM|
|Other bearing for turntable use?||Zero One||Analogue Source||4||27th May 2006 02:13 PM|
|DIY turntable bearing||bigbulb||Analogue Source||9||11th July 2005 03:16 PM|
|Turntable bearing||Tee-Rex||Analogue Source||3||5th May 2005 07:55 PM|
|turntable bearing design||sc351cobra||Analogue Source||1||24th March 2005 11:30 AM|
|New To Site?||Need Help?|