John Curl's Blowtorch preamplifier

Status
Not open for further replies.
Jump to Latest
vuki

vuki

Member
Joined 2002
drzlab.com/
janneman said:


Stan Curtis, the guy who put Rotel back on its feet many years ago, claimed the same. His secret, as much as he confided (IIRC; t was an interview in EW I think) was manipulation of the freq response and Zout, or the combination of it. His reviewers hated him, his amps didn't measure particularly linear but they couldn't stop listening to them. An enviable achievement.

Jan Didden
Click to expand...

Well, Lamm doesn't manipulate with linearity. Quite contrary - he says that an amplifying device should have output imedance and freq. response as linear as it could. Also, distortion spectrum shouldnt change through audio freq. response. He is, in fact, great linearity proponent.
 
Joshua_G

Joshua_G

Member
Joined 2008
gomeh.com/
SY said:


No, they don't. They are asserting that something that depends on an uncharacterized parameter (and the designer of that opamp has confirmed this) will work consistently from batch to batch. Without a LOT of supporting data, that's an extremely dangerous assertion. Read Pease for some horror stories about that.
Click to expand...


This is your theory, while this circuit actually works properly in hundreds of units.
Can you explain that?
(There is a valid explanation).
 
Joshua_G

Joshua_G

Member
Joined 2008
gomeh.com/
janneman said:



Joshua,

You sure you want to do this? You know what 'we' will say, whatever your opinion, right? Unless you use a well-controlled, statistically significant DBT....

Jan Didden
Click to expand...


The point is this.
I do all this for my own enjoyment from my sound system.
A DAC with PSUs and I/V amp based on THS4131ID and LM4562MA are due in few days.
Later on I'm going to do some modifications to the DAC's on board "regulators" and hear the difference.
Later on I'm going to build few discrete I/V amps, one based on JC's design (which I posted here some time ago) and between 1 and 3 bipolar ones.
Eventually I'll use the one that will sound best.
Comparing the various amps will be done eventually by controlled DBTs, for I have no desire to fool myself.
Nevertheless, I'm quite sure that some participants in this thread will argue until doomsday that my findings are invalid. Some may claim that I'm half deaf, therefore, even the best controlled DBTs I may conduct are invalid.
 
jan.didden

jan.didden

AX tech editor
Joined 2002
linearaudio.net
Paid Member
Joshua_G said:



The point is this.
I do all this for my own enjoyment from my sound system.
A DAC with PSUs and I/V amp based on THS4131ID and LM4562MA are due in few days.
Later on I'm going to do some modifications to the DAC's on board "regulators" and hear the difference.
Later on I'm going to build few discrete I/V amps, one based on JC's design (which I posted here some time ago) and between 1 and 3 bipolar ones.
Eventually I'll use the one that will sound best.
Comparing the various amps will be done eventually by controlled DBTs, for I have no desire to fool myself.
Nevertheless, I'm quite sure that some participants in this thread will argue until doomsday that my findings are invalid. Some may claim that I'm half deaf, therefore, even the best controlled DBTs I may conduct are invalid.
Click to expand...



Don't get pathetic. You are perfectly right to do and select what you fancy. Just remember that is will be *your* preference, and as such lots of people will disagree. So don't complain when that happens.

Jan Didden
 
syn08

syn08

Banned
Joined 2005
synaesthesia.ca
janneman said:
Sure, but for audio use, my source would care both about those low value resistors as well as the Ib ;)
Click to expand...

Well, then don't use a 3.9GHz opamp ;) For almost all +/-15V audio purposes (perhaps except ultra low noise for MC, which would require a few K170 or BF862 FETs), the new OPA211 and/or OPA847 (to name only a few from TI/BB) will perfectly fit and requirements at very reasonable costs.
 
Joshua_G

Joshua_G

Member
Joined 2008
gomeh.com/
janneman said:




Don't get pathetic. You are perfectly right to do and select what you fancy. Just remember that is will be *your* preference, and as such lots of people will disagree. So don't complain when that happens.

Jan Didden
Click to expand...


No doubt the results will be only to my personal preferences. However, I'm quite sure some people here will invalidate even that. We had it before, concerning selecting cables to my system.
 
jan.didden

jan.didden

AX tech editor
Joined 2002
linearaudio.net
Paid Member
Joshua_G said:



No doubt the results will be only to my personal preferences. However, I'm quite sure some people here will invalidate even that. We had it before, concerning selecting cables to my system.
Click to expand...


No, not at all. Two things were going on. On was that your results could only be seen as personal preferences. The other was my effort to try to explain some of well-known properties of perception.

Jan Didden
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom