Active Crossover Benefits

Status
This old topic is closed. If you want to reopen this topic, contact a moderator using the "Report Post" button.
Member
Joined 2009
Paid Member
If you are listening to music I don't see a problem with a bit of latency. If you are watching movies however, it may be a bit more of an issue. I find even 10 ms of latency quite annoying (lip sync).

Yes. We talk about latency because Charles and myself come from proaudio and when working realtime live or studio this can be a disaster (nothing worth for musician returns). However up to 3ms this is acceptable for most of us. 10ms is very long! Hope you have a kind of delay control on video player, i could not stand non synced lip.
 
This is FIR related, you don't have this artifact using IIR (regular kind of filters).

Thanks. I did follow that much though. :)

I'm trying to decide whether to buy a regular MiniDSP like the 2 X 8 or go with the miniSHARC which can do IIR or FIR. They say you can use a freeware app called rephase to generate the FIR filters. But apparently they don't have the GUI plugins for the miniSHARC like they do for their regular kits.

I'd like to order one of the 2 X 4 boards to play with adding subwoofers to my current speakers with really flexible crossover points and PEQ but they don't have the digital input modules in stock right now.

Anyway, I know that's getting off topic.

Chris
 
Yes. We talk about latency because Charles and myself come from proaudio and when working realtime live or studio this can be a disaster (nothing worth for musician returns). However up to 3ms this is acceptable for most of us. 10ms is very long! Hope you have a kind of delay control on video player, i could not stand non synced lip.

It can be entertaining to hear people start to slur their words the first time they experience it. A sports radio station I listen to has a bunch of clips where people are speaking over a PA at sporting events and sound drunk from the delayed feedback.
 
iScream, if you're already using a PC, the is software you can use there to do pretty much anything an external DSP can do, right in the PC. Free or near-free...

Plugins for your music player, LADSPA plugins specifically work on some players...

I've got JRiver Media Center. It's definitely got some powerful DSP functionality but I don't know how to use it as a crossover without buying a really expensive PCI card like the Lynx AES16e. $700.

Is there a better way to get at least 7 channels out? Or just something I'm missing? I've only had JRiver installed for a couple weeks.

Thanks,
Chris
 
Member
Joined 2009
Paid Member
I've got JRiver Media Center. It's definitely got some powerful DSP functionality but I don't know how to use it as a crossover without buying a really expensive PCI card like the Lynx AES16e. $700.

No need for a LYNX AES! you'll be struck anyway because aes is a digital format, you'll need to buy converters to convert aes to analog...

If you need 7 channels out and want to stay in progear try to see MOTU offers, usually they are cheaper units and nearly as good. It's been a long time since i've looked at what's on the market... I'll take a look and keep you in touch.
 
iScream, if you're already using a PC, the is software you can use there to do pretty much anything an external DSP can do, right in the PC. Free or near-free...

Plugins for your music player, LADSPA plugins specifically work on some players...

I agree with that, though I choose to use one of the paid programs, JRiver and love it. It has an excellent base for DSP including a convolver for FIR filters build in, IIR PEQ's and lots more including (basic) crossover slopes, accepts plugins and also has an excellent movie player build in with madVR. That basically solves any lip sync issues with movie playback and using FIR filters. MadVR in itself is a marvelous (free) HD video render engine with a lot of custom options and continues to develop still. Excellent renderer and it can also be used in other (free) players. :up:
Possibilities are endless. Lots can be done with free programs, I just happen to like JRiver too much after running a 30 day demo (that was about 4 years ago). I just couldn't give it up. May skip an update every now and then but I just love what it can do. Using mobile phone as remote and even stream to that... So if you do have that PC....
 
Member
Joined 2009
Paid Member
Something like a motu 828x (thunderbolt) second hand should be ok if you want external. Maybe you can find cheaper... But if going studio gear just check that the drivers are stable in operation and ok with the soft you use. Otherwise it could be a real nightmare to debug!
 
Last edited:
No need for a LYNX AES! you'll be struck anyway because aes is a digital format, you'll need to buy converters to convert aes to analog...

If you need 7 channels out and want to stay in progear try to see MOTU offers, usually they are cheaper units and nearly as good. It's been a long time since i've looked at what's on the market... I'll take a look and keep you in touch.

Yep, I would have to use external DACs with something like the LYNX. The expense of all that is another reason I'm looking at a hardware DSP rather than using JRiver.

I don't know my way around pro gear at all. This Crown XLS I got for driving subwoofers is the only thing I have. I had a Behringer pro amp and Feedback Destroyer before but that's it.

I've been considering using a car audio DSP as well. There are some really nice all in one products out there with slick GUI interfaces that just don't seem to have an equivalent in the home audio world.
 
Member
Joined 2009
Paid Member
Yep, I would have to use external DACs with something like the LYNX

So your budget should be many thousands of dollars because converters using aes input are not cheap ones... We talk about serious pro gear here! ;)

Something like Prismsound or Weiss audio, or Lavry... :p

But i don't think you'll spend so much money or you'll have to sell your house!


In fact last time i looked around their still was PCI on motherboards and if you have one on your PC and can find drivers for windows you are using something like that should be perfect:

M-Audio Delta 1010LT

second hand should be less than 100usd and quality is ok!

But if you cannot find any of the 2 in bold just forget.

Maybe other could give you advice about that, me i just know stuff used in the industry i've worked in so prices are not in the same range.
 
Last edited:
So your budget should be many thousands of dollars because converters using aes input are not cheap ones... We talk about serious pro gear here! ;)

Something like Prismsound or Weiss audio, or Lavry... :p

But i don't think you'll spend so much money or you'll have to sell your house!


In fact last time i looked around their still was PCI on mothercards and if you have one on your PC and can find drivers for windows you are using something like that should be perfect:

M-Audio Delta 1010LT

second hand should be less than 100usd and quality is ok!

But if you cannot find any of the 2 in bold just forget.

PCI is getting more scarce but can be found on some workstation type PC's.
I tracked down a Lenovo Workstation just for that PCI bus.
 
Member
Joined 2009
Paid Member
PCI is getting more scarce but can be found on some workstation type PC's.
I tracked down a Lenovo Workstation just for that PCI bus.

That could be a great solution! I own an old PCI+rack card AARdVARK PCI (8in/8out)24bit/96khz which as really great sound (it's now Antelope audio). If you can find one with drivers running on win jump on it! It should be less than 100usd and quality it's on par with Apogee and the like...

O.T.: Wesayso, i just discovered your epic build of line array 2 days ago! Hats off to you, really, it's stunning build! Very very impressive.
 
Last edited:
That could be a great solution!

O.T.: Wesayso, i just discovered your epic build of line array 2 days ago! Hats off to you, really, it's stunning build! Very very impressive.

Thanks, actually it sounds even better than it looks (lol). Would have been a lot harder to do without JRiver though. The thing I love about a program like that is anything and everything is possible. A separate DSP will have certain limits.
 
Damn you all. My modular synth (only a basic digisound kit) ended up in a skip with the divorce (long story). Always wanted another one. But this time bigger!

You want bigger?

Here is an Analogue Systems (not Solutions!) modular to aim for. ;-)
 

Attachments

  • pheonixsm.jpg
    pheonixsm.jpg
    20.7 KB · Views: 129
Member
Joined 2009
Paid Member
A separate DSP will have certain limits.

It depends on the budget you are ready to invest. But in a way you're right: i could never perform auto acoustic correction or phase linearisation (using FIR, i've got a very complete allpass module on mine) with mine. But everything else is possible. But it's not cheap, that's a fact.

Please stop with synth porn!!!! :) It's time to go sleeping and i'll have wet dreams!
 
Last edited:
Status
This old topic is closed. If you want to reopen this topic, contact a moderator using the "Report Post" button.