HiVi - DIY 2.2A (swan 2.1se) for nearfield???

[illnastyimpreza]

I Need some computer speakers. I've been looking at the Amazon.com: HiVi - DIY 2.2A – 2-Way Bookshelf Speaker Kit - Braced Wooden Cabinet - Pair – Black – 2-Year Warranty: Home Audio & Theater

Everything I read says that these are absolutely the best speakers you can get for under $800.
buuuuuut everyone also says they are NOT for nearfield use!

What do you guys think???
Does the fact that they are simply amazing speakers outlook the fact that I will be using them nearfield???

or should I build something like the hitmakers studio monitors? Hitmaker MT Studio Monitor Speaker Kit with Knock-Down Cabinet

part of me also just wants to buy a set of B&W small bookshelf speakers like the 601 or 303 or lm1 and be done with it.....

 

[Jerms]

Quite a distance between the woofer and tweeter. I'd guess I'd want to be at least 6-8 feet away. I'd want widerange single driver or smaller woofer and closer coupled tweeter for nearfield use.... Or even coaxial.

 

[illnastyimpreza]

Quite a distance between the woofer and tweeter. I'd guess I'd want to be at least 6-8 feet away. I'd want widerange single driver or smaller woofer and closer coupled tweeter for nearfield use.... Or even coaxial.

Thanks Jerms.....Thats what I was thinking. I didn't end up getting them.

I actually just found some Dayton Audio MK402 4" 2-Way Bookshelf Speaker Pair

open box for 47 bucks shipped

gonna try those out. If not I'll prolly order some B&W small bookshelfs with the front port, or possibly try some of those ELAC speakers on amazon. they are engineered by andrew jones apparently?? supposed to be some REALLY good sounding speakers.

 

[Lojzek]

This HiVi kit is a pretty reasonable kit and I remember some time ago it was on a discount for about 130 bucks for a very short period of time. There is a fair probability this filter needs a minor mod to become fully developed.

 

[illnastyimpreza]

I think I'm about to pull the trigger on some ELAC Debut 2.0 B5.2
designed by andrew jones, and then refined (hense the 2.0) These get some absolutely AMAZING reviews from guys who are only used to multi thousand dollar systems.
Amazon.com: ELAC Debut 2.0 B6.2 Bookshelf Speakers, Black (Pair): Home Audio & Theater

Do you guys think there is a better nearfield speaker out there for around 200 bucks??

 

[Lojzek]

Hard to tell. You should try for yourself. Elac specs are typically optimistic, and the nominal 6 ohms could be in fact 4 ohms. Waveguide is a nice feature. There is a rather nice kit at meniscus called Caritas, now out of stock, deploying a 6.5" SBA midwoofer and a Vifa tweeter, no waveguide though, probably a fuller sounding speaker on account of bass. If the Dayton Audio BR-1CAB were already not cnc'd for DA units, it would have been a happily made match for Caritas. 100 bucks full kit, 62 for the cabinets, not bad.

 

[illnastyimpreza]

so I went down to the Magnolia at Bestbuy (the only place to listen to speakers anymore?) and listened to everything they had for like an hour. I went through Every speaker from Polk, Klipsch, Martin Logan, definitive technology, and the Elac and B&W speakers. Basicly every speaker (except for B&W)was sub par compared to my current setup ( a mutt of a bookshelf I put together with dayton drivers) The Elac speakers were insanely harsh and not impressive by any means. I guess thats what you get for a $300 already assembled bookshelf pair these days. Right now I'm looking at B&W 6 series on craigslist/facebook marketplace.

Either that or build some....

 

[Jerms]

Whatever you get, try to get some air under them.... Mount them up off the desk and/or angle them.