Signal path Resistor Quality

Status
Not open for further replies.
Jump to Latest
R

rtate

Member
Joined 2002
#1
What are the best resistors to put in the signal path of a pre-amp.
The values that I need are 50-60kohm.
I am thinking of using Caddock or Vishay.

Which is better for this application??

Or is there something even Better??

Thanks
 
#4
rtate said:
For sure I am going to use "metal film"
Click to expand...


What's so sure about it? I like Shinkoh tantalums or Riken carbon films as much as Caddocks. A Vishay or Caddock is certainly a safe choice but neither can be pronounced best in all situations. It's your ears and system - if sound is important to you be prepared to make the effort and compare yourself.
 
#5
I'm quite sure that between metal films, the effect on sound is negligible is at all.

Of course, cheap carbon composition resistors are more noisy.

analog_sa, since you seem to have a lot of comments about componenets, you must have one hell of a system. Can you share the detials with us?
 
#7
Moving Target

I have lately started using Dale RN55E for most applications. I have a lot of surplus bulk metal foil resistors from Texas Components, but think the Dales are just as good.
I picked up some ultra low TCM Dale PTF-56 resistors. Used them as a buffer, between a chip and series output coupling cap. I am not totally sold, need to swap them out for some RN55E of the same svalue to see. But I suspect the difference in the resistors is swamped by the non-linearities of the 10 ufd electrolytic coupling caps. The chip is single rail, there are several volts polarizing the cap.
I really think that resistors are not a big deal. Built a LOT of quiet circuits with AB carbon comp. Also built a lot with Vishay S102. I think that better quality resistors are wasted in most applications. But use a magnet to check for steel leads or end caps. Avoid those.

George
 
#8
John,

can you tell us precisely how the sound is affected, since in the overall amplifier cct we are unable to measure any differences (note I am talking about audio ccts - not RF).

I am not proposing using cheap resistors, but please help me understand how two good quality metal films can make a clear audible difference where that difference cannot be measured.
 
#9
We have been formally evaluating resistors since the middle '80's. Beyond excess noise, which can be important, lead material and attachment makes a BIG difference. You can find articles on resistors in 'Hi Fi News' in the mid '80's.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom