Looking at different designs for the BUF634 most use a current limiting resistor on the output. However some have this resistor inside the feedback loop while some do not. Anyone have any thoughts on placement?
If you want what the BUF634 is driving to see a certain amount of source resistance, then place the resistor with the desired value outside the feedback loop. If you want what you are driving to see a very low source resistance (a hard voltage source), then place the R inside the loop.
I think it's purpose is usually not current limiting, but capacitive load isolation. If the output was to be shorted, the current would likely still be limited by the BUF634s internal current limiting, but I could be wrong.
And obviously what egellings said about the resistance seen by the load.
And obviously what egellings said about the resistance seen by the load.
I agree with knOppers. This resistor is to isolate capacitive loads and needs to be outside the feedback loop.
It would anyway be to low in value for any meaningful current limit. The '634 has its own internal current limiting circuits.
Jan
It would anyway be to low in value for any meaningful current limit. The '634 has its own internal current limiting circuits.
Jan
The isolation resistor can be in the loop, but it makes everything slightly more complicated when it comes to ensuring stability. The BUF634A datasheet even shows an example somewhere. There are also few App Notes on this, I remembered one was from ST because and I found it easily, linked below. You can search for the "Analog Engineers Pocket Reference" from TI, it also touches on and it's free for download (I have the physical version - comes in handy now and then). But these only discuss OPAs by themselves driving capacitive loads, not with a buffer. Every configuration has benefits and drawbacks, but as an introduction I these app notes are okay to get one started.
https://www.st.com/resource/en/appl...ading-applied-to-ts507-stmicroelectronics.pdf
I know Jan has a headamp with AD797 and BUF634. Sadly my favourite version of the BUF634 is pretty much EOL. I really liked the BUF634T (TO-220-5) version, but I refuse to pay around 10 Euros each for the remaining ones on sale. Together with AD797 one composite opamp would cost me around 20 Euros purely in ICs and it would have to be driven from a really low source impedance as well. Hard to justify when you can buy 4 each of OPA1656 and BUF634A for the same price 🙁
https://www.st.com/resource/en/appl...ading-applied-to-ts507-stmicroelectronics.pdf
I know Jan has a headamp with AD797 and BUF634. Sadly my favourite version of the BUF634 is pretty much EOL. I really liked the BUF634T (TO-220-5) version, but I refuse to pay around 10 Euros each for the remaining ones on sale. Together with AD797 one composite opamp would cost me around 20 Euros purely in ICs and it would have to be driven from a really low source impedance as well. Hard to justify when you can buy 4 each of OPA1656 and BUF634A for the same price 🙁
Last edited:
I actually wanted to make a PCB that supports the SOIC-Powerpad versions of both BUF634A and LMH6321 in a composite loop with a dual OpAmp, very similar to the BUF634ADEVM evaluation board:
https://www.ti.com/tool/BUF634ADEVM
It can be done quite easily, you just need a few extra optional components then you can flexibly use either buffer on the same PCB. The evaluation board is based on the BUF634A version without a thermal pad though, that's why they were able to route the power traces very nicely. With thermal pads (and vias) the layout would have to be slightly different.
https://www.ti.com/tool/BUF634ADEVM
It can be done quite easily, you just need a few extra optional components then you can flexibly use either buffer on the same PCB. The evaluation board is based on the BUF634A version without a thermal pad though, that's why they were able to route the power traces very nicely. With thermal pads (and vias) the layout would have to be slightly different.
...search for the "Analog Engineers Pocket Reference" from TI, it also touches on and it's free for download....
www.ti.com/analogrefguide or
https://www.ti.com/amplifier-circuit/op-amps/precision/support-training.html#pocketref
I like the sliderule on page 6.
You may have to give an email. TI is not a heavy spammer. You may get newsletters, which may even be interesting; if not, UNsubscribe works good.
Great reading material, thanks for the links.
One other question. How is the gain calculated with the extra resistor?
One other question. How is the gain calculated with the extra resistor?
- Home
- Amplifiers
- Headphone Systems
- BUF634 output resistor in feedback loop