Troel's Loudspeaker 3 versus Faital 3WC15

I am interested in building one of Troels designs - leaning towards the TL2, TL3, Fatial 3W-15 or CNO-4. I want a speaker with a high level of dynamics and transparency. Can anyone who has heard or built any of these designs comment?

Thanks!
I and built and lived with the 3w-15 for about a year now. It is a fantastic sounding box. I am driving it with about a 6W SE valve amp and the detail and imaging is superb. I have the safabric tweeter
 
  • Like
Reactions: mayhem13 and Arez
@jderimig

Wow thank you. I did not want to get too specific in my ask on feedback on the speakers but my plan is to initially drive the pair I build with a 4W SET amp. I am also willing to get a different amp as necessary to get the best out of the speakers. Glad you are enjoying your 3W-15's!
 
I find I need more that 6W (they are in a large room, 6m x 6m) to get good bass out of them if the material has it. The bass driver on the 3WC-15 is separately wired so you do have the option to use a Hypex there and drive the rest with your SET.
 
Not Bad will be finnished within a week
20231112_141915.jpg
20231212_124204.jpg
20231212_124211.jpg
 
Hi Noam,

Are these going to replace your TL2? 😆

On a more serious note, do you have any extra comments to make about the sound performance of the CNO-4?
Are you considering building a pair for yourself, to complement the TL2?
 
Last edited:
Are these going to replace your TL2? 😆
Happy that you asked! I'll try to write some points and see if it makes sense.
I have listened to the CNO4 only a week and a half, so those nextel drivers are not broken in yet, but here it goes.

-First of all CNO4 to my ears is an upgrade over the NEXT4 which I know very very well ( had it for one year or so). The NEXT4 of course is not a bad speaker but I never really fell in love with it. I couldn't dial in the bass and the seas 10inch woofer never seemed to really do what it supposed to do- moving air. And that was in a dedicated listening room!

-The CNO4 uses BMS 12N630 with HYPEX FA501 is such a different beast! It is capable of wonderful bass and seamlessly merg with the 8inch seas lower midrange driver. The bass is really controlled and articulate, yet gives a good volume to instrument.

-The midrange and especially the tweeter do give a very good presentation, the speakers will definitely disappear if well positioned, but! (and I blame the first order Topologie for that) those speakers are really sensitive to amp and source. They will demand a bit like horn speakers the best you can afford... they will not sugar coat anything, which is good, trumpets and other instruments can be brutal on the ears- those nextel drivers are going pretty far this road.

-overall sound presentation is still very much SEAS nextel house sound being- lively, dynamic and a touch warm..organic- great with piano and acoustic guitar. Not so lean and mean like scan speak drivers tend to be.

- Now comes the but... the CNO4 will go to its new owner and I'm not going to replace the TL2 with a new pair of CNO4. Because:

- unlike small beautiful hifi drivers the TL2 PA drivers are capable of moving more air with less movement= those hifi drivers feel a bit slow in comparison. With the TL2 the music is popping effortlessly into existence, no matter the dynamic load. From 0 to 100 in no time.

I also believe that horns for the upper midrange is the way to go. Compression driver with horn being a machin gun ready to reload in an instant verses our modern tweeter being a beautiful hand gun but slow and sluggish in comparison when it comes to it.

I am sad to see that Troels is not building more of the TL1 family. After having so many years small modern loudspeaker, those TL2 are a revelation.

For those who don't know what I'm on about here are the links to the speakers mentioned above.

http://www.troelsgravesen.dk/CNO-4.htm

http://www.troelsgravesen.dk/NEXT4.htm

http://www.troelsgravesen.dk/The-Loudspeaker-2.htm
 
Last edited: