Trenner and Friedl make no secret of the fact that they coat some of their drivers with 6 layers of Italian balsamic oil varnish. The brand is even shown on some their pictures.
Trenner & Friedl Lautsprecher
http://www.trenner-friedl.com/download/RA-coating1-HR.jpg
I'm busy trying it on one cheap paper driver (rft) I had lying about . I can offer an anecdote in that I find that after only 2 layers it appears to lower shout considerably. Hard to say if it other parameters deteriorate. It definitely sounds as if it lowers distortions...especially at louder volumes.
Very unscientific I know. But to make it scientific I should compare 50 or so untreated drivers with 50 treated drivers from the same batch..etc., etc...bla bla bla...and measure several parameters...something I am just not able to do. So take all this with a grain of salt.
Trenner & Friedl Lautsprecher
http://www.trenner-friedl.com/download/RA-coating1-HR.jpg
I'm busy trying it on one cheap paper driver (rft) I had lying about . I can offer an anecdote in that I find that after only 2 layers it appears to lower shout considerably. Hard to say if it other parameters deteriorate. It definitely sounds as if it lowers distortions...especially at louder volumes.
Very unscientific I know. But to make it scientific I should compare 50 or so untreated drivers with 50 treated drivers from the same batch..etc., etc...bla bla bla...and measure several parameters...something I am just not able to do. So take all this with a grain of salt.
Attachments
Last edited:
Actually, this is something you can get out of the impedance curve and frequency response measurements. It's a lot easier than you're worried about.
Perhaps I should invest in a little PC measurement thingy for that purpose.frequency response measurements.
Actually, for speaker measurements, the built-in sound card will work well enough (I saved you some money- you owe me a beer). A few Euros for an electret mike and preamp and you're all set. Impedance likewise; a resistor and a small power amp is all that's needed.
Yes indeed. There's freeware out there (REW comes to mind), and inexpensive software (e.g., AudioTester). I haven't tried the HOLM freeware, but there seems to be a lot of buzz around it.
Having sent some drivers through Klippel scans, I am sure anything you do not the cone that makes the sound different really effects how the diaphragm flexes during vibration. The new wavelet spectrogram capability in SoundEasy really is a valuable tool to help evaluate if you are doing the right thing.
I think Planet10 uses Moge Podge thinned with a little water. You might ask him.
He does or at least did. I mentioned Mod-Podge earlier in this thread (in 2006? 😱 )
Best Regards,
TerryO
I had a can of spray-on bitumen goop for car use, I originally used it for damping pressed steel cones but decided it was too messy. Last time I built some boxes, it turned out great for sticking felt to the ply walls. I must try it on a cone to see what the effect is, next time I have a driver I'm prepared to sacrifice....
I think Planet10 uses Moge Podge thinned with a little water. You might ask him.
He does...
dave
Call me cynical, but I suspect that stuff is just over-priced dammar with a touch of food colouring???....
I have got no idea.
Never bought or used it nor have I any intention to. I merely knew of its existence.
Never bought or used it nor have I any intention to. I merely knew of its existence.
LTS-50 is nothing like dammar as it doesn't stiffen the cone. The coating is very elastic so the paper cone retains it's original flexibility.
I've tried it with a single coat (my preference) up to insane number of coats which still allows the cone to remain flexible. Not expensive and less than a packet of cigs. Long shelf life as the bottle I have is still good after 7 years.
It's like a condom for cones.... protection but allows flexibilty and enjoyment. 😉 If you want stiff, then use dammar. 😀
I've tried it with a single coat (my preference) up to insane number of coats which still allows the cone to remain flexible. Not expensive and less than a packet of cigs. Long shelf life as the bottle I have is still good after 7 years.
It's like a condom for cones.... protection but allows flexibilty and enjoyment. 😉 If you want stiff, then use dammar. 😀
I use permatex flowable silicone to coat cloth surrounds and sometimes cones and dust caps. It works very well to control surround reflections in paper cone drivers using rubber surrounds, getting rid of that common 1-2 kHz wiggle. Ive used water thinned mod podge too, but it doesnt dry as flexible. PVA works ok for certain applications but don't let it get exposed to moisture.
LTS-50 is nothing like dammar as it doesn't stiffen the cone. The coating is very elastic so the paper cone retains it's original flexibility.
I've tried it with a single coat (my preference) up to insane number of coats which still allows the cone to remain flexible. Not expensive and less than a packet of cigs. Long shelf life as the bottle I have is still good after 7 years.
It's like a condom for cones.... protection but allows flexibilty and enjoyment. 😉 If you want stiff, then use dammar. 😀
Hi,
How do you like it, please ? Have you heard goo sounding improvement enough ? Does it tame subtle details or the opposite ?
Btw, has anyone still tried it on metal cones by little touches here and there near and towards the dome cache where the metal cones resonances occur ?
What's bad with Damer and shellacs on paper ? Is it not what all this thing is about ? Making a sandwich with hard exterior and softer paper core, aka sandwich cones ?
I notice the non drying coating is making the opposite with an external damping instead an internal like the best foam core material at Focal, Eton, SB Acoustics...
I notice the non drying coating is making the opposite with an external damping instead an internal like the best foam core material at Focal, Eton, SB Acoustics...
Last edited:
mod podge too, but it doesnt dry as flexible. PVA works ok
ModPodge is a PVA formulation.
dave
- Home
- Loudspeakers
- Multi-Way
- damping coating substances for speakers' cones ?