|27th January 2004, 10:03 PM||#11|
Join Date: Feb 2001
I bought eight of those ribbons a while back based on the
forum hype that was spreading like wild fire, $30 each. It's not
bad for a $30 tweeter, but I'd rather use a good soft dome
tweeter instead. I listen to aggressive metal music and I like an
overpowering sound system and this just doesn't have what
it takes, you would need one of those high end ribbons costing
5 - 20x more to achieve that type of sonics.
BUT, if you line source eight of these per channel that is
a whole new ball game if you parallel all eight for a 1 ohm
load. While most amplifiers are not rated for 1 ohm load,
I didn't have any problems driving 1 ohm tweeters because
they don't taxi the typical 'good' amplifier like woofers would.
Under this situation, the line source did very well to please,
but it could cost you about $500 just for the tweeters if
you went line array - hehe
Send an email to Danny at GR research, I think he has
some good domes tweeters for an affordable price, I think he
matches the tweeters....
|28th January 2004, 03:24 AM||#12|
Join Date: May 2003
Hey I was just thinking, why not go for this guy? It even gives you box volumes for certian frequencies at bottom of page? And it would let you do an all audax speaker system....
its $17, and its even shielded. B
Stewie: You there, fetch me the wall street journal. You two! Fight to the death!
|15th May 2004, 12:36 PM||#13|
Join Date: Nov 2002
Horn loading of ribbon
If Ribbons have the disadvantage of low dispersion then can horn loading improve its dispersion without degrading its sonic abilities.
|16th May 2004, 05:06 PM||#14|
Join Date: May 2004
Location: La Belle Province
no, can't do. What you can attempt, however, is to use a horn in order to narrow down the ribbon's dispersion at Xover frequency (and somewhat below) to match the mid's dispersion - in the horizontal plane only, that is. In vertical direction, the length of the ribbon ccompared to the wavelength will sooner or later make the ribbon behave like a continuous line source, i.e. with a very pronounced vertical beaming (or lobung, if you perfer that term).
Note that putting a horn in front of something with a rather linear frequency response will give an increase in SPL towards lower frequencies of this horn. That is, you will have to equialize this increase. Hopefully, it can be done with the HP filter of the Xover, but this depends on the very horn paramters. Also note that it'll be tricky to obtain "constant directivity" properties for your horn, unless you design is really sophisticated. (meaning: you'll have to put some considerable brain into it). And there is not really a point in buying a ribbon with a very wide diespersion at high frequencies (simply because it is very narrow) and then to modify this very property. I guess that at the end of the day, you're better off with just a plain vanilla ribbon (if at all, sometimes a good 19mm/0.75" dome can work wonder).
However, a noted above, the strong vertical lobing of a ribbon will affect the vertical dispersion of an MTM configuration (I don't suppose the ribbon be Xover'able below 3 kHz), especially if the centers of the mid's are not located within one wavelength at Xover frequency - the precise conditions are more complex, more strict and hence disappointingly seldom to satisfy. This is even more true if you put a horn in front of your ribbon (or whatever your tweeter will be), since the horn will be quite large. After all, you'll need at least some flaring in vertical direction. And also consider steep filter slopes, steep as in 18 (MTM) or 24 (MT, requires even filter orders) dB/oct. But this you'll have to do anyway to protect you ribbon from desintegrating as soon as a LF electron comes by.
As to the complexity of your project: you really might want to keep it very simple for starters. Nothing is more &^%# than to sink any amount of money in something that doesn't (and can't, as one realizes only after having paid) work.
Good luck & Cheers,
What do you mean, "c'est du pipeau"?
|17th May 2004, 07:21 PM||#15|
I have recently used this small driver
With this horn mounted externally,
and some heavy resistors, I got very nice dispersion and imaging. I was very pleasantly surprised. From about 12 - 15 ft away, a bass wave seems to develop nicely and sounded good even without a woofer. Anyways, if you remember the Realitic Minimus 7's, well these are a step above them.
My girlfriend was impressed.
Her cat was not. Kept nipping at my leg during "testing"
They are not quite as shown as I have blocked off the port.
planet10 needs your help:
Let's help Ruth and Dave
|Thread Tools||Search this Thread|
|Thread||Thread Starter||Forum||Replies||Last Post|
|Why not a ribbon tweeter instead of a horn tweeter?||Curly Woods||Full Range||9||15th July 2009 04:09 PM|
|Fountek ribbon tweeter 3cm2 ribbon black square alumunum faceplate||lduarte1973||Multi-Way||3||16th June 2009 08:50 AM|
|ribbon tweeter||Andy Bartha||Planars & Exotics||10||22nd August 2007 10:34 PM|
|Ribbon tweeter||f.bcn||Multi-Way||0||3rd January 2007 06:05 AM|
|Looking ATD le ribbon tweeter||sma||Multi-Way||0||23rd November 2004 11:31 AM|
|New To Site?||Need Help?|