SSLV1.1 builds & fairy tales

Member
Joined 2006
Paid Member
A voltage reference will perform better than a resistor.
Usually a voltage reference will have a few ohms or maybe tens of ohms of dynamic impedance. A resistor must have a dynamic impedance equal to it's resistance. If you use a 1k0 resistor as your voltage Vref string then the dynamic impedance will be 1k0, If you use a 20V Zener & a 100ohm VR set to 49ohms then the dynamic impedance will be very approximately 60ohms. That is approximately 14 times lower impedance of the Vref. That makes for a better regulator, not 14 times better, but quite a bit better.

Instead of a Zener, you can use LEDs as Vref elements. Most of these Salas regulators use a short string of red LEDs just because they allow the regulator to perform better. 20V from a string of red LEDs would require 10 to 12 LEDs. That is a bit too many, a Zener would probably be better for this higher voltage.

No matter whether a resistor has a 5ppm or 50ppm or 0.5ppm tempco, it can never have a dynamic impedance as low as an appropriately selected Vref semiconductor.

Hi Andrew

Thank you for the very clear explanation.
What is your opinion about a precision reference like LM329 ? The pdf states a dynamic impedance of 0.8ohm.... Can it be used for vref in this case ? What about tjhe value of the filtering cap in this case ?
 
I concur Andrew, bloody marvellous explanation!

Though may I ask, what effect the dynamic imp has on the regulation? Does it "react" quicker to give a smoother output or holds the output voltage more stable under temperature variations?

Look forward to an informative answer. Thanks for putting up with those of us that don't know all this stuff!
 
With TeaBag's GB being dispatched soon, I though it was time to start working on my BOM.
The goal is to power my DD turntable with the BiB.

The TT needs ~200mA at normal spinning and ~400mA peak when starting rotating, all @21V.
Because the load is both digital and inductive, I think that going hot-rod would be a nice idea. Maybe as high as 1A?
The input DC is going to be 30V (2x12V secondaries @120VA)
According to the excel sheet, the CSS should be 3leds and R101 0,5R at 0,5W

Since the voltage is on the high side, I guess that a zener (20V 0,5W ?) filtered with lytics should be a better choice for the reference, along with a 1K trimmer for tweaking.
Unfortunately Q106 results in dissipating almost 17W and will need a substantial size of heatsink. So I really need your opinion on if hot-rodding would really be useful in my case. Dropping the current to 600mA results in ~9W at Q106 which again is high but really more manageable.

Thanks a lot for your time
Dimitris
 
Member
Joined 2009
Paid Member
Is ok this formula:

Rd = 26mV @ 25ºC / If

For example dide 20mA will be:

Rd = 26mV / 20mA = 1.3 ohms

For a resistor will be:

Rd = 26mV / (I:V/R across Resistor)

26mV is given by the formula where
k is the Boltzmann constant k=1.38e^-23 joules/Kelvin
T is the absolut temperature in Kelvin
q is the electron charge q=1.602e^-19 coulomb

This yields approximately a Vt of 25mV @ 20 or
26mV @ 25
 
diyAudio Chief Moderator
Joined 2002
Paid Member
Who knows the dymanic impedance of each 1.9V 20mA red LEDs?

Some makers publish graphs. Most LEDS like that are about 20 Ohm Z at nominal current. Regarding references its a big chapter, and this is a builds thread. Very fast, dynamic impedance of a reference is not only about absolute minimum, but is also about matching to any current source and the error amp circuit. Its about stiffness, harmonic, and random noise, lending to easy filtering etc.
 
Member
Joined 2009
Paid Member
Some makers publish graphs. Most LEDS like that are about 20 Ohm Z at nominal current. Regarding references its a big chapter, and this is a builds thread. Very fast, dynamic impedance of a reference is not only about absolute minimum, but is also about matching to any current source and the error amp circuit. Its about stiffness, harmonic, and random noise, lending to easy filtering etc.

Formula isn't OK?
 
Member
Joined 2009
Paid Member
For 15Vout now I'm using a string of 8 red LEDs at Vref & sounds amazing, can be improved with:

Vbe 0.6V
2 x LM329DZ 6.9V = 13.8V
1 x 1N4007 0.6V = 0.6V
Total 15V

For 45Vout now I'm using 2 1.9V LED, 6.8k R303, 5K trimmer. Other parts jumper. As can be a lot of LEDs I want to reduce at maximum the static resistance to do that I have on hand:

4 x LM4040DIZ 10V
10 x LM329DZ 6.9V
4 x LM336Z 5V

Wich option will be the best for 45Vout

1st option
0.6V vbe
3 x LM329DZ 6.9V = 20.7V
2 x LM4040DIZ 10V = 20V
2 x red LEDs 1.9V = 3.8V
Total 45.1V

2nd option
0.6V vbe
2 x LM336Z 5V = 10V
2 x LM329DZ 6.9V = 13.8V
2 x LM4040DIZ 10V = 20V
1 x 1N4007 0.6V = 0.6V
Total 45V

3rd option
0.6V vbe
2 x LM336Z 5V = 10V
2 x LM329DZ 6.9V = 13.8V
2 x LM4040DIZ 10V = 20V
1 x 1N4007 0.6V = 0.6V
Total 45V
 
Member
Joined 2009
Paid Member
Very interesting Felipe,

Do those LM types still require a 220uF elco and what about the 220 Ohm resistor for filtering as stated in the manual ?

Vref cap depends application as stated in the BiB manual: Clocks, MC pre Lytic rest: lineamps. buffer, MM pre Film.

Dynamic impedance:
LM336Z 5V 0,6 Ohms
LM329DZ 6.9V 0,6 Ohms
LM440DIZ 10V 0,8 Ohms