Seos 12 8" Faitalpro MTM 12" Subwoofer towers

Status
This old topic is closed. If you want to reopen this topic, contact a moderator using the "Report Post" button.
JShadzi, I'm a big fan of MTM and horn drivers, and your project looks very promising to me. Unfortunately, I have no skill to build enclosure, but I really want try it in the future.

I currently own Barefoot MM27 (MTM+ tandem subwoofers) and JBL DMS-1 (WTW, Digital crossover + multi Aleph J driven). Both sounds very dynamic but accurate. Lipinski 707 is extremely accurate but not as dynamic / lively as Barefoot.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Hello Mindsource, how to fight with room mode is probably the endless subject, but I certainly couldn't get any good result with this Geddes idea.

When we bought Lipinski 707 (The world class MTM mastering monitor) + L150 subs, we struggled to locate subs in our studio. We already had a pair of Velodyne, so we experimentally happened to place those 4 subs all over the studio, but our conclusion was the subs should be located as close as possible to the main speakers. It is the least artificial sounding location for the bass. We human can locate the sub for some reasons. This is an experience in the very well acoustically controlled room, so the result might be different in the regular home theater, but I still believe it's better to place the subs as close as possible to the main, then reduce the room mode as much as possible with the conventional way, such as Owens Corning, EQ, resonator, etc.

I can only assume that it didn't work properly because you didn't know how to process the data from each sub's steady state response and equalize accordingly. From what I've learnt the algorithm for such is no simple thing.

That said there is some free software out now aimed at doing just that. I haven't used it, or even read much about it yet but here it is if you're interested.
http://andyc.diy-audio-engineering.org/mso/html/index.html
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Hello Mindsource, how to fight with room mode is probably the endless subject, but I certainly couldn't get any good result with this Geddes idea.

When we bought Lipinski 707 (The world class MTM mastering monitor) + L150 subs, we struggled to locate subs in our studio. We already had a pair of Velodyne, so we experimentally happened to place those 4 subs all over the studio, but our conclusion was the subs should be located as close as possible to the main speakers. It is the least artificial sounding location for the bass. We human can locate the sub for some reasons. This is an experience in the very well acoustically controlled room, so the result might be different in the regular home theater, but I still believe it's better to place the subs as close as possible to the main, then reduce the room mode as much as possible with the conventional way, such as Owens Corning, EQ, resonator, etc.



My purpose is to build full range towers so locating the sub elsewhere isn't something I'd do with this project, much for the reason described above that I can easily locate bass down to 50hz or so (and I suspect most if not all people can).

However I am considering adding a 15 or 18" pro audio subwoofer to take on the low end 20-50hz or so but I don't suspect it will be needed.

I really want to build one regardless, but you know how that goes =)
 
My purpose is to build full range towers so locating the sub elsewhere isn't something I'd do with this project, much for the reason described above that I can easily locate bass down to 50hz or so (and I suspect most if not all people can).

However I am considering adding a 15 or 18" pro audio subwoofer to take on the low end 20-50hz or so but I don't suspect it will be needed.

I really want to build one regardless, but you know how that goes =)
Depending on your room, you would be surprised how high a sub can be crossed. In one of my rooms, I can't cross any higher than 50hz, meanwhile in another room here I can get away with 200hz.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Depending on your room, you would be surprised how high a sub can be crossed. In one of my rooms, I can't cross any higher than 50hz, meanwhile in another room here I can get away with 200hz.



I've spent quite a bit of time EQing and measuring my listening room, it has no purposeful treatment thus far (that's a future project), has a nice room gain right in the listening position against the wall, Alison Effect in the 150hz range, planning on experimenting in the 100-150hz range initially.
 
My purpose is to build full range towers so locating the sub elsewhere isn't something I'd do with this project, much for the reason described above that I can easily locate bass down to 50hz or so (and I suspect most if not all people can).

However I am considering adding a 15 or 18" pro audio subwoofer to take on the low end 20-50hz or so but I don't suspect it will be needed.

I really want to build one regardless, but you know how that goes =)

Great. One question is how you would time / phase align the driver? I utilized (kind of) Keele linear phase method for my horn WTW, and it did work flawlessly. Actually, I started my DIY project very much like yours, but ended up buying used JBL. Call me looser.:D

http://www.diyaudio.com/forums/multi-way/237750-2x12-horn-speaker-design.html

The measurement link is on the page 3. Flat down only to 30Hz, though....

I'll follow your thread, it's very interesting!
 
All bracing finished and working on the front baffle, also got this Magnum 12" in from DIYSG and it's a beast!

Front baffle will be 1.5" thick.

2ebdc2a18b416d7df5b8dc67c05086af.jpg


4d22f41f5e7c77f2e3a63938f43b7973.jpg


41898506323a9cce32e24a642081bab7.jpg


e3178bc713e6dcc54aff8252ae7b9385.jpg



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Got some work done on the baffles

Here I'm flush mounting the 3" port tube from the rear.

53757a61a69633c54488501b576fbdac.jpg


Flush mounted the Mag 12 to the frame for cosmetics, including the front gasket this flange is 3/4" thick

4c87657407acd278bee7817bd92eaa7b.jpg


9232f43893f020c663ee99da96ccdf8f.jpg


c5a6a824dd007eac3156038f3d90b52f.jpg


872291e6819be0555469cf7d7174cb94.jpg


I threw a 1/2" round over on the back of the subwoofer opening.






Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Got out to the garage last night for an hour, front baffle is coming along

Flush mounted both Faitalpro 8" mids

82b10ad480c17e8a6b69e93aa0c28c15.jpg


3/4" roundover on back of baffle to allow mids to breathe.

1a4097994c50671384d19b2f84a440f1.jpg


Front baffle/s as it stands, next step is to roundover the port openings


08fe5d47fe8b251042c70f575a51268c.jpg


Started working on the flush mount for the Seos 10 horn, here is my plan. Initially make a flush cut around the outside of the horn with a 1/4" flush cut bit, that will created a negative ID pattern that is 1/4" larger than the horn per side. Then using that oversized pattern, do another trim cut using a 5/8" trim bit with a 3/8" bearing on it, which will create and undersized ID pattern exactly the size of the horn. Here is the start, more to come.

788a6a9fb5373f543db0cc600c37df75.jpg





Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Got a bunch done today, these guys are really coming together =)

First off I worked on flush mounting the Seos 10 horns...man flush mounting shapes like this is SO much more work than a round driver using a circle jig.

I went a different route than what I was planning before as this was much easier and well documented online. The pictures are sort of self explanatory, let me know if you have any questions.

692f032c5b22a8838bcf81522df474cb.jpg


42ecd541080e14105241c81cc6fd227d.jpg


073f77bf9376d6e8396a9a58209b077d.jpg


This is a pattern guide, I used a 3/4" which compensates for the 1/4" diameter of the router bit.

902b060b80a7a30d74233714faeafdd7.jpg


8afaa2f7cf421ad92f6b507753efc11e.jpg


And this is the finished template positioned on the enclosure ready use

02a55929ea947c91600bc60ef2198796.jpg


Test for to make sure

8b278e14f462a4a898c12e27bce61e45.jpg


Using this bit set to .2"

75c8fc1fd6e4ce8088d75a6863b18635.jpg


And done

95779d9da999628aace1ad7eab370934.jpg


Test fit wala

58a463f200ae3a6f55ceeef54516bdc0.jpg


5fe2868c048564fff5bb6eedfa8ddf42.jpg


Now that all the front baffle driver routing was done, I attached it to the enclosure

2ec9e6cf5751189faad3baf266dc56ee.jpg


3" Port tubes glued into the baffle, you can see the inside entrance flare

93bdfdafaa8aa32f2d9934b81970892c.jpg


From the front

975cbe5fa7f1a9689c4ab7fb2ec46343.jpg


And with 1.125" radius roundover

334bfef13575d86941d6bbc94275b0a7.jpg


My fingers for reference

f4afff87f59f719f8ef972763c808cdb.jpg


And making lots of dust, first lots of flush cutting, then 1.25" radius roundover on front baffle, back of enclosure got a .75" radius and other top edges .25" radius.

Come at me bro

19a11a55050643ed1839a1b3f1c0aa07.jpg


b342815585ea8e27416eb564b3d7c0c6.jpg


0eb35632ef226331a2d44390df3389c4.jpg


Before roundovers

ea3eee5afe0573a4f09fb87a53ca4d0e.jpg


After and where things stand

01ce7430bd1e7d26a34bffaa9e34ca15.jpg


Now lots of sanding and vacuuming!





Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Subscribed!

Nice work!!

Would you mind posting pictures of the tooling used for cutting and profiling the circular holes? What are the ancillaries to the router you use to cut a circular hole to a precise diameter and perfect circle?



Thanks glad you're enjoying it!

For all the circles I use a Jasper circle jig, I have the 7" and 18" version. Like this

9790b886540721d6c179c3216c1a4eb3.jpg



For the larger size roundovers Magnate makes awesome router bits available on Amazon.

HTH!
 
Status
This old topic is closed. If you want to reopen this topic, contact a moderator using the "Report Post" button.