You have me at loss on that one. While obviously just hitting something isn't scientifically rigorous, why is it worthless? Simple mechanical excitation says nothing of value about a material's resonances? I fully understand the final result must take into account the susceptibility and frequencies of the devices mounted on the chassis.
You're correct, I only said it was unscientific. You may rap on a piece of metal and the sound may seem to damp quickly, but it may still be oscillating (inaudibly) enough to make a difference. See nhuwar's post above for one method of analyzing the material in question.
All of my input to this discussion only pertains to metals.
John