Hi keantoken, thanks for contributing some analysis
Your sums seem to assume that this figure of 500 is measured at 0 V Vce but this won't be the case. Anyway, accounting for the actual value of Vce for this measurement would only make a small difference to your calculations.
…
(emphasis added by me). These two statements do not appear to be in agreement. What am I missing?
I'd like to fully agree. But if simulation work is rudely bashed by certain people around here, then one simply has to stay away.Hi keantoken, thanks for contributing some analysis
Have fun.
I'm not sure if the earlier comments RE: simulation were being directed at you; certainly I didn't read it that way and thought they were just more general. I view the ability to use "ideal" components in simulation as one of simulation's most powerful benefits. So thank you for your contributions also.
Whilst I would have to agree that in the end, measurement (as long as it's been done properly) is reality, I also agree with Bob that if simulation and measurement disagree to a very large extent, further investigation is required and it is possible that the error lies in the measurement method (this final comment is meant as a general one rather than aimed at anything specific being currently discussed).
Last edited:
Why did your link disappear? Thanks for the article; I've only read about a page so far but it's well written, and looks really useful and relevant to the discussion at hand.
It seems that the article was taken down, it is still in the index here but the
link no longer works: ~ Scanned and cleaned up Wireless World Articles ~
So (I thought) go measure (build something on the realty plane
But... new hurdles pop-up, anyone? what is this difference between I(R1) and Ib(Q1)?
O.k. I see it, I'm an idiot
sorry, 100kOhm was to small an resistor Attachments
That I can solve:
Goto Internet Archive: Wayback Machine
Enter the URL
Select a date (I used early 2014)
Open the PDF
Worked for me
That I can solve:
Goto Internet Archive: Wayback Machine
Enter the URL
Select a date (I used early 2014)
Open the PDF
Worked for me
The normal link works for me!
Took a while for me to spot it too! Current in C1, R2, C3, R6 (input network to current-measuring in-amp).
The normal link did not work for me, the solution did, as it will do for the OP
I will do that, the network was there as some kind of a safety and to make other measurements possible (and it removes the DC component of Ib).