200W MOSFET CFA amp

Disabled Account
Joined 2012
Not always -- but often a lot of time and money goes into making a recording of a performance which includes its sound. For myself, I want to hear it as intended by the musicians and producer and intended for us to hear it the same way.. No more and no less.

As for designing out any and all distortion is always a challenge to designers to do their best effort.

THx,
-Richard
 
Ok bimo you got me sold, I am immediately ordering the flights tickets to Indonesia! :)

If you have presented your design somewhere on the net I would be happy to have a look at it, any link?
Edit: ok maybe I found your amp, if it is on the Anistardi Wordpress page?
.

The accurate amp is only for commercial, sorry.
But you can find my other design in my blog, in this forum, and a facebook's group. I think they are "good enough" for most people.
 
Not always -- but often a lot of time and money goes into making a recording of a performance which includes its sound. For myself, I want to hear it as intended by the musicians and producer and intended for us to hear it the same way.. No more and no less.

As for designing out any and all distortion is always a challenge to designers to do their best effort.

THx,
-Richard

Richard, haw is going over there in Bangkok?
BR Damir
 
If someone interested in 200W CFA version I sell two assembled and tested boards, please PM me.
Damir
 

Attachments

  • 200W-VMOSFET-newPCB-5-b.jpg
    200W-VMOSFET-newPCB-5-b.jpg
    403 KB · Views: 801
  • DSC00078.JPG
    DSC00078.JPG
    597.3 KB · Views: 782
  • DSC00075.JPG
    DSC00075.JPG
    709.7 KB · Views: 754
Disabled Account
Joined 2012
This is a really really good design. The distortion is extreamly low --- however, what is most unusual is that the distortion doesn't change much for any reason... at any freq, power output, load Z..... stays low under all contditiions.

At a very low B2 Ohm load, the THD at 1KHz and 200W was still only .0005%



THx-RNMarsh
 
Last edited:
This is the point at which one needs to voice the amplifier.
I don't think it should be a good idea to use this amp as a guitar amplifier. Tubes are better for this purpose.

You are on a thread of a designer which did a miracle, reaching one of the lowest distortion number i have seen in this power range, while keeping very high speed (400V/µs).
And here you come, saying "add distortion" ?

A "HIFI" amplifier is NOT a musical instrument. The signal at its output has to be as close as possible to the signal at its input.

And, yes, better will be your system, more you will discover the defects in recordings.

All circuits produce distortion. While the aim is rightly to minimise THD, IMD, etc.the profile can be tailored to make it sound more euphonic. That's all I want to say.

If a design produce distortion high enough to be audible, of course, it is a good idea to try to have-it as agreeable as possible. (pair harmonic dominant).
What can be the audibility of any distortion at < -100dB from the signal in your opinion ?
 
Last edited:
A "HIFI" amplifier is NOT a musical instrument. The signal at its output has to be as close as possible to the signal at its input.
I want to support that.

If you audition a really good amp, it will *not* unpleasently magnify minor shortcommings of a decent recording. Rather, it will tend to integrate all into an enjoyable overall picture. Especially, true neutrality in timbre leads to this perhaps surprising effect. (There are, of course, exceptions.)

In my limited experience, this is true for some totally linear amps with excellent (e.g., 0.001% THD) distortion performance.

Matthias
 
Last edited:
Damir:

I saw your message about a set of populated & tested 200W CFA boards.
Are you aware of any plans for any other (unpopulated) PCB group buys of the latest vintage of your 200W (or 100W) CFA?

Thanks,
mlloyd1

I don't have any board left, but if there interest for 200W or 100W versions I could order some more boards but minimum is 10 boards of the same kind.
Damir
 
This is a really really good design. The distortion is extreamly low --- however, what is most unusual is that the distortion doesn't change much for any reason... at any freq, power output, load Z..... stays low under all contditiions.
Richard, why don't you publish a complete set of measurements of this amp in one and unique PDF. For the moment it requires an adventurous navigation between lot of messages in this thread.
 
Does the index in post 1 give you what you need?
What is missing from that index?
As I said, not everything is in one place.
It is a suggestion to Dadod too:
One web page with schematics (and prices), LTSPICE models, BOM (with sources), recommendations (quiescent current tuning, minimal cooler's value etc.) and photos of builds, plus a complete set of measurements, wave forms etc.

Dadod, if you need help to write the web page, I'm your man.