John Curl's Blowtorch preamplifier part II

Status
Not open for further replies.
64!!! Just the heater puts out 30 watts a tube. That's 2 kW right there and we haven't even turned on the plate supply....

I suppose it would be a good idea if you wanted to run a steam plant or a glass-blowing facility or maybe even if you owned stock in the electric company...

I bet it sounded great before you ran from the room screaming, with thermal burns on the exposed parts of your body!
 
They were toasty. 32 tubes (64 sections) per side. The CCS loads (2SJ49) pumped out a few BTUs as well. We ran them for a total of 40 minutes as a demo for the editor of Audio Update (that dates me!), then never again. He put a photo on the cover and actually treated it seriously in his article.

I still have the tubes, the FETs, and the chassis.
 
Scott, there is a difference between 'mid fi' and 'high end'. Charles and I tend to design 'high end' and are proud of it! We get laughed at here for doing it, but we are proud and competitive anyway. Congratulations, Charles for getting an 'A' rating this month on your new preamp in 'Stereophile', AND it's cheaper than the JC-2 as well. Just wait! You have my 'blood up' now! Now, I will have to recall a JC-2 and see what can be 'improved'. Servos come to mind. 'Keep on Truckin'
 
If I'm not mistaken, you built a homebrew discrete JFET phono stage with zero feedback one time. I guess you don't use it any more as you have likely switched to digital.

But if you still have your vinyl rig, try comparing your own ancient device against the modern IC's that ADI sells. Then tell me that op-amps aren't mid-fi. If I'm wrong, ADI will sell a lot of IC's this year...

Just as I don't understand "high-end" designers that put pre-packaged class-D modules in their power amps, I don't understand why someone would use pre-packaged IC op-amps in other parts of their system.

Well, I have to take back part of that last statement. I actually do use 3-pin voltage regulators, because they are cheap, simple, and easy to use -- but only for non-critical digital circuits such as the display or the display uC. If I ever start running them in critical applications, you can take away my "high-end" license and issue me a mid-fi citation.
 
Congratulations, Charles for getting an 'A' rating this month on your new preamp in 'Stereophile', AND it's cheaper than the JC-2 as well.

Thanks, John. Do you want me to twist the knife?

The K-5xeMP is made in the US with a US chassis, US transformer, US PCBs, Roederstein resistors (actually Beyschlag now...), a mix of Wima and Rel-Caps. The only thing from the Far East are the RCA connectors we have custom-made for us there. Oh, and the Toshiba JFETs!

Just wait! You have my 'blood up' now! Now, I will have to recall a JC-2 and see what can be 'improved'. Servos come to mind. 'Keep on Truckin'

In the immortal words of "W"..."Bring 'em on!"

YouTube - President George W. Bush Says "Bring 'em on"

(Also known as, "Servos? We hain't gotch no servos...We don't need no servos...I don't have to show you any steenkin' servos!!!")

YouTube - We don't need no stinking badges!
 
Does ANYBODY on this thread care if their op-amp draws 2 mils or 20 mils? NO!

I do :D Maybe that's my pro audio background showing though - console designers use rather a lot of opamps, and for power consumption to go up a factor of 10 would be a complete no-no. Its already tough enough keeping heat under control.

But Apple does. And as Apple goes, so goes the world...

Sometimes I do wonder if Apple really is the canary in the coal-mine.
 
Gee, Scott, we wouldn't have to if Analog Devices made any good sounding parts. The only one that is even close is the ancient AD844 (you were kind enough to measure some resistor values on it for me a decade or so ago), but they moved it from a 4" fab to a 6" fab and now 20% of the parts are noisy.

And where are the ADI parts with complementary differential JFET inputs? PMA did an analysis on this very thread (or was it the previous one?) that showed an unsurpassed performance from this topology.

BUT it's too much trouble for the big IC companies to make. So they just make the stuff that's easy. The biggest driving force in IC design right now (besides lowering costs!) is to reduce power consumption. Does ANYBODY on this thread care if their op-amp draws 2 mils or 20 mils? NO! But Apple does. And as Apple goes, so goes the world...

That's why there is mid-fi and a separate category called "high-end".
I dunno what a 4" or 6" fab is but I did not notice a changed noise spec in the AD844 dataheet.
I also noticed the reduced power consumption trend.
With 4 ICs in my DAC and a 30 Watt power transformer it's hardly relevant.
 
If I'm not mistaken, you built a homebrew discrete JFET phono stage with zero feedback one time. I guess you don't use it any more as you have likely switched to digital.

But if you still have your vinyl rig, try comparing your own ancient device against the modern IC's that ADI sells. Then tell me that op-amps aren't mid-fi. If I'm wrong, ADI will sell a lot of IC's this year...

In fact we just added a couple of rooms to our offgrid house and I'm fixing to set my rig up to transfer the rest of my LP's that can't be replaced. All battery set up, +-12V @ 250A directly from 25' of 0000 welding cable. Do you honestly think something like the AD8559 is not up to making a phono front end? I'll probably stick with a pile of JFET's, I haven't listened through IC's since Walt and I did the AD624 preamp in 1982.

Not much point in doing an A/B you guys wouldn't listen without peeking, too much to lose.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.