Thanks everyone for letting me know that the compensation cap can be tuned by ears. Initially I was skeptical even tho all the experts had confirmed the fact
p). But after Bigun mentioning the phase lag thing suddenly I realized Still, LC has not confirmed about the cap. Small one could be issue, but none couldn't be, as long as it is stable?
It may be that a Vbe multiplier is required. I can't see the current for the drivers being very stable, and it directly affects output bias in this version. It's not clear to me that a current source, instead of a resistor (plus trimmer) will have much affect on reaching a stable equilibrium. Cascoding the drivers might help by reducing the dissipation.
But I think something else is amiss also, as I see significant distortion in the waveform when driving an 8 Ohm load. With a load, it overshoots, but doesn't settles. With no load, it rings quite a bit. I built it up first without the Miller comp caps. I'm pretty sure it was oscillating. I replaced the drivers, when I added the compensation caps. I'm wondering if oscillation could have damaged the outputs too.
I'm not sure I want to chase this down for the TT version. Maybe Nico's design is the way to go for a simple version of the amp.
Sheldon
Member
Joined 2009
Paid Member
I realized this is a feature of all symmetrical BJT VAS designs - at least those I've seen. I noticed that the Bryston amp I have, which is also a symmetrical VAS, uses large emitter degeneration resistors on the VAS. So I also used large degeneration resistors on the VAS of my TGM5 amplifier. I believe it helps to reduce sensitivity of the VAS current to operating conditions.
I went through the same issues in TGM5, albeit in Spice simulations. I concluded that the VAS current would not be stable enough to guarantee good output bias without paying some attention to the Vbe multiplier. I ended up using a design from Hagerman. I don't find the output bias as stable as my TGM1 but it appears to do the job well enough. In fact, the amp has been more stable with respect to temperature than I had feared, both bias and dc offset.
I used small compensation caps on both the VAS and the pre-drivers of the Triple output stage.
This topology sounds good, it's worth persevering.
Last edited:
I believe that the reason for the temperature sensitive VAS is the fact that is also current vise dependent on the input-stage, so two thermal issues is playing a role, and as none of them is driven by a CCS, you will run into thermal problems...This circuit sounds fantastic, but needs better household...!! The Salas Jfet is good for the VAS, bur does not solve the input-stage current dependency
Member
Joined 2009
Paid Member
My sims also highlighted this. I actually found you can fix this by incorporating a thermistor in the circuit but that seems like a kludge. In the end, I didn't find thermal stability to be an issue. But there's an opportunity still to improve it - but achieving that without spoiling the topology doesn't look trivial.
That is why the input stage VR (trimmer) CCSs got to be BF245s as well. One of those variable.
Look alive to the thermal offsets.Guys have to go out, urgently (Friday's eve) .. I'll be back soon
About 2.2mA, with 8ma of driver current, 2.35mA with 12mA driver current. Same for both sides. Thermal drift for inputs is much lower than for the drivers.
Sheldon
Hi guys, me back
I really like the simplicitiy of the input stage and splitted feedback and all about SSA, so I decided to solve thermal stability issue in a simple manner. Of course one could do it by adding BJT's, OP amps, etc., but than this would become something else. The simplest solution of them all is to put NTC + serial resistor in parallel to 100 uF in feedback bridge. NTC must be thermally coupled with the input pair BJT-s and serial resistor is serving to lock the NTC to be in exact proportion to input's Vbe thermal drift. At the end VAS bias current is stabilized to 10 mA from cold start to any thermal condition there is.
And some pictures to show how SSA BIGBT HP should look at the end.
I really like the simplicitiy of the input stage and splitted feedback and all about SSA, so I decided to solve thermal stability issue in a simple manner. Of course one could do it by adding BJT's, OP amps, etc., but than this would become something else. The simplest solution of them all is to put NTC + serial resistor in parallel to 100 uF in feedback bridge. NTC must be thermally coupled with the input pair BJT-s and serial resistor is serving to lock the NTC to be in exact proportion to input's Vbe thermal drift. At the end VAS bias current is stabilized to 10 mA from cold start to any thermal condition there is.
And some pictures to show how SSA BIGBT HP should look at the end.
Attachments
- Status
- This old topic is closed. If you want to reopen this topic, contact a moderator using the "Report Post" button.