Go Back   Home > Forums > >
Home Forums Rules Articles diyAudio Store Blogs Gallery Wiki Register Donations FAQ Calendar Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read

Planars & Exotics ESL's, planars, and alternative technologies

Advice wanted
Advice wanted
Please consider donating to help us continue to serve you.

Ads on/off / Custom Title / More PMs / More album space / Advanced printing & mass image saving
Reply
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Old 25th July 2005, 11:12 AM   #1
bret is offline bret  South Africa
diyAudio Member
 
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: Johannesburg, South Africa
Default Advice wanted

I am planning on building my first ESL's. I have eventually sourced perforated mild steel sheets and 12 micron Mylar (the thinnest currently being imported into South Africa where I live). I think I will use 3m double-sided tape for spacers and liquid soap (at least initially) for coating the diaphragm. Ideally I would like to have an ESL panel/panels covering mid/high and a dipole woofer for the base (crossed as low as feasible given the other constraints).

I only know what I have read on the net. I am sure that the books on the subject (e.g. by Roger Sanders) would be very useful. But if I do order one, it would be weeks before it arrives.

Deciding what design to go with is not an easy matter. I would like a sufficiently large sweet spot for at leat two listeners at a distance of about 4m. For this reason, it seems to me that I should be making the panels tall and narrow, not wider than a foot (maybe as narrow as 3 inches) and about five feet high. Is is better to make one panel or stack two smaller ones?

As regards the stators, what hole size is optimum? I can choose almost anything. I was thinking around 3mm, but this is completely arbitrary. Also what thickness is best? 1mm? 1.6mm?

Almost all of the ESLs I have looked at have no added baffle width. Would this not be useful to cancel dipole cancellation at low frequencies, particularly for narrow panels? I haven't done the math, but maybe 6 to 12 inches added on either side. Does this give unwanted baffle step or diffraction effects? This also raises the question of how thick the baffle can/should be.

My biggest obstacle at this stage is the audio transformers. I have not managed to source any locally and I think it would probably be significantly cheaper to get them custom wound than importing them. The local import duties and shipment costs are pricey. Are technical details available anywhere or can somebody help me on this? I would like to stick to one audio transformer per side.

Any advice the list could offer would be much appreciated. I wish I had endless supplies of money and time to spend on research and experimentation...

As an aside, has anybody ever tried using a "digital" amplifier with an internal step-up transformer? It seems to me that such a beast could be directly coupled. The negative feedback would come from after the transformer (via a resistor divider?). Wouldn't this give much better control of the speaker? Presumably a lot of the LC effects could be greatly reduced. Switching noise at these voltages may be an issue though.

Bret
  Reply With Quote
Old 25th July 2005, 12:07 PM   #2
jmateus is offline jmateus  United States
diyAudio Member
 
jmateus's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: US, New Jersey
Default ESL advice

I can see that you are in the same boat as I was 3 years ago,
not knowing too much about building ESL panels and reading all
I could find about it. Another issue I had in common with you was
the "budget" wich is to be taken in consideration in an endeavour
like this.
My spacers were done in PVC also 3 mm thickness. PCV is an
excellent material to use for spacers, they are practically immune to temperature
changes and humidity. They are not cheap though... However they
can be very forgiven if you are to disassemble the panels, because
you can always to get rid of the glue used to glue the diaphragms.
By the way you should use Polyerethene glue which is powerful and
also independent of humidity. Actually it works better with a certain
degree of moisture...
I made my panels 12 inches wide and around 5 feet tall, that worked
very well for its sonic qualities, however I segmented the panels
puting two 2,5 feet panels on top of each other. I really don't
recommend to make them narrower than 12 inches unless you
want to make a tweeter element which in this case should be 2 to
2.5 inches.
This big issue and where the beef is, the audio transformer. The
prices are astronomical if you are to consider a very good quality transformer. My option was to use two transformers from a
delapidated tube amplifier and even thouhg is not the very best
as the turns ratio are considered, it suits the purpose and I
got good results with them. So, if you have access to an old and
beaten tube amplifier this is the way to go, the transformer is
wired backwards the secondary to the output of the amplifier,
the primary with the center tap to the minus side of the HV
supply.
These is my modest contribuition, I hope you are to succed as
I was even though with a lot of frustation and difficulties, as
you can imagine.
John
__________________
JLH 2005, Cyrus and so on...
  Reply With Quote
Old 26th July 2005, 08:00 AM   #3
bret is offline bret  South Africa
diyAudio Member
 
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: Johannesburg, South Africa
Default More questions re ESLs

Thanks for your input John. What performance do you get from your ESLs in terms of frequency response and sensitivity? Do you cross to a conventional woofer? 3mm spacing implies that you have some fairly low frequencies in your panels.

As regards the last comment in my post re switching amplifiers, I went and actually looked at the Application/Test Circuit for the TP2150B. The feedback comes before the reactive components, not after. Nevertheless, it still seems to me that a Class D amplifier would be far more suited to ESLs than a class AB. To use a term not normally associated with audio, ESLs have a very low power factor, i.e. a mostly reactive load. When driven by a class AB amplifier, peak currents occur when almost the full rail voltage is across the output devices and hence far more power is dissapated in the amp than the panels. The efficiency improvements of a class D amplifier would be even more pronounced than with conventional cone drivers.

Presumably the inductor in a class D amp would not be necessary as the inductance could be provided by the audio transformer.
Also, the power supply would need to be a lot less beefy. I am not sure if I am missing anything here.

I still have questions I would like advice on from my first post, including:
- optimum stator hole size
- increasing the baffle width
- audio transformer winding

Bret
  Reply With Quote
Old 27th July 2005, 12:34 PM   #4
jmateus is offline jmateus  United States
diyAudio Member
 
jmateus's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: US, New Jersey
Default ESL questions

Sorry for the delay, things have been quite hectic around here.

Yes, I cross over the ESL to a subwoofer around 200 HZ and this is
acomplished by an active 24 db crossover even though I really donīt
quite like it, when I take the crossover out of the circuit the sound
is much more transparent and the frequency response seems to
be better. Even though the crossover has top quality components
(high quality ICīs and polypropylene caps) the sound is quite muffled
compared to running the ESL directly from the amplifier. One thing
that I have to try is to use a passive line crossover but thatīs another
story all together.
The hole diameter on the stators is 3,5 mm which at the time was
what I could find, however even 4 mm is alright.
Of course you can always increase the width size but from the pratical
point itīs something that only you could determine, I guess that
increase could lead to a lower response with the same 3 mm spacer
thickness.
Transformer winding is something that I donīt have any experience
with and I think it would be a difficult endeavour if you are not
really experienced dealing with transformer windings. We are
talking here about a LOT of turns believe me... Like I said before
your best bet would be to buying already made trafos even
if you consider its relatively high price. Gary Waldron had trafos
for sale sometime ago for $48 each, designed specifically for
ESL however this has been a while ago and when I tried to get
a hold of him to buy those his e-mail adress wasnīt operative
anymore and his web site was also outdated. I donīt know
what happened and Iīm convinced that it is not up and running
again (has been a while...)
Of course the other alternative is a tube amplifier transformer...

Now the class D amplifiers.
Sometime ago I bought one of those class T amplifiers, the
Sonic Impact job that used to sell for around 20 bucks. The
amplifier sounded really well with dynamic speakers even though it didnīt have too much power. I thought I would give it a try with
my ESL, well to make the story short, it blew right before my
eyes! I guess it didnīt like the ESL, since then Iīve tried to get
some input from this forum as far as other amplifiers including
the UCD modules and others. Nobody is very positive about it
and I donīt think Iīm going to risk a few hundred dollars just
on a experience in which I donīt have the minimum assurance
that is going to be succeful.
This is the whole story about the class D amplifiers if I had a
lot of money to waste I would do it but unfortunately I canīt.
The same thing applies to Class AB amplifiers, some (the majority)
cannot drive the ESL others may be and I donīt want to risk
anymore of my stuff, I rather stick with the ones I know very
capable of driving them, the tube amplifiers and class A amps.
I have a JLH 40 watt amplifier that drives the ESL beautifully.
If I could give you anymore details of what I know about ESL
please feel free to say.
Regards
much power
__________________
JLH 2005, Cyrus and so on...
  Reply With Quote
Old 27th July 2005, 12:40 PM   #5
jmateus is offline jmateus  United States
diyAudio Member
 
jmateus's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: US, New Jersey
Default ESL questions

I forgot to tell you that the way they are the response of my ESL go
down to about 55 to 60 Hz running them without the sub you can
ear low frequencies around those but of course they donīt have the
same level as the other, they are still useful but not enough. This
is the reason why Iīm using the sub but of course I already knew that before I built the ESL. I ran a test (several tests) with different confi-
gurations and my conclusion was that I would have to use the sub.
I hope this helps.
__________________
JLH 2005, Cyrus and so on...
  Reply With Quote
Old 28th July 2005, 11:18 AM   #6
bret is offline bret  South Africa
diyAudio Member
 
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: Johannesburg, South Africa
I was originally considering crossing at around 200Hz as well. But I am sure it would improve things if I could cross to 100Hz or lower. Obviously this all depends on the ES panels and what kind of performance I can get.

By my reckoning, dipole cancellation (from omni-directional drivers) should start at a much higher frequency than the 200Hz you are crossing at. It is obviously negated by the directionality of the panels.

I am not sure what kind of excursion you get at 100Hz, but would it not be possible to add some equalization to extend the low frequency response?

As for transformers, I had the same attitude as you until I started reading dhenryp's thread on has ribbon array. He would he own transformer from apparently very little experience. Granted, it was very simple in comparison but I did a little more reading and it definitely doesn't seem to be an impossibility to wind my own, although it might be very time consuming.

I was concerned about the quality of transformers in the $50 price range. From what I have read, the transformer is likely to be at least as great as source of distortion as the panel. The transformer seems (I may be way off the mark here) to be the critical item in the whole ESL. I could potentially hand wind a toroid with a few (hopefully not too many) hours of labour. I would presume the performance would be better than an E-I core, which seems to be the standard. I need more data on the subject and it is not very easy to come across.

Class D amplifiers still seem like a good solution to me. Why yours fried is a bit of a mystery. The ESL is a far more complex load than a 4/8 ohm cone driver. Maybe some additional compensation is needed to prevent instability. I may ask this question elsewhere.

Bret
  Reply With Quote
Old 28th July 2005, 01:16 PM   #7
jmateus is offline jmateus  United States
diyAudio Member
 
jmateus's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: US, New Jersey
Default ESL build up

Hi Bret

Yes, itīs definitely possible to add equalization to the low frequencies
but be careful with that, you donīt want too much boost otherwise
is going to affect the performance of the ESL exactly on the excursion
of the panels, too much is too much for the panels. There are schemas
of that on the Web (the audio circuit is the place to check). I really do
not like this type of boost I always see this arrangement as an unatural
way of modifying what seems to be natural coming out of the panels,
but thatīs me talking.
Yes, youīre right, the cheap transformers have always the drawback
as being...cheap. However the ones I cited from Barry had a very
good report quality/price and that was mentioned by various people
especially on that site http://www.audiocircuit.com. Actually if you
have never visited this site it's a very worthwhile experience to do
is a wealth good source of information on ESL. When you open it
click on Loudspeakers and again on Electrostatics, you're going to
find lots of information.
On the class D subject I sugest you ask in this forum again even though
I couldn't find definitive answers, some people responded but with
no assertive information that I could use. May be you get lucky...
Last but not the least I've read somewhere that toroids weren't very well suited for electrostatics don't know why, but don't quote
me on this, it's something in the back of my mind that I can't
recall.
__________________
JLH 2005, Cyrus and so on...
  Reply With Quote
Old 28th July 2005, 01:47 PM   #8
bret is offline bret  South Africa
diyAudio Member
 
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: Johannesburg, South Africa
Thanks for the advice John. I have spent some time looking at http://www.audiocircuit.com and I agree that there is a lot of useful information.

It is a pity that the http://www.eslinformation4u.com site no longer seems to exist. Any other suggestions for well priced, good quality audio transformers?
  Reply With Quote
Old 29th July 2005, 09:22 AM   #9
bret is offline bret  South Africa
diyAudio Member
 
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: Johannesburg, South Africa
Question Possible transformer

How about the Hammond 1650F?
  Reply With Quote
Old 2nd August 2005, 01:22 PM   #10
jmateus is offline jmateus  United States
diyAudio Member
 
jmateus's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: US, New Jersey
Default Hammond P-T1650F

I think you should choose your transformer (since you decide to go
for a tube transformer) with a bit less primary impedance because
this will translate in more turns ratio.
The P-T1650K has an impedance of 3,400 CT ohms, is rated for 50 W
and even though itīs about $20 more expensive it represents a
better value over the F version which is only for 25 W.
I donīt know exactly the prices of these transformers in South Africa
but I figured these will be similar to the ones in the States.
Cheers
__________________
JLH 2005, Cyrus and so on...
  Reply With Quote

Reply


Advice wantedHide this!Advertise here!
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Accuton C95-T6, advice wanted Fred75 Multi-Way 20 2nd February 2009 11:18 AM
Advice wanted on 1541-kit Jolojl Digital Source 2 4th October 2007 07:48 AM
A new setup, advice wanted jgunn5066 Tubes / Valves 1 27th June 2005 09:19 AM
Wanted: Eagle advice pinkmouse Everything Else 9 25th February 2005 03:03 PM
Unregulated PSU advice wanted falcott Chip Amps 2 26th August 2004 06:01 AM


New To Site? Need Help?

All times are GMT. The time now is 10:47 AM.


Search Engine Optimisation provided by DragonByte SEO (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2020 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.
Resources saved on this page: MySQL 15.79%
vBulletin Optimisation provided by vB Optimise (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2020 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.
Copyright ©1999-2020 diyAudio
Wiki