Why do transistors seem to come and go so quickly? Is there really a need for manufacturers to change them and retire them so quickly?
I need a 2SB649A. I understand that virtually all of these on ebay etc are fake and I can't find one at RS or Farnell or Mouser etc (I live in the UK). I have seen people glow all warm and bubbly about Cricklewood Electronics. First they told me they had real ones from Hitachi. Then when I questioned them on how they could be new when they hadn't been made for a decade they told me they cannot guarantee their 2SB649A's are real. All they could say is they had not recieved any complaints. Say no more. No sale. Now the NTE374 looks like an exact copy, but again problems.. Farnell and RS make this a special item whereby you have to pay an extra £10-16 even if you only want 1.You can get the odd NTE374 on ebay but are NTE's faked?
This is for my NAD C370 that has bit the dust. And I am a newbie to diy and repair, though I have an engineering degree so I should pick up things quickly. Though I expect what will actually happen is no-one will respond to this post. Cos I aint cool and flashy and making my own amps.. yet
I need a 2SB649A. I understand that virtually all of these on ebay etc are fake and I can't find one at RS or Farnell or Mouser etc (I live in the UK). I have seen people glow all warm and bubbly about Cricklewood Electronics. First they told me they had real ones from Hitachi. Then when I questioned them on how they could be new when they hadn't been made for a decade they told me they cannot guarantee their 2SB649A's are real. All they could say is they had not recieved any complaints. Say no more. No sale. Now the NTE374 looks like an exact copy, but again problems.. Farnell and RS make this a special item whereby you have to pay an extra £10-16 even if you only want 1.You can get the odd NTE374 on ebay but are NTE's faked?
This is for my NAD C370 that has bit the dust. And I am a newbie to diy and repair, though I have an engineering degree so I should pick up things quickly. Though I expect what will actually happen is no-one will respond to this post. Cos I aint cool and flashy and making my own amps.. yet
Last edited:
Am I right in thinking that on the power channel output side all trannies should be matched? But elsewhere say in the pre-power circuit equivalents will do and matching not quite so important....?
Are the NTE on ebay likely to be faked? Are fakers faking NTE?
Why is it so hard to get real parts? It's madness.
Last edited:
Usually not. Matching transistors show bad design (or High-End, that is the same
) (except for some special exceptions). You just have to check that they mutch some of their characteristics.Another reason you know they were lying is those parts were made by Hitachi, not Toshiba.
mlloyd1
Oops my bad, I meant Hitachi. Either way, they couldn't guarantee they were real. So they must be fake.
I wouldn't mind fake if it meant they had faked the characteristics and spec. I'm amazed at the shear scale of fakes out there. Virtually every semiconductor on ebay etc and from small shops is fake. Also upsetting is a lot of service technicians use these fake parts in repairs.
Last edited:
Cost - noone buys them in quantity, then you are losing money hand over fist keeping the production schedule active. These days the volume is in class-D amps, so linear stuff sells in way way less volume, the market consolidates to fewer popular transistors, plus some specialist semiconductor firms doing small runs.
That's usually because its in the US, not the UK, so you pay for the airmail/customs handling - the charge is per order not per part.
If you buy all the transistors at the same time and same source its likely they are from the same batch anyway so should be close.
- Status
- This old topic is closed. If you want to reopen this topic, contact a moderator using the "Report Post" button.