Beyma 10CMV2 vs Faital 10FE200 help

[Celsius]

How can I determine what is the better option ?

My amp is 20w tube amp.


Beyma --- Faital
Fs 52 Hz 55 Hz

Re 5.9 ohm 5.9 ohm

Qms 3.8 11.3

Qes 0.47 0.74

Qts 0.42 0.70

Vas 44 l 53,4

Cms 216 µm/n 0.34 mm/N

Rms 3.7 kg / s 0.75 Kg/s


Xmax 6.5 mm 4.67 mm
Coil 38,1mm 37 mm

mmd 42g 21,2g


60-5000 Hz 50÷4500 Hz

Faital

Beyma

 

[TBTL]

What are your goals?



Do you require a flat response without DSP? Then do they work in the box size you have available with the low frequency extension and efficiency you require?
Does the lower xmax of the Faital allow for sufficient low frequency SPL?
Can you find data on harmonic distortion?
Which one has a lower inductance? (one of the properties that are related to distortion)
Do you need performance at f > 1 kHz? The Beyma has a cone resonance at 3 kHz.


The large difference in mms suggests that for this Beyma woofer, the engineers put more priority on low frequency perfomance as compared to this Faital.

 

[Celsius]

What are your goals?

Do you require a flat response without DSP? Then do they work in the box size you have available with the low frequency extension and efficiency you require?
Does the lower xmax of the Faital allow for sufficient low frequency SPL?
Can you find data on harmonic distortion?
Which one has a lower inductance? (one of the properties that are related to distortion)
Do you need performance at f > 1 kHz? The Beyma has a cone resonance at 3 kHz.

The large difference in mms suggests that for this Beyma woofer, the engineers put more priority on low frequency perfomance as compared to this Faital.

two ways at 1800 khz.


Le Beyma 0.8mh Faital 0.42mh



I am a little worry with mmd faital 21g too soft but the rest of number seem good

 

[chris661]

If you're good at notch filters, go with the B&C. The 3kHz breakup needs taming, but other than that it looks pretty smooth.
The Faital Pro has breakup at more like 2kHz, which is close to the crossover frequency. Looks more benign, though, so might be easier to work with.

Chris

 

[zmyrna]

by just looking at the cone shape and structure of beyma, i would not use it for mid duties; nothing scientific, just IMHO

 

[Frabor]

Celsius,

I am building a econowave with a 10" lf. Wich one did you choose? I am liking more the faital.

 

[OscarS]

Based on my testing of top-tier 10" Beyma's and Faital Pro's, the Beymas will likely produce much lower harmonic distortion than the Faitals. But the lower damping of the Faitals will likely produce louder bass.

 

[CHANGGUIYONG]

Look at the size of FAITAL'S magnet and its basin rack. This process seems to be a heap of garbage in Chinese factories.

 

[kec]

Look at the size of FAITAL'S magnet and its basin rack. This process seems to be a heap of garbage in Chinese factories.

Uh, they're made in Italy.

 

[YSDR]

The mechanical resistance (Rms) of the Faital is impressively low.

 

[zmyrna]

faital fe200 series are very much like old skool wide range drivers: lightweight cone and low mechanical resistance. suitable for diy home audio projects IMO

 

[Audio Elite]

Look at the size of FAITAL'S magnet and its basin rack. This process seems to be a heap of garbage in Chinese factories.

You sir are obviously from another planet!
The Faital is Italian and is by far more musical than the Beyma.
I know both drivers and the Faital has better midrange clarity.
Chinese WTF