Peerless or Vifa Mid?

[PeteMcK]

Guys,

I'm planning a 3 way system based around the Peerless 850146 10" Woofer (Fs 22.6Hz, Qts 0.35, Vas 144.4L, ) in a big cabinet;

For the midrange, I'm tossing up between the Peerless 850488 5" (Fs 55Hz, Qts .3031, Vas 7.59L, ) or the well known Vifa P13WH-00-08 (Fs 60Hz, Qts .33, Vas 10L).

There doesn't seem to be much between them in specs or price;
anyone got an opinion as to which way I should go?

Probably use a Peerless tweeter, undecided as to which one yet (either 811827 or 810665)

Cheers,
Pete McK

 

[RobM]

Both those mids are nice, but I think the Peerless CSX 850108 is even better, especially on vocals and strings.