Tosted PW tranformer
I finally was able to do a bench test of a Tubelab SimpleSE that I've been working on for quite a while. In any case it sounds very nice! All for 10 minutes then I decided to flip the standby switch. The 5A fuse in my variac blew and likewise the 3A fuse in the amp's chassis. I replaced the fuses and this time I used a killawatt meter in front of the variac to measure current. The Hammond 274BX was buzzing loudly and drawing about 100watts at only 40 volts ac on the variac. I think the resistance on the 274's primaries was less than an ohm I think.
I think I shorted the primary my PW transformer. 🙁
Aside from making a doorstop out of the 274 is there anything I can do? Repair? Core exchange?
I finally was able to do a bench test of a Tubelab SimpleSE that I've been working on for quite a while. In any case it sounds very nice! All for 10 minutes then I decided to flip the standby switch. The 5A fuse in my variac blew and likewise the 3A fuse in the amp's chassis. I replaced the fuses and this time I used a killawatt meter in front of the variac to measure current. The Hammond 274BX was buzzing loudly and drawing about 100watts at only 40 volts ac on the variac. I think the resistance on the 274's primaries was less than an ohm I think.
I think I shorted the primary my PW transformer. 🙁
Aside from making a doorstop out of the 274 is there anything I can do? Repair? Core exchange?
Strange that the transformer started buzzing after you threw the standby switch...
Are you using solid state or tube rectifiers? With the power off and tube rectifier removed, use an ohm meter to check the wiring on the standby circuit and make sure you're not accidentally shorting a secondary to ground.
-- josé k.
Are you using solid state or tube rectifiers? With the power off and tube rectifier removed, use an ohm meter to check the wiring on the standby circuit and make sure you're not accidentally shorting a secondary to ground.
-- josé k.
Post a schematic of how you wired your power supply, and double check to make sure you really wired it that way.
Next disconnect everything except the primary and check to see whether or not the transformer is actually bad or you have a shorted component elsewhere..
How about rectification - tube or ss?
Snubber network on secondary of pt, switch or ?
Does your standby switch the transformer CT or something else?
Conventional switches have been known to short to chassis when used on the HV dc side of power supplies - particularly as the secondary winding creates an inductive kick when suddenly unloaded - that energy wants to go somewhere and usually what happens is the voltage rises as the field collapses until it arcs over somewhere that is unless you have made provisions for this issue.
Next disconnect everything except the primary and check to see whether or not the transformer is actually bad or you have a shorted component elsewhere..
How about rectification - tube or ss?
Snubber network on secondary of pt, switch or ?
Does your standby switch the transformer CT or something else?
Conventional switches have been known to short to chassis when used on the HV dc side of power supplies - particularly as the secondary winding creates an inductive kick when suddenly unloaded - that energy wants to go somewhere and usually what happens is the voltage rises as the field collapses until it arcs over somewhere that is unless you have made provisions for this issue.
Disconnect everything from the secondary side and leave them floating. Then repower the transformer and see if it still draws this much power. If not, check for a short further out in the circuit by reconnecting first the filaments and then the high voltage.
Victor
Victor
Note that although the primary winding resistance is relatively low, your measurement does not indicated that the primary is shorted. (DCR is usually low on primaries.) Most likely you have a wiring or design error as I mentioned above. You may get lucky or not.. (Dead short somewhere?)
Thanks everyone. I pulled the rectifier tube out and still the same problem. A lot of current. Then I disconnected the high voltage secondary and tried again. The transformer was pulling about 25 watts and the tube heaters were glowing happily. No buzzing. I'm embarrased I made a quick assumption about the PW tranny.
There appears to be a short somewhere on the PCB. I do have the rectifier diodes on the PCB although I'm not using them. Nothing appears to be charred or melted.
I'll try to get a photo posted soon.
There appears to be a short somewhere on the PCB. I do have the rectifier diodes on the PCB although I'm not using them. Nothing appears to be charred or melted.
I'll try to get a photo posted soon.
Here the innards:
http://mysite.verizon.net/oldamps/simplebot.JPG
In the photo I've detached one end of the power transformer's primary.
In hindsight I would have put the fuse inbetween the power socket and power switch.
The wiring is for tube rectification, and triode output with no feedback. The center tap of the secondary is the standby, but I'm undone that by now. Simple is better.
http://mysite.verizon.net/oldamps/simplebot.JPG
In the photo I've detached one end of the power transformer's primary.
In hindsight I would have put the fuse inbetween the power socket and power switch.
The wiring is for tube rectification, and triode output with no feedback. The center tap of the secondary is the standby, but I'm undone that by now. Simple is better.
Here's another photo
An externally hosted image should be here but it was not working when we last tested it.
The big motor run cap is not actually attached yet, but I included it in the photo so I wouldn't have to take photos again.
I have a cage for the top too. Kidproofing and clumsy me proofing.
I have a cage for the top too. Kidproofing and clumsy me proofing.
whitelabrat said:
Please check the assembly instructions for the board. Are you allowed to have both the tube and diode rectifiers installed simultaneously?
-- josé k.
Here's the schematic, including the power supply.
http://www.tubelab.com/AssemblyManualSimpleSE/schematic_SSE.htm
How exactly did you configure the power supply?
-- josé k.
http://www.tubelab.com/AssemblyManualSimpleSE/schematic_SSE.htm
How exactly did you configure the power supply?
-- josé k.
Many folks have the board switchable between solid state and tube rectification with a switch so it shouldn't be a problem. By not shorting the terminals for choosing rectification the board should default to tube rectification.
I'm thinking I should pull the solid state diodes out, but they don't seem to be shorted according to my multimeter. I'll need to take a closer look.
Check out tubelab.com for more details.
I've also got a high-rez link to a photo that should make it easy to see the wiring.
I'm thinking I should pull the solid state diodes out, but they don't seem to be shorted according to my multimeter. I'll need to take a closer look.
Check out tubelab.com for more details.
I've also got a high-rez link to a photo that should make it easy to see the wiring.
Hi whitelabrat:
Remove the FRED diodes and try the amp again using the tube rectifier. There have been some issues with IXYS diodes blowing when the standby switch is flipped. They often test OK. The amp will work without them. They are only used in the SS rectifier mode, but when one dies it makes the transformer really unhappy. Unless you ran the transformer with a dead doide and no fuse for a long while it will be fine.
You should have a fuse in the circuit between the line input and the power transformer. 2 amp in 120 volt countries, 1 amp in 240 volt world.
I am 1200 miles from home, and missed the start of this thread. Just got DSL installed here, like 10 minutes ago.
Remove the FRED diodes and try the amp again using the tube rectifier. There have been some issues with IXYS diodes blowing when the standby switch is flipped. They often test OK. The amp will work without them. They are only used in the SS rectifier mode, but when one dies it makes the transformer really unhappy. Unless you ran the transformer with a dead doide and no fuse for a long while it will be fine.
You should have a fuse in the circuit between the line input and the power transformer. 2 amp in 120 volt countries, 1 amp in 240 volt world.
I am 1200 miles from home, and missed the start of this thread. Just got DSL installed here, like 10 minutes ago.
Thanks George!!!
A personal thanks for the awesom board and instructions! For the 10 minutes I was up and runnging... It sounded fantastic!!!
A personal thanks for the awesom board and instructions! For the 10 minutes I was up and runnging... It sounded fantastic!!!
Ok. I yanked the Freds off the board. Rock and roll! Literally!
The solid state diodes shorted. All is well. Sounds great!
The solid state diodes shorted. All is well. Sounds great!
I had a very similar problem with my SimpleSE. After removing the solid state diodes, I was still using the standby switch with a JJ 5AR4 and eventually fried the rectifier tube as well. My solution was to remove the solid state diodes and also remove the standby switch. No problems since. Here is a link to a very similar problem with an EL84 PP design. Similar standby switch implementation with similar failures. http://www.diytube.com/phpBB2/viewtopic.php?t=493
Hope you don't have any more problems. Apart from this, my SimpleSE has been great!
Chris
Hope you don't have any more problems. Apart from this, my SimpleSE has been great!
Chris
I saw the same post for the Diytube ST35 board. I just got one recently and realized that the standby switch issue applies to the SimpleSE as well. I'll be using the ST35 board for a project to salvage an old PP EL84 amp.
I've done away with the switch and the diodes on the SimpleSE and I've had reliable operation for just about a week now.
Also another thing I've discovered. I've gone around and done a sampling of the resistance of the primary side of several power transformers. They all seem to be less than 2 ohms.
I've done away with the switch and the diodes on the SimpleSE and I've had reliable operation for just about a week now.
Also another thing I've discovered. I've gone around and done a sampling of the resistance of the primary side of several power transformers. They all seem to be less than 2 ohms.
- Status
- Not open for further replies.