It looks to me like "Kiwame" resistors are really just KOA SPR2 and SPR5 carbon film resistors.
I got some 8.2k KOA SPR2 resistors in Japan for 4 cents each. I just compared them to 8.2k 2W Kiwame resitors.
I cannot find any differences between them.
Both have non-magnetic leads and end caps, which look by eye to be the same material. Both appear identical externally, and also inside the green coating (which I scraped away with a knife).
I measured 20 pcs. of the KOA resistors and all were within 0.25% of nominal - most within 0.1%. These are specified as 5% resistors.
I believe that they are the same thing, and "Triode Co." in Japan is just selling the KOA's at a premium price.
The KOA SPR series is not very common, but Mouser in the US carries a limited selection of the 2 watt parts.
Pete
I got some 8.2k KOA SPR2 resistors in Japan for 4 cents each. I just compared them to 8.2k 2W Kiwame resitors.
I cannot find any differences between them.
Both have non-magnetic leads and end caps, which look by eye to be the same material. Both appear identical externally, and also inside the green coating (which I scraped away with a knife).
I measured 20 pcs. of the KOA resistors and all were within 0.25% of nominal - most within 0.1%. These are specified as 5% resistors.
I believe that they are the same thing, and "Triode Co." in Japan is just selling the KOA's at a premium price.
The KOA SPR series is not very common, but Mouser in the US carries a limited selection of the 2 watt parts.
Pete
Pete,
THANK YOU!! Whatever Mouser stocks will save us from being gouged, at least some of the time.
Now, I wonder how good KOA-Speer low wattage Carbon film resistors are
THANK YOU!! Whatever Mouser stocks will save us from being gouged, at least some of the time.
Now, I wonder how good KOA-Speer low wattage Carbon film resistors are
/runs to go buy a fudgeload of resistors of various types
am I the only one that thinks someone could easily buy the KOA and pass them off as Kiwame, with significant profits? And that its possible someone is already doing it? Don't worry, you won't find me selling them on ebay. I'm too lazy for that.
however, if I can get significant savings doing it this way, no harm done, right? $0.16 versus $2 is worth it to me. I'll get some of the Kiwames just for comparison to hear for myself, but if it;s true, or close enough, then I'm one very happy dude.
...can anyone find cheaper Caddock and/or Rikens? Maybe some cheap Blackgates, Jensens, or any of the other good caps?
I'd not be too surprised if this sort of thing happens often...
am I the only one that thinks someone could easily buy the KOA and pass them off as Kiwame, with significant profits? And that its possible someone is already doing it? Don't worry, you won't find me selling them on ebay. I'm too lazy for that.
however, if I can get significant savings doing it this way, no harm done, right? $0.16 versus $2 is worth it to me. I'll get some of the Kiwames just for comparison to hear for myself, but if it;s true, or close enough, then I'm one very happy dude.
...can anyone find cheaper Caddock and/or Rikens? Maybe some cheap Blackgates, Jensens, or any of the other good caps?
I'd not be too surprised if this sort of thing happens often...
Hi, Pete-san
I fully agree with you. I found the data sheet of KOA SPR resistor
from KOA Germany Web site as below.
http://www.koaeurope.de/at/koa/pdf/spr(x).pdf
It clearly says SPR is Carbon and SPRX is metal film.
'73 de JA2DHC
I fully agree with you. I found the data sheet of KOA SPR resistor
from KOA Germany Web site as below.
http://www.koaeurope.de/at/koa/pdf/spr(x).pdf
It clearly says SPR is Carbon and SPRX is metal film.
'73 de JA2DHC
Thanks Pete,
Checked Mouser and they had the 1/2watts too. Was just about to order Kiwames when I saw this thread.
Thanks again!
Checked Mouser and they had the 1/2watts too. Was just about to order Kiwames when I saw this thread.
Thanks again!
kstagger said:
People have been afraid of depleting the stocks since september, or earlier (earliest I found a mention was from september on a different DIY site). I don't think we have to worry 😀
-J
defect9 said:
Suppose they will restock the values necessary - just the experience of buying NOS tubes makes you paranoid
- Status
- Not open for further replies.