According to a fellow I know, off-axis response can actually do wonders for a speakers' sound. (How exactly this is, I'm not quite sure. )
Can anyone reccomend some good mid-woofers, midranges, and tweeters with unusually good off-axis response?
Can anyone reccomend some good mid-woofers, midranges, and tweeters with unusually good off-axis response?
Hi,
Non-technical,
1. Off axis response doesn't determine quality. It is desirable when the listener is not in front of the speaker. Other times a detriment.
2. The smaller the driver, the better the dispersion.
3. The lower the frequency, the better the dispersion is naturally.
EDIT: Oops, I never answered your question. 🙂
Non-technical,
1. Off axis response doesn't determine quality. It is desirable when the listener is not in front of the speaker. Other times a detriment.
2. The smaller the driver, the better the dispersion.
3. The lower the frequency, the better the dispersion is naturally.
EDIT: Oops, I never answered your question. 🙂
It's not only the off-axis response of each separate driver you should look for.
The goal is a consistent off-axis/power response of the whole box, getting as close as possible to constant directivity (having a flat response at each angle off-axis). This means either omnidirectionality (same response in all directions) or a uniform fall-off as you go off-axis. Thus, drivers with a large dispersion are not necessarily always the best - it all depends on what you want to achieve and how you combine them.
It has been pointed out that true CD cannot be obtained with piston sources(cone/dome drivers). It is nevertheless important to try to get as close to that as possible.
The goal is a consistent off-axis/power response of the whole box, getting as close as possible to constant directivity (having a flat response at each angle off-axis). This means either omnidirectionality (same response in all directions) or a uniform fall-off as you go off-axis. Thus, drivers with a large dispersion are not necessarily always the best - it all depends on what you want to achieve and how you combine them.
It has been pointed out that true CD cannot be obtained with piston sources(cone/dome drivers). It is nevertheless important to try to get as close to that as possible.
I wonder how a dome midrange paired with a ribbon would sound. I guess we would have seen that quite often in the eighties if they had good and affordable ribbons at that time. But since dome midranges have gone with the wind you were probably one of the first to try.
There is a B&C cone midrange that has the best off axis response i have ever seen. cant find the model at the moment. 5 or 6" cone driver with a strange looking surround...very nice driver.
Zc
Zc
Driver with good off axis response will normally have bigger sweet spot. If you don't normally listen to music on one spot, good off axis will be something you looking for. However, top quality driver from Seas and SS don't have good off axis response. As always, there trade off.
Good 60D off axis with flat response driver is hard to find so far I only found these.
For midrange Seas 4in MCA11FC, if you can find it. For midbass, Peerless 4in 830854, 830870.
For tweeter, have a look at OWI and OWIV.
The best is download the catalog for each manufacturer from Madisound. If is easier to find what you looking for.
Have fun 😀
Good 60D off axis with flat response driver is hard to find so far I only found these.
For midrange Seas 4in MCA11FC, if you can find it. For midbass, Peerless 4in 830854, 830870.
For tweeter, have a look at OWI and OWIV.
The best is download the catalog for each manufacturer from Madisound. If is easier to find what you looking for.
Have fun 😀
You could also take a look at the drivers used by Linkwitz for the omnidirectional Pluto:
http://www.linkwitzlab.com/Pluto/construction.htm
It's a Peerless midwoofer and a Aura widerange.
http://www.linkwitzlab.com/Pluto/construction.htm
It's a Peerless midwoofer and a Aura widerange.
18Sound 6ND430:
http://www.eighteensound.com/index.aspx?mainMenu=view_product&pid=243
..Tilted response on-axis though. And I believe it was tough to find the 8 ohm version when I was searching for them, if I remember correctly. I was only able to find it in 16 ohms. Would probably make for a good MTM.
I agree with the statement regarding the Hiquphon 3/4" tweeters. Supposedly some of the best off-axis response to be had in a soft dome.
http://www.eighteensound.com/index.aspx?mainMenu=view_product&pid=243
..Tilted response on-axis though. And I believe it was tough to find the 8 ohm version when I was searching for them, if I remember correctly. I was only able to find it in 16 ohms. Would probably make for a good MTM.
I agree with the statement regarding the Hiquphon 3/4" tweeters. Supposedly some of the best off-axis response to be had in a soft dome.
- Status
- Not open for further replies.