ATC SM75-150 versus SM75-150S

Attachments

  • ATC SM75-150.jpg
    ATC SM75-150.jpg
    46.3 KB · Views: 604
  • ATC SM75-150S.jpg
    ATC SM75-150S.jpg
    47.8 KB · Views: 608

Rewind

Member
2009-01-18 7:42 pm
Oslo
That looks very similar. We could just cross the tweeter a little lower to get more detail in the lower highs. I don't know. :S



But where to find them for cheap?! On a students budget I will only afford one. Called ATC in the UK and they wanted ~300 pounds for it.

Oh, and ATC is keeping the S version to their own speakers now, I asked them on the phone. So this discussion is pretty fruitless.

I am planning to use my single, mono :( SM75-150 driver to build a ATC SCM50 clone to go with my Krell KSA-100 clone, of which none is of course completed. I happen to have the chinese made tweeters from the ATC SCM16A (still on ebay for $21: "atc tweeter") and a pair of unknown ATC PA75-260 STD 8 ohm (!). Not the -314. Not the -243. Not the -234. But a rare -260. I measued also. 255mm across. It likes to be between 250Hz and 900Hz. They are very revealing. I played it a long time before they loosened up a bit, or my stereo warmed up properly. I was scared the first two days and thought, "what a crappy speaker I bought!" We will see if I can decide on a cabinet for these rarities. 255mm is not 243mm across, like in the original SCM50.

I asked ATC and they didn't have anyone old enough to answer what they were. Does anyone here know? I need to know things like cabinets, and if the official scm50/100 crossover still works.

I know I am kinda hi-jacking the thread, but it is on the topic of using the SM75-150 in a sensible way. And since nobody can really buy the S version anymore we could just talk about my speaker project instead. ^^,
 
Last edited:

Rewind

Member
2009-01-18 7:42 pm
Oslo
Solen will sell you both version, but they are more expensive than direct buy from ATC.
I find the price quite right compared to compression drivers and horns...

True, true. Good compression drivers are equal in price. It is not like I have to buy the worlds best speaker more than once.


It is interesting that you mention compression drivers. Maybe the SM75-150 is considered to be a compression driver, but I am thinking more of TAD, JBL, BMS, etc, when I think of CDs. How would they fare against the SM75-150? The Avantgarde Trio is considered by many, not all, as one of the finest speaker in the world.