diyAudio

diyAudio (http://www.diyaudio.com/forums/)
-   Tubes / Valves (http://www.diyaudio.com/forums/tubes-valves/)
-   -   Stubborn Noise/Oscillation - Another Call for Help (http://www.diyaudio.com/forums/tubes-valves/209455-stubborn-noise-oscillation-another-call-help.html)

LinuksGuru 23rd March 2012 11:56 PM

Stubborn Noise/Oscillation - Another Call for Help
 
4 Attachment(s)
Hi, folks,

Having fought with that problem for a while, I decided its time to call for help.
Kingneb had similar problem, but with different amplifier and condition.

Looks like I have oscillation, around 100 KHz, 12 - 20 mV RMS. At first sight, it may be recognized as a noise, but it is NOT. And here is why.

1) Amplifier power is 60W, thus, RMS output voltage is 22V on 8 Ohm load. S/N ratio = =20*LOG(22/(20/1000)) = 60 dB. Clearly a problem. This kind of amplifier must have S/N ratio around 80 - 90 dB.

2) Distortions (jagged sine-wave) and instability (square wave) on small signal output (100 - 200mV).

3) Instability under certain circumstances (e.g. heavy overload), which leads to oscillation (seen as washed out sine-wave curve).

Amplifier under test loaded with 8 Ohm wire-wound resistor. Power supply is CLC: 200uF + 4H Choke + 200uF. All filament wires are twisted - in case of hum frequency of noise should 50 Hz, not 100 KHz. Input is shorted during measuring noise/oscillation.

On the original schematic there was optional C3/R10 (to suppress oscillation), it is installed.
Then, in order to improve square wave performance, I connected C21/R53, and removed C3/R10. It didn't help to get rid of oscillation. Changing GNFB with R2 trim potentiometer also helpless.
I even turned off LCD monitor and fluorescent lamp on my table, and shielded pre-driver 6N1P.

Original schematic used 6AQ8, 12BH7 and 6L6GC. I replaced these tubes with closest possible substitutes from my collection. Reverting back from 6N1P to 6AQ8 have no effect to oscillation.

Of course, its possible to connect zobel RC network to output terminals, and remove oscillation from oscilloscope, but this is not a real solution for tis problem.

Increasing supply voltage for pre-driver (shorting R31) leads to heavy 200 KHz oscillation, which can be only suppressed with reducing GNFB with trim potentiometer R2 (>= 1K). I have several different output transformers with CFB, 3.9K - 5K, with leakage inductance 8 ... 18 mH, problem the same. Output tubes biased at 60mA, tried Shuguang 6550 and Tung Sol KT120.

I'm attaching schematic and pictures for reference. Power transformer, rectifiers, HV/B+ CLC filter, BIAS C filter are not shown.

Thanks in advance for any suggestion(s).

Wavebourn 24th March 2012 12:18 AM

What about grid stoppers?

Also, are you sure that shorting R31 you increase anode voltage, or may be you decrease losses in ground loop?

avp1 24th March 2012 12:25 AM

First increase R1 to 10-15k. Then try 330pf and 10k between plates of VL2. Then 1000pf capacitor with 1.5k resistor from B1 to plates of each output tube.

Or disconnect global feedback and measure gain and phase shift from input to output in all range of frequencies from 20 Hz to 500 kHz and post results here.

LinuksGuru 24th March 2012 10:08 AM

Disconnected CFB (cathode feedback) winding. The same oscillation, 12 - 20mV on output terminals.

trobbins 24th March 2012 11:34 AM

Perhaps short R23 at it's location - just to check CFB is completely disconnected.

Is 6N1P shorted at the valve base, or some distance away?

LinuksGuru 24th March 2012 03:54 PM

3 Attachment(s)
Here is the update:
1) GNFB disconnected - oscillation continues.
2) CFB disconnected - oscillation continues.
3) 0.22 uF capacitor connected between B3 (6N6P HV supply) and GND - oscillation waveform slightly changes.
4) Grid stoppers for 6N6P - quite difficult to install, sockets are soldered on PCB.
5) Removed input pre-driver 6N1P from the socket - oscillation continues (slightly different waveform, but 12 - 24 mV, around 67 KHz).
6) Removed 6N6P from the socket - oscillation gone, output noise around 4mV.

For tests I used the worst output transformer I have with leakage inductance 18 uH. Replacing it with better (9 mH leakage inductance) don't kill oscillation anyway. If amp will work with worst trafo, it will work with better one for sure. This unit is very large (around 4.5 kg), so stray capacitance should also be high.

All data below with GNFB disconnected.
Input voltage around 184 - 200mV.

Frequency / Output voltage 8 Ohm
20 - 9.00
200 - 9.60
2,000 - 10.00
5,000 - 9.60
10,000 - 9.20
15,000 - 8.60
20,000 - 7.80
25,000 - 7.20
30,000 - 6.60
35,000 - 5.88
40,000 - 5.00

Below are pictures from 2-channel oscilloscope (2 KHz, 10 KHz, 20 KHz). Phase shift is clearly visible at 20 KHz, but it is not cause of oscillation because GNFB is disconnected.

avp1 24th March 2012 04:27 PM

Try to increase R24 to 3-4k. If oscillation continues after GNFB disconnected I suspect problem with feedback via power. Also you can try to run it without output tubes or with tubes closed by high bias. You need to see if there is any oscillation at the output of phase splitter.

LinuksGuru 24th March 2012 04:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by avp1 (Post 2958723)
If oscillation continues after GNFB disconnected I suspect problem with feedback via power.

Hmmm, how to to suppress it?

avp1 24th March 2012 04:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by LinuksGuru (Post 2958744)
Hmmm, how to to suppress it?

Rethink power filtering. But first you need to find a stage which oscillates. First exclude output one by closing tubes.

LinuksGuru 24th March 2012 05:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by avp1 (Post 2958751)
Rethink power filtering. But first you need to find a stage which oscillates. First exclude output one by closing tubes.

Thanks, avp1. I have reduced idle current of output tubes tenfold. Oscillation continues, down from 12 - 20 mV to 4 - 8 mV.


All times are GMT. The time now is 09:03 AM.


vBulletin Optimisation provided by vB Optimise (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2014 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.
Copyright 1999-2014 diyAudio


Content Relevant URLs by vBSEO 3.3.2