OPT choice for PP1C
I am still working on my PP1C, see:
Rundmaus at work - PP1C without sand - diyAudio
Now, here's another question to the diyaudio community, concerning the choice of output transformer:
The schematic suggests a 5k plate-to-plate transformer, and at first sight I thought a Lundahl LL1663 5k:8 Ohms would do. But with the winding ratio of 24:1 given in the Lundahl datasheet, this is merely 4.6k:8 - with the ratio being even worse when impedance variations (usually downwards) of the speakers are taken into account.
What do you think, is 4.6k:8 acceptable with the usual impedance variation 8 Ohm speakers produce?
Alternatively, one could use the LL1620, LL1623 with primary impedances of 5-6k, but the LL1663 is already 130 Euros and the larger ones are close to 200 Euros per piece. This is getting too expensive!
Alternatively, I have a transformer vendor who could custom-wind C-core output transformers - stock values are 6.6k:8 but different ratios are doable on request.
So the choices are:
1) Take the cheaper Lundahls and live with 4.6k:8 or worse.
2) Pay a lot of money for the multi-impedance Lundahls.
3) Get a custom-wound C-core OPT for half the price of the Lundahls, but with no experiences concerning quality. The power transformer bought there was very nice, but OPTs and their winding techniques are a different beast....
What do you think?
Allen recommended the LL1663/PP over other Lundahl OPTs. Allen claimed the Lundahl OPTs to better than Tamura.
I use the LL1663 myself and I'm most satiesfied.
Get'em all tell us your findings... ;-)
|All times are GMT. The time now is 12:42 PM.|
vBulletin Optimisation provided by vB Optimise (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2015 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.
Copyright ©1999-2015 diyAudio