Hi.
For the first time I’m going to build a tube preamp (ARC LS7 clone) and a tube power amp (ARC VT60 clone), and I intent to use top quality components.
I have no experience with sound quality and stability of power resistors (>0.5W) suitable for my project.
Can you recommend some types and marks?
Should I use deferent types of resistors depending on application in the circuit?
Thanks.
For the first time I’m going to build a tube preamp (ARC LS7 clone) and a tube power amp (ARC VT60 clone), and I intent to use top quality components.
I have no experience with sound quality and stability of power resistors (>0.5W) suitable for my project.
Can you recommend some types and marks?
Should I use deferent types of resistors depending on application in the circuit?
Thanks.
For 3W to 14W (more power with parallel pairs), try Vitreous Enamel wirewound. Welwyn W21, W22, W23 & W24 are a good series. These are used by designer Tim de Paravicini, in the EAR professional product range - in anode and cathode circuit positions.
Also, they are not expensive, so you can buy a few and try the sound for yourself! Be sure to run them at only 1/2 or 1/3 of the rated power, to get good sound.
Produktsøgning | Farnell Danmark
Also, they are not expensive, so you can buy a few and try the sound for yourself! Be sure to run them at only 1/2 or 1/3 of the rated power, to get good sound.
Produktsøgning | Farnell Danmark
Dav,
I haven't noticed any difference between brands in terms of sound quality. However, note that power resistors are designed to run HOT. As in 250 deg C at max power dissipation. To me, that's too hot for comfort so I tend to run power resistors at somewhere around 1/5~1/3 of their max rating. That keeps them to 65~100 deg C with 20 C ambient.
I tend to default to Vishay-Dale as they're usually the least expensive. I haven't had any issues with drift, but I haven't run an accelerated life-time test either... In my recent power supply design, the voltages were within 0.1 % of their initial value even after a couple of hours of burn-in. The output voltage was linearly dependent on the resistance of a 5 W power resistor (classic LM317-based "Maida regulator").
I'm sure Vejle RC Elektronik and/or Aarhus Radio Lager will be able to help you out with mail order parts if you don't have a local electronic components pusher.
~Tom
I haven't noticed any difference between brands in terms of sound quality. However, note that power resistors are designed to run HOT. As in 250 deg C at max power dissipation. To me, that's too hot for comfort so I tend to run power resistors at somewhere around 1/5~1/3 of their max rating. That keeps them to 65~100 deg C with 20 C ambient.
I tend to default to Vishay-Dale as they're usually the least expensive. I haven't had any issues with drift, but I haven't run an accelerated life-time test either... In my recent power supply design, the voltages were within 0.1 % of their initial value even after a couple of hours of burn-in. The output voltage was linearly dependent on the resistance of a 5 W power resistor (classic LM317-based "Maida regulator").
I'm sure Vejle RC Elektronik and/or Aarhus Radio Lager will be able to help you out with mail order parts if you don't have a local electronic components pusher.
~Tom
Last edited:
- Status
- This old topic is closed. If you want to reopen this topic, contact a moderator using the "Report Post" button.