First a question:
I have a set of high efficiency speakers. They have an MSRP of $6500, and I've been using them with a handful of VERY cheap amplifiers. As in under $200. I've been into audio for twenty years, and I've never heard an audible improvement between amplifiers, interconnects, or speaker wire. I have owned three tube amps. The first tube amp I bought was audibly inferior to a cheap solid state amp, the bass was really bloated. The second that I purchased was clean, but didn't sound any better than a solid state. And it broke down. The third tube amp I bought was for my headphones. It *did* sound really nice, better than the other two. But I had nothing to compare it to; it's the only headphone amp I've ever owned.
The other day I noticed an Adcom GFA-555 II at a pawn shop, and I was thinking about buying it. As I noted, I've never heard an audible improvement from replacing an amp, but using a $150 amplifier with a set of $6500 speakers IS a bit ridiculous.
On a whim, I hooked up the headphone amp to my high efficiency speakers.
Oh sh!t, why did I do that? Now I'm totally screwed. It transformed the speakers.
And I don't mean that I sat there listening for four hours, and thought that there was a subtle improvement. I sat down for 30 seconds, everything sounded different, and I literally got up off the couch and started checking wires. I thought for sure I must have plugged in something wrong. I spent ten minutes changing the polarity on the speakers, double checking that the RCA plugs were firmly seated, checked the gains on the output, etc...
This sounded completely different.
So...
Will I blow up my headphone amp doing this?
It's an Antique Sound Labs MG-SI15DT. I've heard that it's a clone of the Decware Zen amp. It puts out 0.15 watts into 10 ohms. Admittedly, that's a ridiculously small amp, but my speakers have an efficiency of 104db. So it's no different than using a 5 watt amplifier with speakers that have an efficiency of 89db.
Here's the amp:
http://www.tubehifi.com/amp/amp/mgheaddt.html
And the speakers that it's powering:
http://www.ai-audio.com/products_esp15.html
I have a set of high efficiency speakers. They have an MSRP of $6500, and I've been using them with a handful of VERY cheap amplifiers. As in under $200. I've been into audio for twenty years, and I've never heard an audible improvement between amplifiers, interconnects, or speaker wire. I have owned three tube amps. The first tube amp I bought was audibly inferior to a cheap solid state amp, the bass was really bloated. The second that I purchased was clean, but didn't sound any better than a solid state. And it broke down. The third tube amp I bought was for my headphones. It *did* sound really nice, better than the other two. But I had nothing to compare it to; it's the only headphone amp I've ever owned.
The other day I noticed an Adcom GFA-555 II at a pawn shop, and I was thinking about buying it. As I noted, I've never heard an audible improvement from replacing an amp, but using a $150 amplifier with a set of $6500 speakers IS a bit ridiculous.
On a whim, I hooked up the headphone amp to my high efficiency speakers.
Oh sh!t, why did I do that? Now I'm totally screwed. It transformed the speakers.
And I don't mean that I sat there listening for four hours, and thought that there was a subtle improvement. I sat down for 30 seconds, everything sounded different, and I literally got up off the couch and started checking wires. I thought for sure I must have plugged in something wrong. I spent ten minutes changing the polarity on the speakers, double checking that the RCA plugs were firmly seated, checked the gains on the output, etc...
This sounded completely different.
So...
Will I blow up my headphone amp doing this?
It's an Antique Sound Labs MG-SI15DT. I've heard that it's a clone of the Decware Zen amp. It puts out 0.15 watts into 10 ohms. Admittedly, that's a ridiculously small amp, but my speakers have an efficiency of 104db. So it's no different than using a 5 watt amplifier with speakers that have an efficiency of 89db.
Here's the amp:
http://www.tubehifi.com/amp/amp/mgheaddt.html
And the speakers that it's powering:
http://www.ai-audio.com/products_esp15.html
hard to say, but at a nominal 8 ohms, you can be sure the impedance of the speaker dips pretty dramatically at some point. If your amp is designed for 10 ohm headphones (which typically are less inclined to wild swings of impedance) you MAY have an issue in the long term. Meantime, try and figure out what it is about the sound that you are enjoying!
Are you using the amp in triode or pentode mode? Searching the model bring up lots of favorable write-ups. Looking at: http://www.affordableaudio.org/ASL-MG-SI-15-DT.pdf it seems your doing nothing wrong or damaging. Enjoy!
That was the first amp I bought from ASL. Really sounded terrible. Loose tubby bass, and it broke after less than a month of use.
Sold it on Ebay.
The one I'm listening to at the moment is their *headphone* amp... with a set of Summas.
You get what you pay for. In the first case, I'd guess the design was open loop pentode final. Probably something like a SE 50C5 running open loop. That'll really sound hideous. The second amp: probably a Big Box offering: too much gNFB, poor open loop deisgn. Of course, it'll sound just like a SS amp. Now, I've done solid state designs that come very close, but they aren't there yet, and hollow state sounds better. Of course, I design 'em right.
As for that headphone amp, I'd be more worried about poofing the $6,500 speeks, especially if it's an OTL design that might put voice coil destroying DC offsets through them.
This may be an output impedience issue. A typical amp ment to drive 4 or 8 ohm speakers will typicaly have an output impedience of ~.1 ohm if it's solid
state or maby ~3 ohms for a single ended tube amp don't hold me to these
figures. Your headphone amp says it has either a 10 or 600 ohm output impedience. If it realy have a 10 ohm output impedience this can alter
the frequency responce of the speaker. You might try one of your solid state
amps again but this time with a 8 ohm resistor in seriese with the speaker cables. If this helps you might also look at the Pass F2 amp.
state or maby ~3 ohms for a single ended tube amp don't hold me to these
figures. Your headphone amp says it has either a 10 or 600 ohm output impedience. If it realy have a 10 ohm output impedience this can alter
the frequency responce of the speaker. You might try one of your solid state
amps again but this time with a 8 ohm resistor in seriese with the speaker cables. If this helps you might also look at the Pass F2 amp.
Here's the circuit. I don't know enough about amps to comment much. It uses the same tubes as the Decware Zen (6BQ5 instead of EL84). There have been a few articles noting that Antique Sound Lab is in the habit of cloning other brands designs...
An externally hosted image should be here but it was not working when we last tested it.
Last edited:
There appears to be major differences between the two circuits. The Zen uses 6N1P/6922/6DJ8 instead of the 12AX7 in the HEAD-DT.
BTW, 6BQ5 and EL84 are the same tube.
Jeff
Last edited:
Have you considered using a SS power amp with a good tube pre-amp? The SS amp will give you the bass maybe you're looking for and the tubes will give the sweet vocals and highs.
When I swapped out my Carver SS pre-amp for an Aikido (and various other tube pre-amp designs I've tried) , made a massive improvement when hooked up to my SS Carver Power amp.
When I swapped out my Carver SS pre-amp for an Aikido (and various other tube pre-amp designs I've tried) , made a massive improvement when hooked up to my SS Carver Power amp.
- Status
- This old topic is closed. If you want to reopen this topic, contact a moderator using the "Report Post" button.