Why is distortion harmonic?
 User Name Stay logged in? Password
 Home Forums Rules Articles diyAudio Store Blogs Gallery Wiki Register Donations FAQ Calendar Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read Search

 Tubes / Valves All about our sweet vacuum tubes :) Threads about Musical Instrument Amps of all kinds should be in the Instruments & Amps forum

 Please consider donating to help us continue to serve you. Ads on/off / Custom Title / More PMs / More album space / Advanced printing & mass image saving
 10th March 2008, 06:01 PM #11 Wavebourn   Designer & Technologist diyAudio Member     Join Date: Sep 2006 Location: Pleasant Hill, CA Fourier found that any periodic function may be represented by multiple sine functions. However, is the signal is modulated by noise (that happens always because all electronics is non-linear and generate a noise) there are non-harmonic distortions generated, but their level is the less the better is linearity and the lower is the noise. __________________ The Devil is not so terrible as his math model is!
Jim McShane
diyAudio Member

Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: Southwest Chicago Suburbs
Quote:
 Originally posted by Wavebourn Fourier found that any periodic function may be represented by multiple sine functions. However, is the signal is modulated by noise (that happens always because all electronics is non-linear and generate a noise) there are non-harmonic distortions generated, but their level is the less the better is linearity and the lower is the noise.

I'm not sure if you were responding to my post above, but it seems like it.

To say that all electronics are non-linear and generate noise is two different statements and conditions. The non-linearity does not necessarily occur as a result of the noise, nor does the noise necessarily occur as a result of the non-linearity.

I am not a math major, by any means! But as I understand the math if I take a perfect sine wave at a single frequency (say 1KHz) and pass it through a non-linear but noiseless device (if there was such a thing), I will still get harmonic distortion due to nonlinearity. The perfect sine wave will no longer be perfect due to the device's nonlinearity, harmonics will be generated, and those harmonics by definition will be multiples of the 1KHz fundamental.

So I'm trying to figure out what Tubelab meant with his statement that all the bad stuff happens at 1K - the math says that can't be. I was seeking clarification about what he meant.

Miles Prower
diyAudio Member

Join Date: May 2005
Location: USA
Re: Why is distortion harmonic?

Quote:
 Originally posted by dsavitsk When you put a 1KHz wave through an amp, for instance, you get 1KHz, 2KHz, 3KHz, ... etc. harmonic distortion components at the output. But, why aren't there non-harmonic components, 1.3KHz for instance?
First off, not all distortion is harmonic. If you were to modulate a SSB xmtr with a signal that had these components: 1.0KHz, 2.0KHz, 4.0KHz, 6.0KHz, you would create a radio wave where the carrier frequency was either added to those baseband frequencies (upper sideband) or subtracted from the carrier (lower sideband). If the xcvr's BFO was running at the wrong frequency, let's say it was off by 10Hz, you could get a baseband with these frequencies: 1010Hz, 2010Hz, 4010Hz, 6010Hz. Those are not harmonically related. The fact that SSB demod depends on a free running BFO that is neither frequency nor phase locked to the original carrier is what accounts for the unique sound of SSB. You also get the same distortion with a doubly balanced detector receiving AM since the DBM nulls out both the BFO and the RF carrier.

Other processes, such as aliasing during analog-to-digital conversion, intermodulation, and frequency division aren't harmonically related either.

As for why most distortion is harmonic, consider this: for musical instruments, the taught wires, or vibrating air columns, have one fundamental, and a series of stable arrangements of nodes and antinodes. These are all harmonically related. (The only exception here would be a drum head, which has a much more complex set of nodes and antinodes that can produce nonharmonic vibrations.) Electronic circuits, whether lumped or distributed, share the same property as physical resonant elements. Even if resonance doesn't play a part, every sort of nonlinear transfer function will generate harmonics, barring some other more complex phenomenon. Fourier analysis will demonstrate this.
__________________
There are no foxes in atheistholes
www.dolphin-hsl.com

 10th March 2008, 06:47 PM #14 PigletsDad   diyAudio Member     Join Date: Jul 2007 Location: South Worcestershire The key question in thinking about this is whether the behaviour of the circuit is time dependent. If it is independent of time, any distortion effects must be the same for each cycle. The output waveform will be the same for every cycle, and if we fourier analyse this we find that all the distortion will be harmonic. Time dependent effects can easily result in the output varying from cycle to cycle, giving rise to non-harmonic components. A simple example is intermodulation with 100Hz (or 120Hz in the US) components from the power supply. This is often seen in power amps on the verge of clipping. The spectrum will show the usual high order (probably mostly odd) harmonics, and sidebands either side of the fundamental. More complex cases involve circuits which have some sort of nonlinear memory effect, which can give subharmonics. There are even circuits known that show a progression into chaotic behaviour as an appropriate variable like input amplitude is varied; an example of this is a resonator containing a nonlinear element, driven by an external sine wave. So the answer to the OP question is that distortion is not always purely harmonic, if the circuit has time dependent behaviour.
Tubelab_com
diyAudio Member

Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: West Virginia panhandle
Quote:
 So I'm trying to figure out what Tubelab meant with his statement that all the bad stuff happens at 1K - the math says that can't be. I was seeking clarification about what he meant.
What I was trying to say is that a distorted 1KHz sine wave will create "stuff" at 1KHz and its integer multiples. I was thinking faster than I was typing and a few thoughts did not get translated into words.

Fourier states that any repettitive signal can be represented by a series of summed sine waves. In theory a 1KHz tone distorted through an amplifier can only create 1KHz and its integer multiples. This represents harmonic distortion. Here the "bad stuff" happens at a 1KHz (and its multiples) rate. There are distortions that do not happen at the fundamental (or its harmonics) rate.

You will not get 1.3KHz out of a distorted 1KHz sine wave unless some other signal is present. It is possible for 300 Hz and 1KHz to be applied to the same amplifier simultaneously to create 1.3 KHz through intermodulation distortion. (the SSB analogy presented above). It is possible for 100 Hz and 1KHz to enter an amplifier and have 1.3 KHz come out if harmonic distortion and intermodulation distortion are both present. It is possible under some conditions for the second signal to be created inside the amplifier.

I have seen cases where 1KHz goes into an amplifier and some unrelated tones come out. The usual cause here is oscillation (and IMD). When an amplifier is oscillating at an ultrasonic rate the oscillation is rarely a prefect sine wave. It may have harmonics and noise associated with it that gets mixed in with the intended signal creating a broad spectrum of low level spurious signals.

Quote:
 So the answer to the OP question is that distortion is not always purely harmonic, if the circuit has time dependent behaviour.
I have seen an amplifier overdriven by a 1KHz tone produce frequencies below 1KHz. Fourier says this can't happen, but it does. The usual culprit is blocking distortion. If the time constant is small enough (guitar amps) it is possible to drive the output stage into cutoff so that only every second (or third, fourth, etc.) peak of the sine wave makes it through to the speaker. There is a secondary signal being created by the output stage turning on and off at a rate slower than the input signal. With a radically unbalanced push pull amp operating in this manner some really unusual "stuff" can be created. Blocking distortion and power supply sag together can create some unusual sounding distortion, often at a subharmonic of the input signal.
__________________
Tubelab, it's 5 year mission. To explore strange new tubes, to seek out new circuits and topologies, to boldly go where no tube has gone before......

Wavebourn
Designer & Technologist
diyAudio Member

Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: Pleasant Hill, CA
Quote:
 Originally posted by Jim McShane I'm not sure if you were responding to my post above, but it seems like it. To say that all electronics are non-linear and generate noise is two different statements and conditions. The non-linearity does not necessarily occur as a result of the noise, nor does the noise necessarily occur as a result of the non-linearity. I am not a math major, by any means! But as I understand the math if I take a perfect sine wave at a single frequency (say 1KHz) and pass it through a non-linear but noiseless device (if there was such a thing), I will still get harmonic distortion due to nonlinearity. The perfect sine wave will no longer be perfect due to the device's nonlinearity, harmonics will be generated, and those harmonics by definition will be multiples of the 1KHz fundamental. So I'm trying to figure out what Tubelab meant with his statement that all the bad stuff happens at 1K - the math says that can't be. I was seeking clarification about what he meant.

I was responding to the original question. If common practice of measurement of distortions is to measure harmonic distortions it does not mean that only they exist. Harmonic distortions are easy to measure in order to compare amplifiers. But such measurements have to be weighted against human perceptions that has no standard defined yet.

__________________
The Devil is not so terrible as his math model is!

 10th March 2008, 09:49 PM #17 AuroraB   diyAudio Member     Join Date: May 2001 Location: Norway, -north of the moral circle.. Hi, guys......Sorry, but some of you are making a terrible mess out of something that's relatively simple from a math POV, although the math may seem hairy for some. I'll also state clearly that I have no intentions of being condecending here- I've been teaching radio theory at polytecnic level for several years, and seen quite alot of students struggling with this..... Harmonic and intermodulation are the two sides of the same coin - harmonic distortion is a single frequency item - injecting F1 results if F1+n x F1, where n is an integer. Intermodulatioin is usually described with two frequencies - F1 and F2, resulting in intermodulation products ( n x F1 +- m x F2). Ex. above with 100Hz and 1000Hz gives 900,1100,1900,2100,1200, 800, 1800, and so on, all depending on the nonlinearites in the transfer function. The optimum transfer function is Aout=k x sin(wt), where k is your amplification factor -graphically displayed as a straight line where the rise angle coefficient is the Amp factor. The problems arise when the curve deviates from the straight line, introducing higher order factors - sin^2, sin^3 and so on. These are the factors responsible for the higher order distortion products. If only sin^2 were present, there would only be 1 order products 2 x F1 and F1 +- 2 x F2. The reference to SSB modulation, in essence AM and all its derivates, ( SSB being one of them), is a situation where you strive to achieve a perfectly quadratic transfer function based on sin^2. In the frequency mixer circuits used for this purpose, one actually uses purposely developed diodes wiith a well controlled dforward current to optimize the 2nd order behaviour - nothing but well controlled IMD. Mingling these processes with clipping, noise, oscillation etc. is trying to describe the interaction of highly different processes - truly a daunting task from a theoreticacl POV.
Tubelab_com
diyAudio Member

Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: West Virginia panhandle
Quote:
 Mingling these processes with clipping, noise, oscillation etc. is trying to describe the interaction of highly different processes - truly a daunting task from a theoreticacl POV.
I understand the math, and I understand what happens in a real world circuit, even when operated in unreal conditions (a guitar amp with worn mismatched tubes driven into severe clipping). Trying to explain it all in a simplified manner is difficult.
__________________
Tubelab, it's 5 year mission. To explore strange new tubes, to seek out new circuits and topologies, to boldly go where no tube has gone before......

jan.didden
diyAudio Member

Join Date: May 2002
Location: The great city of Turnhout, BE
Quote:
 Originally posted by Wavebourn [snip]If common practice of measurement of distortions is to measure harmonic distortions it does not mean that only they exist. [snip]

It is absolutely a fact that no others exist. If they would exist, you would see them on the spectrum, simple as that.

You are correct that we don't know exactly how we (our ear/brain system) reacts to distortion. But that's another unrelated kettle of fish, of course.

Jan Didden
__________________
Music is dither to the brain; lets me think below the usual chaos - me
Linear Audio Vol 13 is out! Check out my Autoranger and SilentSwitcher

 10th March 2008, 10:23 PM #20 AuroraB   diyAudio Member     Join Date: May 2001 Location: Norway, -north of the moral circle.. As to the above... Noise is stocastic in nature - i.e non predictable vs. time. That's the reasons we use pink noise as a test signal, as pink noise has a constant energy content pr. octave ( or parts of an octave), but it's frequency is impossible to predict in absolute time. Thus room resonances and reflections are not excited ( mostly..). As such, mixing a fixed frq. AND noise is an interesting thought - giving the possible production of all sorts of IM products - i.e. .all frequencies, but this requires the noise to have a significant amplitude - which we don't want, do we? Somewhat like listening to music frrom a weak shortwave station -- all hiss and whistles - and maybe some music.......... EDIT : An overdriven, worn down guitar amp may be an interesting case for its function - creating strange guitar sounds ( and I'm actally currently planning one for my son) , but this has little relevance in HiFi - and I wouldn't even dream of trying to describe one in math terms

 Posting Rules You may not post new threads You may not post replies You may not post attachments You may not edit your posts BB code is On Smilies are On [IMG] code is On HTML code is Off Forum Rules
 Forum Jump User Control Panel Private Messages Subscriptions Who's Online Search Forums Forums Home Site     Site Announcements     Forum Problems Amplifiers     Solid State     Pass Labs     Tubes / Valves     Chip Amps     Class D     Power Supplies     Headphone Systems Source & Line     Analogue Source     Analog Line Level     Digital Source     Digital Line Level     PC Based Loudspeakers     Multi-Way     Full Range     Subwoofers     Planars & Exotics Live Sound     PA Systems     Instruments and Amps Design & Build     Parts     Equipment & Tools     Construction Tips     Software Tools General Interest     Car Audio     diyAudio.com Articles     Music     Everything Else Member Areas     Introductions     The Lounge     Clubs & Events     In Memoriam The Moving Image Commercial Sector     Swap Meet     Group Buys     The diyAudio Store     Vendor Forums         Vendor's Bazaar         Sonic Craft         Apex Jr         Audio Sector         Acoustic Fun         Chipamp         DIY HiFi Supply         Elekit         Elektor         Mains Cables R Us         Parts Connexion         Planet 10 hifi         Quanghao Audio Design         Siliconray Online Electronics Store         Tubelab     Manufacturers         AKSA         Audio Poutine         Musicaltech         Aussie Amplifiers         CSS         exaDevices         Feastrex         GedLee         Head 'n' HiFi - Walter         Heatsink USA         miniDSP         SITO Audio         Twin Audio         Twisted Pear         Wild Burro Audio

 Similar Threads Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post JimOfOakCreek Planars & Exotics 2 20th April 2008 04:04 AM owdi Multi-Way 42 23rd February 2007 12:09 AM owdi Multi-Way 0 26th April 2006 03:55 PM tenderland Tubes / Valves 5 5th August 2004 11:29 AM JMB Multi-Way 0 20th July 2004 02:54 PM

 New To Site? Need Help?

All times are GMT. The time now is 04:44 AM.