Slewmaster - CFA vs. VFA "Rumble"

Thanks Terry. I don't know enough to understand what advantage a digital scope would have over analog. The model you have it seems there are lots of them at surplus prices. I see them from $150.00 to $350.00. There was one that was never used and they were asking $1,200 for that one. Since I am only just starting I'm sure it will be more than adequate for my audio needs.

ps. I guess if you are looking for oscillations at extreme frequencies a higher speed may come in handy but how high is that? What is the max bandwidth we are looking at in an audio application?
 
Last edited:
You will need to ask someone who has a digital scope. I see screen shots that show all kinds of information. My scope just shows the sine wave.

We can only hear, 20khz. My signal generator only goes to 150khz. I guess some folks measure all the way up to 200khz. 1mhz is 1000khz. So 200mhz is more than enough AFAICS.
 
Thanks again Terry. Yes I have seen Ghz scopes but since I'm not going to do RF design or anything exotic so not so sure what advantage those would be for anything we are doing. I'll look and see if I can see what a digital scope does that you can't do with an analog scope.
 
A digital scope is nice for getting some measurements displayed as text on the screen with the trace rather than reading off a graticule. An analog scope is still nice in many cases, especially if there is some HF noise / interference; that can make a digital scope display get kinda hairy where in analog scope just blurs a little. I had both (my analog scope died recently, replaced with an inexpensive PC scope) but I generally use my digital Tektronix most of the time anyway.
 
There is a way using 3 resistors to adjust the Symasym LTP current without disturbing VAS bias level.

I would only use this in a prototype to establish the optimal operating point, and then remove it, because it may worsen PSRR.
 

Attachments

  • Symasym-LTP-bias-trim.png
    Symasym-LTP-bias-trim.png
    22 KB · Views: 424
I guess if you are looking for oscillations at extreme frequencies a higher speed may come in handy but how high is that? What is the max bandwidth we are looking at in an audio application?

The worst case oscillations I had measured were 250MHz (preamplifier output diamond buffer) with harmonics up to 1GHz. I needed Agilent spectrum analyzer to reveal it. And yes, it matters for audio, it worsened S/N and increased distortion.
 
Thanks Pavel,
I'm afraid that a Ghz scope would more than likely be out of my budget for now, But that is very good information and I will remember that. Hopefully I won't have to look for a problem like that using other proven amplifier circuits rather than my own creations!
 
The worst case oscillations I had measured were 250MHz (preamplifier output diamond buffer) with harmonics up to 1GHz. I needed Agilent spectrum analyzer to reveal it. And yes, it matters for audio, it worsened S/N and increased distortion.

On a BJT ? Would not Ft be the limiting factor.

I know of some devices that would ..... RF Transistor, 30V, 300mA, fT=3.5GHz, NPN Single PCP -

But would this hold true for "our" lowly <120mhz Ft BJT's ?

OS
 
I must say I have enjoyed having this scope. Being a novice, I have very limited experience, so being able to post pictures of what is happening with my amp has been vital to getting good advice from the experts who hang out here. I learn things also that I didn't understand for instance just recently here I learned that my DMM doesn't read AC voltage correctly at high hz. The scope shows the true voltage of a square wave at 100Mhz and the DMM show a pittance of it. I have been burning zobel resistors because I didn't know that. Definitely get a scope. It will make this hobby much more enjoyable.

Blessings, Terry
 
Thought I would share my experience this morning. I ordered a couple PSU units from ebay so I could make two identical power supplies for the A/B Slewmaster setup I trying to put together.
4 10000uF 100V High End Power Amplifier Board | eBay
Received them yesterday so I hooked them up one at a time to test them. I hooked them using my light bulb tester just in case. On one of the units the light continued to burn dimly so I felt the caps and one of them was warm. I figured it may need to be reformed so I hooked up a separate bridge and used a 27K resistor and let it charge over night. This morning, I checked it again and the resistor was still discharging about 6V. I tried hooking up the PSU normally and the cap still got warm so I shut it down and discharged it. Then I hooked up the second unit and turned it on. I kept feeling the caps and they were all cool so I decided to let it run for a while and see how it did. Well after about 5 or 10 minutes one of the caps exploded. Fortunately I was a few feet away. I hate to think what might have happened if I was standing right there staring at it. I am attaching some pics for your enjoyment.

Blessings, Terry
 

Attachments

  • blown capacitor.jpg
    blown capacitor.jpg
    705.2 KB · Views: 468
  • ebay psu1.jpg
    ebay psu1.jpg
    382.6 KB · Views: 442
  • ebay psu2.jpg
    ebay psu2.jpg
    371 KB · Views: 433
Last edited: