Is using a high-end op amp for gain stage an acceptable practice in an ultra-high-end amplifier ?
is the practice mostly avoided out of snobbery or are there actual downsides ?
if there are downsides are these subjective or measured ?
also if ther are downsides how can we explain what causes them ?
is the practice mostly avoided out of snobbery or are there actual downsides ?
if there are downsides are these subjective or measured ?
also if ther are downsides how can we explain what causes them ?
Burning questions!They have no answers I'm afraid. It's like discussing religion or politics.
you know what they say in the military - bad decision is better than no decision
and what does that tell us ?
what is more things in signal path - 1 op amp or a bunch of transistors ?
An op amp basically consits of a bunch of transistors and each of them can introduce noise... I think an op amp as a chip will introduce less noise than an op amp consisting of the same number of transistors.
I just re-read my post and noticed I messed up that sentence. I wanted to say:
"My theory is, that one should try to use only as few things in the way from the source to the power amp as possible. "
I just re-read my post and noticed I messed up that sentence. I wanted to say:
"My theory is, that one should try to use only as few things in the way from the source to the power amp as possible. "
well op-amps do use tons of NFB ...
but can anybody actually hear the sound of an individual op-amp ?
i mean can anybody reliably tell an op amp ( with gain set to zero ) from straight wire in double blind testing ?
I don't know. I think I should give it a try on my gainclone with some op amps I have around.
Its not always the op amp that messes with the sound.
Input and output capacitors filter the sound.
There is noise in the resistors.
It depends on the type of resistor.
Carbon film tend to be more noisy than metal film.
I believe its called Johnson noise.
Thanks, I'll feed google with "Johnson noise" now and have a read.
Edit: YAY! http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Johnson–Nyquist_noise
Edit: YAY! http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Johnson–Nyquist_noise
Bearing in mind that we are on a DIY forum then the answer is yes, if it meets the requirements of the designer.
Who said it is mostly avoided?
How would you define a high-end op amp?
And what is the differences between high-end an an ultra high-end?
Yes, IMHO use of quality (not necessarily the most exotic or expensive) op-amps are expected in a high-quality amplifier.
Now IC op-amps, being integrated circuits (ICs) do have limited current and thus power handling capacity, so they typically need to combined with discrete devices (i.e. transistors) for the current and power amplification stage(s) of the signal chain.
There are also discrete op-amp circuits, which can be used to meet a particular set of requirements. Typically IC op-amps combined with a discrete current / power amplification output stage meets most needs.
I think the downside include the lack of mystic (hence pricing premium) for some designers or perhaps they should be called marketers, of the sort who promote and sell more about the audiophile "perception" or snobbery rather than performance.
Other than the current / power handling limitations of IC op-amps, I am not aware of any measurable quality or characteristic that an IC op-amp is inferior compared with discrete components (solid state or electron tube).
One special application where the usage of electron tubes (vacuum tubes / valves) is in electric guitar amplifiers, where the additional distortion of even harmonics may be desirable sonic quality. I believe that even harmonic distortion is considered more pleasuring the human ear, compared to odd harmonics generated from distortion in solid state components.
In terms of transistor matching, I believe (from memory, so don't quote me on it) IC op-amps may be as much as 10-100 times better matching than discrete matched transistors (e.g. LM394) . I believe this is because performance of ICs has demanded continued research in improving the quality of IC manufacturing process so as to turn out higher performance (higher speed digital clocks, faster / wider bandwidth op-amps, higher performance DACs and ADCs) ICs that are a competitive advantage.
Perhaps one downside amongst amateurs is that IC op-amps do require care and modest amount of complexity in circuit design and construction that may not be necessary or the same techniques as found in other circuit designs.
- Status
- This old topic is closed. If you want to reopen this topic, contact a moderator using the "Report Post" button.